My dear Surbhi,
First things first. While you are of course free to write anything you like on this thread, and I shall read it with interest, I just wanted to spare you the effort and say that it is not necessary. I have grown to like you a lot even after such a minimal acquaintance: you are persuasive in a non-confrontational manner, you are fair and you are just. Even now you are trying your level best to salvage this shipwreck, and I was impressed by your determination and the passionate eloquence you brought to your task. From your perspective, of course, and you are very persuasive indeed.👏
However, you also have to see things from my perspective. I am 70, and I suffer from rheumatoid arthritis. I have been 38 years in the Indian Foreign Service, and the IF is a post-retirement hobby of mine that has been considerably cramped because of my RA. I never wrote a line in this forum till March 28 last, that is less than two months ago, for there was nothing that seemed worth commenting about in this straightforward and predictable set up, with black and white characters in a melodramatic narrative.. Then again, I have to pace my typing and I did not feel like getting on to the forum treadmill and having my fingers lock up.
I watch only historicals, not saas bahu soaps. They all start out well -Maharana Pratap, Ashoka, Jodha Akbar, and now Porus. But they invariably deteriorate and I have never lasted more than half of any of them. Of these, Jodha Akbar was the best of the lot, but that too became a farce, with vishkanyas and outlandish twists and plots when there was such a wealth of historical material ready at hand to be used.
The only truly superb historical I have watched - which, predictably, flopped and was terminated in the most clumsy and insulting manner possible - was Bajirao Peshwa. Every character in it was perfectly etched, even all the side ones, the actors were superb, the period settings were impeccable, and the script stuck close to history. I live in Pune, which is Peshwa territory, so I should know! I would unhesitatingly recommend it to you and to anyone else who reads this post for online viewing.
In Porus, it is not that the one episode of yesterday made me decide to quit, though I resent being treated like an 8 year old watching Superman😡. It is the wholesale distortion of history, and not only Alexander's, for lack of an intelligent script that would pit a street smart, shrewd, supple minded and intelligent Porus against Alexander, trying to outwit him in mind games, tactics and strategy. How I would have loved such a Puru!
Instead we have a hot headed youngster who has neither common sense nor a sense of priorities, and rushes into every situation that presents itself, like a weathercock in the wind. He never appealed to me, even before he started making speeches, whether after a Samson act from atop a pillar or on the ground. In fact I think it is the weakness in the characterisation of Puru that has kept Porus from getting the TRPs that Maharana Pratap and Ashoka got in their first year. The young protagonists there caught the imagination of the viewers, this one didn't, for otherwise, such an opulent show should not languish at TRPs of 1 or less.
Then came Alexander and Rohit, whom I had never seen before, and he made me sit up and watch. He might be an invader and an enemy, but I like complex characters, and Alexander, with such a perfect piece of casting, looked very promising. And the early Alexander was indeed handled very well, and even till recently there were excellent snippets. I am not saying that he should have got 50% of the time, and in any case, even the 20% he had was mostly more arresting than Puru's 80%. To me, that is, and this of course need not be your opinion.
Morever, Porus might be a show with an Indian perspective, but the fact is that without Alexander, no one would have remembered Porus. He is not a Chandragupta Maurya or a Chanakya or an Ashoka, who are immortalised on their own steam. Porus' sole claim to fame is that he was brave enough, and devoted enough to his land, to stand up against Alexander when no one else would do so. And it is the makers who keep on dragging the link with Alexander in at every possible moment, as if it was an umbilical cord, with the endless references to niyati. That is because they too know that without the Alexander connection, their script cannot stand on its own.
So the show was chugging along fairly well. But then things started slipping. Puru was deified and Alexander was demonised, and neither appealed to me.
I note your point that for Alexander the antagonist, the CVs would not bring up the good points and highlight all the bad ones. But then they should have chosen a script on Chengiz Khan or Timurlang, in an unrelieved black.
Here, they have been busy suppressing the wonderful bond between Sisygambis and Alexander, and have totally reversed his honourable treatment of the Persian royal ladies, because that would have humanised him and would thus have been contrary to their plans. They made him murder the High Priestess of Delphi, an event that never took place, to add another coat of tar.
This is not highlighting bad points in Alexander's makeup, and God knows there are plenty. It is manufacturing bad points that never existed and suppressing the good ones. It is dishonesty, pure and simple. I do not like such dishonesty.
Now they have reduced Alexander not just to a standard issue villain, but he has been made out to be a fool. 😡Which are both things the historical Alexander never was. Not even Rohit can now save this Alexander, who has had the stuffing knocked out of him last night.
As for Puru, he is busy hamming away for all that he is worth. It is not the boy Laksh's fault, it is the fault of the script. And whenever he faces a sticky situation, he falls back on playing Superman. It makes me weep to think of Puru's wasted potential.
My dear, I have taken up far too much of your time with this rambling response and taxed my fingers too much as well. But I was touched by your posts and I did not want to upset you in any way, whence this longwinded explanation. I hope it makes some sense!
I will now call a halt to this Ramayana. As for the forum, it is unlikely to be in any way affected by my departure. After all, I have been here for less than 2 months. And since I now dislike both Puru and Alexander, any future posts of mine would hardly make for pleasant reading!
In fact, I think you should exert yourself and post as much as you can - I have not seen a single post, or even comment of yours in these two months till you surfaced on my last but one thread. Why was that? You are good at analysis and have a sense of balance. I am sure your posts and threads will be popular and will enliven the forum. And I will come and comment on your threads, after I have had a break to recover from last night!😉
Take care, my dear Surbhi, and God bless.
Shyamala Di
Originally posted by: EtherealRati
Okay, i will reply to the complete post tomorrow. But i want to say something...i can understand no one really expected ki aisa kuch ho sakta hain jaisa ki hua...but remember anusuya was told he will be lohe ka shareer and moam ka dil always. He is still same...ofcourse i dont support the whole jumping scenario...because anu was never told ki aapke bete ko udne ki shakti bhi prapt hogiii...wohhh jyaada ho gaya...teer nikalne se bahut jyaada...but please dont stop watching this show ...pls dont stop analyzing...itni mushkil se toh is forum ke kuch jaan aayi hain...ronak hain ...discussions hai...khos.a gaya tha kahi...porus will be back on track...please dont stop...porus rajya track is gonna be interesting now...with bamni and anu finally in action...i know things have not gone as expected...but yeh shayad issi tarah hi hona tha...unhe puru ko waha se nikalna tha...aur yeh warning dene ke baad nikalna tha ki woh bharat par attack karne ki na soache...instead of high jump...agar woh usse bhaag kar us stage par chadtha hua dikha dete toh najane kya jaata. Par samjho...ki shayad yeh log dikhayenge alex ko jeeta hua last mein aur isiliye aaj puru ko khada kiya talwar lekar...to show when he got a chance...he dint killed...and alex yaad rakhega...aage future mein aur isiliye nahi marega purushottam ko...i have read articles which said ki roxanne ki rakhi ke baad...porus jaan baksh deta hain alex ki ek baar...bas yeh samajh lo...yeh wahi tha...i know bahut negatives ho rahe show mein...like people are not liking the long dialougues...but try and understand...an historic like this is also meant to tell what india is...how indian people are and ya in a veryyy enhancedd way because its all about porus...about india. When a movie was made on alex...it concentrated on alex more...a show from indian persexpective willl boost about india and porus much more than alexander. They will not show alexander as a parallal lead because from an indian perspective...alexxx was an attacker...woh hamare desh ka dushman tha...he attacked our nation. Try and understand in that prospective...movies on alex never highlight what porus was and its vice versa here. A show on porus wont highlight good qualities of alex...its from indian perspective. They will highlight india and porus more.
Originally posted by: EtherealRati
Siddharth sir said that he will cover alex story parallaly too...he never said he will go in deep details...alex movies have porus entry only when he enters for war...but here they are covering alex story in a show named porus. Biasness toh naam se hi aa jaati hain...agar alex aur puru ko equal karke dikhana hota
...toh name could have been two legends...war of hydapes ...or something like that ...not porus. CV's did cleared in all interviews...that this show is gonna cover story from indian perspective...and from indian perspective...alex was an attacker...an attacker who couldnt take anything from our land and never reached his country after the war either. Indian perspective mei toh woh dushman hain...and thus they will not highlight all good in him but will make sure ki bure points saare cover kare...i will answer to whole post tomorrow in detail.
Edited by sashashyam - 7 years ago