AIYAARI-Reviews/BO

222149 thumbnail
Posted: 7 years ago
#1

Aiyaary movie review: The Manoj Bajpayee starrer isn't taut enough to qualify for an edge-of-the-seat thriller


Aiyaary movie review: Even though the movie puts together an impressive ensemble cast comprising some of our best actors, it takes a lot of time to establish their characters. A veteran in Neeraj Pandey's movies, Manoj Bajpayee carries the film on his shoulders.

Written by Alaka Sahani | New Delhi | Published: February 16, 2018 10:18 am
Aiyaary movie reviewAiyaary movie review: Had the film been closely edited to make it pacy, it would have sent out the message it intends to.

Aiyaary movie cast: Manoj Bajpayee, Sidharth Malhotra, Naseeruddin Shah, Anupam Kher, Vikram Gokhale, Kumud Mishra, Rakul Preet Singh, Pooja Chopra
Aiyaary movie director: Neeraj Pandey
Aiyaary movie rating: 2.5 stars

It is all too familiar: men in uniform, who are deeply righteous and patriotic, going after robbers, arms dealers and terrorists. In fact, as a writer and director Neeraj Pandey has created a brand of thriller with them that he can call his own. He often creates a heightened sense of drama aided by music, that's almost a constant; stylised images with generous use of slo-mo; and, of course, the necessary twists and turns to make the cat-and-mouse game engrossing.

This time, Pandey spins the story around two men mentor Colonel Abhay Singh (Manoj) and acolyte Major Jai Bakshi (Sidharth) who are part of a special unit of Indian Army's military intelligence. The latter goes rogue when he discovers deep-rooted corruption and flaws in the system. This sets his mentor on his chase as the action shifts from Delhi to Central London. It would have been interesting to watch two men, who have deep regard and love for each other, tackle their conflicts even as their ideologies clash. This lays bare the generation gap, the questions and cynicism that the younger ones have. Yet, the film does not go deeper into these issues.

Aiyaary, for which Pandey gets the story, script and direction credit, isn't taut enough to qualify for an edge-of-the-seat thriller. The plot is emaciated. The narration, which revolves around deception and sense of duty, is long-winding. Even though the movie puts together an impressive ensemble cast comprising some of our best actors, it takes a lot of time to establish their characters.

A veteran in Pandey's movies, Manoj Bajpayee carries the film on his shoulders. But, one expects more from this collaboration, especially since Manoj is a versatile actor. As a former army man turned arms dealer, Adil Hussain brings his usual finesse to the screen. What is particularly disappointing are the sketchy women characters. Even though Pandey has written and produced Naam Shabana, which revolves around a woman spy, he fails to create any remarkable woman characters. Though Rakul Preet Singh is introduced as an IT wizard, she is reduced to being Sidharth Malhotra's love interest.

Team Aiyaary On How They Stayed Positive Despite Trouble With Its Release Date

Neeraj Pandey has perfected the art of weaving opinion on the political scenario, the hankering for money and power, the prevalent corruption in the system and the state of democracy in his stories. At one point in the movie, Singh explains to Bakshi that the Kashmir issue is never going to be resolved as it is like an "industry since too many people stand to gain from the conflict. Pandey has, in the past, deftly woven real-life scams and incidents into the narrative. In Aiyaary, he fictionalises the Adarsh Housing Society scam in Mumbai. The result, this time, is not very impressive.

Had the film been closely edited to make it pacy, it would have sent out the message it intends to. As of now, it remains as lost as the purpose behind some of the film's long drawn chase sequences.

Edited by MinzPie - 7 years ago

Created

Last reply

Replies

24

Views

4.8k

Users

10

Likes

8

Frequent Posters

222149 thumbnail
Posted: 7 years ago
#2

Aiyaary movie review: Manoj Bajpayee carries the film on his shoulders while Sidharth Malhotra-Neeraj Pandey play eye spy

If you are a fan of spy thrillers and Neeraj Pandey, you will have to stifle yawns while watching Aiyaary

By Ankita Chaurasia | Published: February 16, 2018 3:08 am

Aiyaary movie review: Manoj Bajpayee carries the film on his shoulders while Sidharth Malhotra-Neeraj Pandey play eye spy

As a fan of spy-thrillers, it is almost impossible to not be excited by the prospect of watching a Neeraj Pandey film. With titles like A Wednesday, Special 26 and Baby to his credit, it comes as no surprise that the filmmaker is now synonymous with good thrillers. And when he joins forces with Manoj Bajpayee, with whom he has collaborated on many films, the excitement doubles. Some promising teasers and a well-cut trailer later, I am understandably kicked about watching the film. But does it live up to the expectations I have? Let's find out...

What's it about

A secret and unauthorised intelligence division of the Indian army is under attack. The secret of their existence is about to be aired on national television, and there's hardly anything that they can do about it. Considering that they are the top-notch intelligence officials of the country, you might wonder as to why are they so helpless, right? Well you see, Major Jai Dikshit, (Sidharth Malhotra), one of their celebrated officers, with a proverbial bright future, has gone rogue. But not all is lost yet as his mentor, Colonel Abhay Singh (Manoj Bajpayee) is out to get him before he pulls off the big reveal. There's another person, who is inadvertently involved in the whole mess. Sonia (Rakul Preet Singh) is a IT genius, who shows off her prowess by hacking into people's computers to shop online. However, considering how love is blind and all that, she doesn't see through Jai's trickery and ends up becoming his secretary. Like in all Neeraj Pandey's film there is a sub-plot too and it provides a bird's eye view of the bigger picture. So while you are trying to figure out, along with Col. Abhay, as to why the prodigal good boy has veered off track, there are a few other elements thrown in the mix. A corrupt ex-army man who is trying to bribe an honest officer before blackmailing him, another ex-army man with a ammunition company and a terrible obsession with 3d models, a frazzled old man in a seedy motel room, and a mastermind with no nationality, form the ensemble cast of the film. And while you are still trying to wrap your head around what exactly is going on, as the filmmaker ties one loose end after another, there comes a final reveal, which makes you question everything.

What's hot

Manoj Bajpayee, and in a film that stars Sidharth Malhotra, that's saying a lot. While Sidharth look great in every shot, what with those cool jackets and hot aviators, it is Manoj who carries the film on his able shoulders. He is believable as a secret agent, who is the master of disguises. In a film like this, where you have to brood and frown most of the time, Manoj brings in that extra dimension with his brand of sarcasm-laced humour. It is in these scenes that you truly enjoy the film. Neeraj and Manoj have worked in several films together and the level of comfort that they share reflects on screen too. The film makes some witty commentary on the Kashmir issue and even though it is fleeting, it is interesting enough to be one of the highlights of the film.

What's not

The film indulges itself so much that the entire first half is invested in developing the characters and establishing their loyalties. A slick thriller can't afford to be so generous. When I walk into watch an espionage thriller, I am expecting a fast-paced, blink-and-you-miss suspense. As far as Aiyaary is concerned, I could have clocked in some shuteye and still not missed out on much except some more character sketching. What's more...unlike most of Neeraj's films, this one uses the supporting cast for just that support. They come in to the picture and fade out without much ado. So despite featuring names like Anupam Kher and Naseeruddin Shah, the film barely uses them. The incongruous timeline doesn't help matters either. Also, considering that it is a spy-thriller, it is disappointingly boring with the use of technology. The officers and the blackmailers all communicate through Whatsapp. Even the TV show CID knows that it is not safe, for God's sake! And what was that whole thing with Sonia. I, who have never been a part of any intelligence agency, know that you can't let a liability tag along, no matter how efficient she is in booking tickets and clicking selfies. How can a well-trained spy commit such a blunder? James Bond would be so disappointed in him!

What to do

If you are a fan of spy thrillers and Neeraj Pandey, you will have to stifle yawns while watching Aiyaary. However, if you appreciate the finer things in life like Manoj Bajpayee's flawless performance, you must book your tickets to the film because the actor is at the top of his game here.

Edited by MinzPie - 7 years ago
222149 thumbnail
Posted: 7 years ago
#3
Karan JoharVerified account @karanjohar
More

#Aiyaary is such a solid smart and poignant thriller!! It makes you think and keeps you on your toes right through! So proud of you @S1dharthM for all the varied choices you make and have excelled in every one of them!! Congratulations to the team! Must watch


POP Diaries @Popdiarieslive
More

#Aiyaaryreview: Every #SidharthMalhotra fan would cherish this act from the actor where there will be many scenes where he will surprise you with his many avatars!


Amar ButalaVerified account @amarbutala
More

Go watch #Aiyaary today !! An edge of the seat thriller set against the world of the arms dealers, the army and Delhi politics! @S1dharthM and @BajpayeeManoj are superb as army men trying to do the best for the country! #Aiyaaryreview



divaz thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 7 years ago
#4
hope this movie is profitable for sid's sake. I really liked him in A Gentleman and the movie was good. He needs luck on his side
greenletters thumbnail
7th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 7 years ago
#5
Not surprised people are giving these reviews. I am a big fan of Manoj but I don't think I could sit through this film. Glad he is getting good reviews.
altgr thumbnail
Posted: 7 years ago
#6
Taran Adarsh

#OneWordReview...
#Aiyaary: DISAPPOINTING.
Rating:-

#Aiyaary has some interesting twists and a couple of skilfully executed sequences, but it lacks the punch associated with Neeraj Pandey's movies... Stylish, yes. Substance, no... Neeraj Pandey misses the bus this time... His weakest work to date...

Lengthy run time [2.40 hours] and lethargic pacing are two major hiccups of #Aiyaary, besides patchy and confused screenwriting... Boasts of fine performances by Manoj Bajpayee, Sidharth Malhotra and of course, Naseeruddin Shah. That's it!
Moodyblue thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 7 years ago
#7
Saw the movie .
Manoj bajpayee's performance is the best thing about the film, Siddharth suits his role , there are some instances where he could have been better but all in all ,he is good. . Nasruddin's cameo breathes life into the movie, you except nothing less from a actor of his calibre.
The problem with movie is its script and screenplay, instead of being taut , it is convoluted and messy at times. We were provided with some back story after interval which frankly, was not needed ,since characters and their competence had already been established. Shorter runtime would have helped in the narrative .
The movie could have been better but it was decent . 3/5 from my side.
Edited by Moodyblue - 7 years ago
222149 thumbnail
Posted: 7 years ago
#8
Reviews and reports by Bollywood trade analyst Komal Nahta

AIYAARY

Reliance Entertainment, Motion Picture Capital, Plan C Studios, PEN Studios and Friday Filmworks' Aiyaary (UA) is the story about the armed forces of India and the corruption that has set in in the ranks of the forces.

Principled army chief Pratap Malik (Vikram Gokhale) has clandestinely set up a covert army unit under Colonel Abhay Singh (Manoj Bajpayee), allocating funds to it although he has no authorisation to do the same. Major Jai Bakshi (Sidharth Malhotra) is a part of the covert team and he is a promising young army officer who is very inspired by the principled Colonel and his philosophies of life.

It emerges that Colonel Abhay Singh and Major Jai Bakshi have disappeared. Army officer K. Srinivas (Rajesh Tailang) is interrogating Maya (Pooja Chopra), another member of the covert team of Colonel Abhay Singh, about the whereabouts of the two.

As the drama unfolds, it turns out that Jai has stolen sensitive data from the covert unit's data centre and he also has the recorded conversation between the army chief and Lieutenant General (retd.) Gurinder Singh (Kumud Mishra). Jai has learnt the art of decoding data from hacker Sonia (Rakul Preet Singh) whom he has ultimately fallen in love with.

In the taped conversation, Gurinder can be heard offering army chief Pratap Malik bribe money to clear the arms and ammunition deal offer received from an arms supplier in Czech Republic. But the upright Malik won't do it as the cost of the deal is four times what it should be. Gurinder Singh, before concluding the conversation, has threatened to expose the covert unit and the army chief if he (army chief) does not close the arms deal. Armed with so much incriminating evidence, Jai has fled the country.

Gurinder Singh even starts the process of exposing the army chief by colluding with a television journalist (Nivedita Bhattacharya). Meanwhile, the army chief cancels the covert operations to ensure his own and Abhay Singh and his team's safety. But the army chief gives Abhay Singh unofficial orders to ensure that the corrupt army people are wiped out in order to protect the nation.

Abhay Singh is shocked that his blue-eyed boy, Jai, could turn rogue. Abhay Singh follows Jai to London where the latter has gone to settle down. He ensures that the crores of rupees, promised to him by Gurinder Singh for not exposing him and Mukesh Kapoor (Adil Hussain) whom he (Gurinder Singh) works for, are transferred to his account. Jai wants to meet arms supplier Mukesh Kapoor in London. It soon becomes clear that Mukesh Kapoor is an ex-army officer of India. Mukesh Kapoor has quit the Indian army to make pots of money by supplying arms. He has retired army officers on his pay roll so that he can use their knowhow to make the best offers to the Army.

Colonel Abhay Singh, on the same flight as Jai, reaches London to kill Jai for turning rogue. He meets a trusted person (Anupam Kher) in London, who helps Abhay in tracking down Jai. Abhay Singh meets Mukesh Kapoor and asks him to eliminate Jai who would be meeting him, threatening to otherwise expose him alongwith Gurinder Singh if he (Mukesh Kapoor) does not oblige.

Meanwhile, the black sheep in the army, including Gurinder Singh, are wondering where Abhay Singh has disappeared after meeting the army chief. They also don't know where Jai Bakshi is.

Does Mukesh Kapoor eliminate Jai? Or does Abhay Singh kill Jai? Is Mukesh Kapoor exposed? Does Gurinder Singh expose the army chief or does Abhay Singh prove one-up on him and expose him before that? Is Jai Bakshi working against the interest of India? Why does Jai Bakshi ask his boss, Abhay Singh, to meet Baburao (Naseeruddin Shah) who is holed up in a small hotel in India? Who is Baburao and what explosive information does he have? Whom will this information expose?

Neeraj Pandey's story is too confusing and convoluted to be easily comprehended by the average person. It has so many sub-plots that it becomes difficult for the audience to keep track of the same. Besides, while talking of the corruption in the armed forces right through the drama, it focuses on such a small (comparatively speaking) aspect in the climax that it appears like a case of much ado about nothing. In an age when scams of thousands and lakhs of crores of rupees make headline news, the scam unearthed by Baburao in the climax looks like a tiny joke. Furthermore, the entire track of Jai Bakshi being disillusioned by the corrupt system does not seem justified because in the taped conversation between army chief Pratap Malik and Lieutenant General (retd.) Gurinder Singh, it is amply evident that the army chief is an honest and principled person. Rather than being inspired by Malik, Jai Bakshi keeps harping on the point of not willing to work for the corrupt system. So long as the man on the top is clean, how can Jai Bakshi take the plea that he is working for a corrupt system, and expect the viewers to buy that?

Neeraj Pandey's screenplay is so confusing that the audience wonders what he wants to convey. The details of the sub-plots revealed by the screenplay are often unnecessary and serve to confuse the audience more than anything else. The tracks of Chiru and some others are unnecessary or, even if essential, are so long that they irritate more than adding anything worthwhile to the drama. There are flashbacks within flashbacks, only adding to the confusion. For example, there is a scene in which Sonia goes into flashback mode. In that flashback, Jai is shown explaining his stand to her and while doing so, he goes into a further flashback. Scenes like these are so irritating that the frustrated audience wants to throw up its hands in despair and shout out for help. Consequently, the viewers sometimes lose track and at some other times, they get irritated with the surfeit of information. The result is that the drama becomes too unwieldy for the audience to handle. In fact, the viewers get the feeling that Neeraj Pandey had so much to say that along the way, he himself lost track of what he must've first set out to say! Neeraj Pandey seems to have overlooked the point that like brevity is the soul of wit, it is also the soul of a box-office hit. The climax, of course, is a major letdown after the huge build-up and it pales into insignificance when viewed in the context of the drama leading up to the climax.

The screenplay lacks the elements of emotions and patriotism. Although the army chief and Colonel Abhay Singh are shown to be confirmed nationalists, nothing in the entire drama evokes patriotic feelings in the viewers. Even the title (meaning the art of disguising and deceiving) seems quite unsuitable.

Neeraj Pandey's dialogues are good at places but definitely not half as punch-packed and patriotic as they ought to have been.

Sidharth Malhotra is sincere as Major Jai Bakshi. He delivers an earnest performance but his character does not get the audience's sympathy because of the reason given above. Sidharth looks very handsome. Manoj Bajpayee shines in the role of Colonel Abhay Singh. He gets into the skin of the character and comes up with an absolutely stunning show of talent. Here, it must be added that the youth may not approve of the fact that Manoj Bajpayee often seems to have a meatier role than Sidharth Malhotra. Rakul Preet Singh does well as Sonia but she tends to overact in the last few reels. Adil Hussain plays arms dealer Mukesh Kapoor with conviction and authority. Kumud Mishra gives an interesting colour to the character of Lieutenant General (retd.) Gurinder Singh. Naseeruddin Shah is very natural as Baburao and makes a fine impact. But in the scheme of things, the viewers get the feeling that an artiste of his calibre has been quite wasted even though he turns out to be like the hero of the climax. Anupam Kher makes his presence felt. Pooja Chopra has her moments as Maya. Vikram Gokhale makes his mark as army chief Pratap Malik. Rajesh Tailang lends lovely support as army officer K. Srinivas. Juhi Babbar Soni leaves a mark as Abhay Singh's wife. Nivedita Bhattacharya is effective as the television journalist. Lushin Dubey (as Jai's mother), Ajith Bhurre, Gaurav Sharma, Maan Sarohi, Mir Sarwar, Deepak Chand, Zafar, Kacho, Sidharth Bhardwaj, Rahul and Janvi Kapoor are adequate.

Neeraj Pandey's direction, like his script, leaves something to be desired. The accomplished director does not seem to be in form this time as his narration is found lacking in a lot of aspects. Rochak Kohli's music is appealing as the Lai dooba' song is of a popular variety. Manoj Muntashir's lyrics are good. Feroz Khan's choreography is functional and goes well with the mood of the film. Sanjoy Chowdhury's background music is excellent and greatly adds to the drama. Sudheer Palsane's cinematography deserves distinction marks. Abbas Ali Moghul's action and stunt scenes are good. Production designing (by Narendra Rahurikar) is of a fine standard. Praveen Kathikuloth's editing could've been more effective but, of course, the major blame for lack of effectiveness lies on the weak script.

On the whole, Aiyaary is a flop show which will face rejection at the box-office because it is too long and boring and lacks entertainment value and the patriotic flavour.

222149 thumbnail
Posted: 7 years ago
#9
Aiyaary Movie Review: Manoj Bajpayee | Sidharth Malhotra | Neeraj Pandey | FilmiBeat Rating: 2.0/5 Cast: Sidharth Malhotra, Rakul Preet Singh, Manoj Bajpayee Director: Neeraj Pandey Aiyaary (U/A): Book Your Tickets Right Away! During a regular drinking session, a colonel tells his protege that he always tosses a coin when stuck in dilemma because the heart already selects the right choice when the coin is in mid-air. Nope, we ain't kidding. Imagine, just flicking a coin and poof...your confusion disappears just like that! Even if it meant you are stuck in a life-and-death situation! Too hard to believe naa? But in Neeraj Pandey's parallel universe in Aiyaary, everything's a smooth cakewalk. His latest outing set against the backdrop of Armed forces, revolves around Major Jai Bakshi (Sidharth Malhotra) who goes rogue after stumbling upon the Indian military's murky secrets. He isn't alone in this mission and has his hacker girlfriend Sonia (Rakul Preet Singh) by his side who also doubles up as 'I-have-made-some-coffee-for-you' pal. Meanwhile, Jai's mentor Col. Abhay Singh (Manoj Bajpayee) becomes furious after learning about his treachery and sets out to hunt him down and teach him a lesson or two. Amidst this cat-and-mouse game, there are bigger fishes in the sea who have more at stake and pose a greater risk of getting exposed. Neeraj Pandey is known to be a master when it comes to espionage thrillers. Be it 'A Wednesday', 'Baby', 'Special 26', the filmmaker has never shied away from portraying the grim reality on-screen in the most realistic way. His take on corruption and malpractices existing in the country has always been bold and stark. Unfortunately in Aiyaary, the man has refrained from digging deep into the dirt and played it as safely as possible. While in his media interviews, Neeraj maintained that 'the DNA of Aiyaary is the point of view of the youth and not corruption or scam,' the commentary that he makes on today's youth who are considered irresponsible and constantly underestimated, lack a strong voice. National security, espionage, corruption, terrorism, scams and the clash of ideologies between two generations- Pandey tries to pack in too many ingredients but is terribly let down by his own feebly writing. The non-linear narrative especially for a major portion in the first half leaves you with jumbled minds as you struggle to keep pace with events happening at a swift speed. Neeraj takes his own sweet time to explain character quirks and idiosyncrasies which induces a few 'yawns'. There are several questions left unaswered even post the rolling of end-credits. When it comes to performances, Sidharth Malhotra falters as Major Jai Bakshi. While it's highly applaudable of the actor to step into a different zone, he needs to buck up when it comes to emoting on celluloid. Lesser said about his intense scenes here the better. Also one question for Mr Malhotra, what's with that smirking throughout the film? Thankfully, his swooning looks might save the day for the ladies at least! Manoj Bajpayee relishes his role with sincerity and gives you reasons to cheer. The actor remains true to the film's title and keeps you hooked with his 'shape-shifting'. Right from the body language to the mannerisms of a staunchly scrupulous army officer, he gets it spot on. Rakul Preet Singh looks charismatic. Sadly, she barely gets a chance to showcase her acting talent. But wasn't her character supposed to be that of a brilliant hacker? Instead, we see her basking in puppy love and blindly follow her beau's intructions for reasons which are never revealed! Naseeruddin Shah's cameo suffers from a serious 'A Wednesday' hangover. Nevertheless, it's still a treat to watch the veteran actor utter the veiled threat- 'Gareeb aadmi ko na ungli nahi karne ka sahab' and echo every common man's sentiments. Pooja Chopra randomly pops up in a scene or a two. Kumud Mishra's character begins well but later simply trails off. Talented performers like Adil Hussain and Anupam Kher suffer from weak character sketches. Sudheer Palsaane's lens beautifully captures the intrinsic details and perfectly builds up moments. Despite Praveen Kathikuloth's editing scissors, Aiyaary makes for a tedious watch at a run-time of 160 minutes. The song 'Lae Dooba' in Aiyaary merely acts as a filler and adds to the 'forced' romantic track brewing between Sidharth Malhotra and Rakul Preet. The film has some impressive background score. There's a scene in the film where Manoj Bajpayee's Abhay Singh tells a character, "Matlab bhi batayega ya google karoon..." That perfectly sums up your feelings after watching Aiyaary. Neeraj Pandey fails to conjure an engaging watch. Instead, he serves you a half-baked plot that just beats around the bush and leaves you apathetic by the time it reaches the finish mark. Those carrying remnants of Neeraj's previous films with them to the cinema hall will be highly disappointed!

Read more at: https://www.filmibeat.com/bollywood/reviews/2018/aiyaary-movie-review-rating-plot-271724.html
angrybread thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 7 years ago
#10
Aiyyary released today 😲 completely forgot about it .

Related Topics

Bollywood Thumbnail

Posted by: oyebollywood

12 days ago

Coolie - Reviews And Box Office

https://x.com/UmairSandu/status/1954571916745794046

https://x.com/UmairSandu/status/1954571916745794046
Expand ▼
Bollywood Thumbnail

Posted by: Maroonporsche

10 days ago

War 2 -Movie Reviews & BO Discussion

https://x.com/umairsandu/status/1954950592771895651?s=46 Tis is review thread ?

https://x.com/umairsandu/status/1954950592771895651?s=46
Expand ▼
Bollywood Thumbnail

Posted by: priya185

8 days ago

Tehran Reviews- starring John Abraham

Tehran Reviews- John Abraham and Manushi Chillar...

Expand ▼
Bollywood Thumbnail

Posted by: oyebollywood

27 days ago

Bollywood Thumbnail

Posted by: Maroonporsche

1 months ago

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".