Is infidelity progressive? (DT Note pg. 5) - Page 4

Created

Last reply

Replies

39

Views

5k

Users

20

Likes

156

Frequent Posters

Alohomora_ thumbnail
10th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail
Posted: 7 years ago
#31

Originally posted by: -Medico-

Probably like you were judging people as insensitive using your OWN moral compass 😉

So you admit now that you were indeed judgemental? 😃 I nowhere claimed to be non judgemental while doing so but you kept repeating you are not at all judging people here !. Big difference there! You might as well admit you are judgemental and we can be done with this debate 😉
Edited by Alohomora_ - 7 years ago
Girl_InMedicine thumbnail
9th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 7 years ago
#32

Originally posted by: Alohomora_


So you admit now that you were indeed judgemental?😃I nowhere claimed to be non judgemental while doing so but you kept repeating you are not at all judging people again and again. Big difference there! You might as well admit you are judgemental and we can be done with this debate😉

You can never move in life without judging anything but being judgemental means judging someone without proper knowledge of the situation they are in. It's again pretty subjective 😆
Girl_InMedicine thumbnail
9th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 7 years ago
#33

Originally posted by: Twenty1st


Is
infidelity progressive?


The
answer to that question would be NO, but hasn't the concept of infidelity lived
with us for centuries. My ex-neighbour has been with his wife and his partner for
donkey years. In Egypt I bhabi found a couple holidaying, he who's a married
man and a father of 3 and she a single girl, so bhabi comes home and
generalises the whole town as being flip-mongers lol. But that's the reality,
sad and frustrating. I doubt they were influenced by a show to be exact.



However TV's
have shown it for years, haven't the male leads always wavered to some other
female before realising their mistake and coming to their wife. So why can't a
female represent the same case even if she's the main lead?



My
questions above does not in any way mean I ship KuNan, that is probably the
only ship I ain't sailing (lol), I like Nan-Mau even DD-Abhi. Maybe in the future,
but right now I don't see how I would accept them as a couple. Because makers
have already made Mau-Kun a perfect couple for me and YES I AM A DD Fan since
GEET days



I am one
of the countless Angelina and Brad fan (more Ange tbh and now that they are
over, I've tossed Brad like a leaf out my interest zone), but weren't they
accepted as a whole. Just because you watch, like or ship a couple that comes
out of infidelity does make you any less or more of a person? It's a modern era,
things (though unfortunate and morally wrong) does happen? Partners do separate
due to this reason.



At first
I too was hunting for excuses, shows and books I've watched/read always suggest
something must have happened, usually it's the woman neglecting her husband which
I feel is rather shallow and feeble of an excuse and yet they showed it here
with that other guy who ends up cursing Mauli, so hence now I am watching the
show as it is.



If you
haven't watched the show, and made the basis of your views on the promos and
y'day epi alone then I advise you to give it a shot because as of yet they
haven't shown anything to harm the morals or ethics, rather to showcase two
beautiful women (Mauli and Nandini), one very loving and caring (at times for
me too caring) and Nandini (a victim of domestic violence which hasn't been
shown on telly much, well not that I've watched, though that's another thing
that I don't watch too much Indian shows, solely DD unless something else
catches my eyes).



Anyway
neither do I object to KuNan shipping and nor do I belong to that list, at least
not until I know why and how they fall for each other?



I think
the main problem is people are watching the show with the EMA baggage, let it loose
and maybe they would be able to enjoy the show for what it actually is, it is
an incredibly well put-out and has the most amazing cast. I haven't watched Mauli
or Kunal before so they are new findings.



I see
this story more about 2 friends, and the becoming of a strong individual in
terms of Nandini.



Anyway
thank you for the topic, and I hope I have answered your question.


Thank you for such a well put reply!
I was expecting this kind of discussion without putting down others 😳
Sir-Please thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 90 Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 7 years ago
#34
There is only one case in which I excuse EMA, domestic abuse victims but this is either where both culprits are in an abusive relationship or one is and the other is unlinked to another. I don't see any point of being faithful to such a monster or even such a marriage being valid in the eyes of God.

Silsila doesn't fall into this category but as of now nothing indicates EMA (just that feelings and relationship change). Maybe one relationship breaks down and they get divorced before the other relationship starts. Maybe it doesn't break down but Kunal has the guts to be a decent being and ask for a divorce as soon as he realises his feelings towards Mauli (and Nandini) has changed. I know logic and TV rarely go hand in hand and maybe I'm hoping for the impossible.

I started watching cos I'm a DD fan and her saree's were so beautiful. I stayed for the Mauli and Nandini friendship (if I have any ship, it is this tbh), for Kunal and Maulis supportive relationship. Basically all 3 main leads are written so human and logically and beautifully so far.

It's just sad that one day this show will most likely ruin all the beautiful friendships b/w all 3 leads.

There's nothing progressive infidelity nor should it be promoted...but divorce is progressive, if either of the partners fall for someone else at any point, then it's better to divorce than keep yourself in a marriage that you're not happy with anymore and have children. These relationship turn sour and make people monsters, unconsciously you'll start being emotionally abusive, you're partner never meeting your unrealistic expectations because you want to find flaws and will be quick to use it against them.

I'd rather my partner come to me and tell me that he's fallen out love with me and that he wants a divorce than cheat on me and pretend our life is sailing smoothly and that he reciprocates my feelings. Would I be angry, maybe but I definitely would respect him and walk out with my head held high. Maybe in time I would even be friends w/ him/them.

You can't help who and when you fall in love but you can definitely help how you treat all those linked to you in this situation.
Edited by Ahlaam5 - 7 years ago
rosemahal thumbnail
Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 7 years ago
#35
Just we love dd & shakti .. so much
sharie2525 thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 7 years ago
#36

Originally posted by: Angels11

I initially watched the show for the following reasons:

1. What makes people fall out of love.
2. What makes a man or woman walk out of a marriage. Is it extreme reasons like abuse or as simple as growing apart, incompatibility (in an arranged marriage setup).
3. With the right director the subject can be handled in a very sensitive manner. Silsila, Arth, Astitiva, Aakir Kyon etc etc. Movies on EMA can be beautifully told without being crass. I wanted 2 c if this show deals with it in a sensitive & realistic manner.
4. Different from the saas bahu, naagin, chudail crap on Indian TV
5. Initial 2 promos were intriguing.

However sadly aft the 1st 1 week this show has been a terrible disappointment to me. Heroine is the typical Indian TV shivering, shrinking, violet, abla naari, OTT antics by her so called husband & her equally OTT response to it. All the 1970s style so called symbolism.

The CVs made a huge mistake by showing Mauli-Kunal so lovey-dovey & Mauli-Nandini being BFFs. Now anything that they show will only alienate the viewers further. Wat I was hoping for are 2 couples where there r already rifts/undercurrents/issues in their marriage. Then BHAM suddenly a person with whom they can connect, who feels like their ideal soulmates. In such a situation how do they handle it. How does it impact their family & friends. This is wat I was looking for but none of this happened.

So I no longer watch the show. I tune in just once in a while, sometimes come 2 the forum. That's it.

Reg ur quest bt shipping, those are the respective fans of the actors. Dont think any of the neutral viewers like me are shipping Kunal & Nandini. In fact neutral fans want Nandini to b an independent woman & Mauli to shine in her profession.


sharie2525 thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 7 years ago
#37
I usually don't write comments as I'm a silent viewer but like every sane and a neutral person nothing can justify EMA...by showing Mouli and Kunal so lovey dovey and understanding it will be so hard to justify this affair...:I liked dhrashti but nandini's charcter is weak and Mouli is just like any other girl and her character is so beautifully portrayed...honestly it's funny how some people are shipping for Kunal and Nandini knowing that Mouli is such a nice girl and this just shows that how your own best friend can have an affair with your man behind your back by giving such a lame excuse of so called JAZBAAT
-lazybee- thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 7 years ago
#38
Infidelity is neither progressive nor acceptable but definitely realistic especially in today's world..😊

I think people shipping KuNan are more of fan of actors including myself..😆 I don't find anything wrong in it..I would never like to see or ship such things in real life but then againTellly or bolly world has nothing to do with reality as well...



annu_ms thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 7 years ago
#39
I really don't know whats the big deal about this concept.
It is the reality ..I know many people around me who has a partner at their work place.
Initially I used wonder what is making them leave their beautiful wives and go for other woman?
But this is the fact.Kudos to the CV s for showing it on the TV.May be its true the feeling for someone is not pre planned or calculated it just happens ...you never know when your heart started beating for someone else.In our society if its for the first time and spent money get married then its Pavithr...
If it happens for the second time then it's a crime..
Many say its becoz of TV,internet bla bla..
If so what about Rekha,Hemamalini,Sridevi,Shabana azmi??They all fallen for happily married men that time there was no TV?
Anyone stopped seeing Amitabhachan movies or reality show because of this?
No body watches Amir khan,Rani Shilpa,karishna,kareena,Akshay,Saif...the list goeson...Anyone stopped them falling in love or leaving their partner?
So why problem with only these characters?Here at least they are only doing their work..
Minionite thumbnail
Posted: 7 years ago
#40
Hello everyone,

The topic currently is threading a fine line between moral policing (questioning people's preferences) and discussions on infidelity. TM if you wish to discuss infidelity and whether it is progressive or not, please open a new topic only on those lines. Do not ask why people are shipping Kunal and Nandini or how Nandini can be justified because that becomes moral policing.

Regards,

Shreya
SBRK DT

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".