ShadowImbue thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 180 Thumbnail + 5

Team Critics

Posted: 7 years ago
#1
Character Analysis of Kirti's character from the beginning depicted that she is a vulnerable, non-trusting, non-opinionated, fearful, hesitant, polite and a very compromising girl but her character is turning quite inconsistent as the story is progressing


Even after being physically abused wanted to give her relationship a chance on dadi's insistence. Consistent Behavior
Had a bitter past experience but fell in love with SIL's brother even after being vulnerable and non trusting. Inconsistent Behavior
Kirti being vulnerable decided to leave her family when her marriage alliance was fixed with SIL's brother as he wasn't replying in a proper way and she was feeling guilty Consistent
Agreed to get married without a proper conversation with her fiance despite of being a vulnerable person (which isn't a flaw) who blames herself for everything Inconsistent
On knowing about Naksh's sacrifice decided to stay in GV despite of being sacrificing and always compromising in terms of relationships. Inconsistent (though liked the change)
Got convinced very easily while compromising her dignity, she did that previously too when she stayed with Aditya for years. Consistent (though disliked the change)
Hesitated to ask about Naksh's feelings for Tara as he might get angry. Consistent
All of sudden became opinionated regarding her feelings over Naksh's overly caring or adjusting nature and awkwardness hearing Kirti jee. Inconsistent


Every human and character has growth but the growth is steady and consistent more realistically.
Are they heading towards Kirti is stubborn that's why Aditya use to beat her physically? (Disclaimer: physical violence is a crime and not acceptable in any case!!) The way those ladies in kitty party expressed their not so valuable opinions. Are they heading towards Bua-Dadi finding flaws in Kirti and considering those not so valuable opinions while observing Kirti's behavior? All characters have flaws but inconsistency is rare. Either be opinionated or be a non-opinionated in other words easily convinced person. A girl who didn't trust her family her mother/ brother to be precise that they will side with her on knowing about her condition trusted a person she met a few months ago so easily? Why there is no hesitance from Kirti's side in terms of relationship, trust and future? Why her character has turned non-opinionated to opinionated than again non-opinionated to opinionated as per convenience? The most poorly handled character! Her strengths should be in her vulnerabilities not in her changing behavior.

Created

Last reply

Replies

10

Views

1.8k

Users

6

Likes

35

Frequent Posters

janvi0513 thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 7 years ago
#2
Lovely post
The inconsistency in her character is what has been pointed out many times.Character growth is a great thing, it is what is needed most but jumping from square 1 to 5 then going back to 3 then to 7 is not the way to do things.
ShadowImbue thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 180 Thumbnail + 5

Team Critics

Posted: 7 years ago
#3

Originally posted by: janvi0513

Lovely post

The inconsistency in her character is what has been pointed out many times.Character growth is a great thing, it is what is needed most but jumping from square 1 to 5 then going back to 3 then to 7 is not the way to do things.


Exactly that's my point the progression should be step wise or steady. They themselves are confused what they want to show. Even if they want to show divorce women being blamed for failed relationship they can highlight any flaw that wasn't in her hands. Why highlighting attributes she never possessed till today.
Miss-Behave thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 365 Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 7 years ago
#4
The maker's clearly didn't know what to do with kirti's character or how to progress her, hence why her character never made sense to me.
kirts123 thumbnail
8th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 7 years ago
#5
But I liked keerthi yesterday...anyone will feel sufficcoated with overbearing or over caring like how naksh was doing.. I liked that she raised her opinion and made it cLear that she wanted o be treated normally.. I really really liked it..
When one is being abused, anywhere where they don't find it they will be more comfortable.. with naksh she started liking him cos she was just out of the abusive stage and with naksh she knew that a person who bears his sister on a sliver string can never hurt others.

She did not tell the truth of her abuse to karthik as she knows of his anger issues and that Karthik will not think twice to even kill aditya for what he had done.. given that aditya had already fed fear into her mind about the loss of family reputation and business loss if the truth came out. Most of all she could not trust her dadi who has the final say in her house due to dadi s damad worship...

I used to fee bad with keerthi s cribbing.. but they are trying to make her character grow.. it was good that she refused to forgive naksh that easily and has raised her srand about bring treated normally...

However I feel keerthi will have issues in SS.. given we have a counter part of karthik s dadi there in the firm of bua dadi..
anu023 thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 7 years ago
#6
Well the blame goes to garima anf bhavna who introduced characters and were clueless how to give them a story.
Well bhavna's grandiose ideas and convenient memory lapses about kirti just so that only leads remain relevant has resulted in this.
No i am not hating or bashing but just pointing out what went wrong. They are already salvaging keesh now with subtle growth in their relation.
It would definitely look inconsistent if they show silly nok jhoks of keesh or meaningless fights n milan that make no sense anyway. I can see a consistent growth in keesh now after keesh milan happened.hope bhavna doesn't slip into amnesia again and ruin them for me like she ruined gayu..
Stop blaming the character kirti and pass this message to garima instead.
ShadowImbue thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 180 Thumbnail + 5

Team Critics

Posted: 7 years ago
#7

Originally posted by: sammy17

The maker's clearly didn't know what to do with kirti's character or how to progress her, hence why her character never made sense to me.


That's for sure writers are clueless in terms of appropriate projection of Kirti's character.
ShadowImbue thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 180 Thumbnail + 5

Team Critics

Posted: 7 years ago
#8

Originally posted by: anu023

Well the blame goes to garima anf bhavna who introduced characters and were clueless how to give them a story.

Well bhavna's grandiose ideas and convenient memory lapses about kirti just so that only leads remain relevant has resulted in this.
No i am not hating or bashing but just pointing out what went wrong. They are already salvaging keesh now with subtle growth in their relation.
It would definitely look inconsistent if they show silly nok jhoks of keesh or meaningless fights n milan that make no sense anyway. I can see a consistent growth in keesh now after keesh milan happened.hope bhavna doesn't slip into amnesia again and ruin them for me like she ruined gayu..
Stop blaming the character kirti and pass this message to garima instead.


Problem definitely lies in writing but it has nothing to do with leads. Also nok jhoks, misunderstandings, fights and reconciliation are a part of every couple's life who love each other but turning Kirti and Naksh like Karthik and Naira would be wrong. Same writers are writing brilliantly for Suwarnish too.
anu023 thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 7 years ago
#9
what all k.dadi haters are forgetting is bua.dadi is the worst kind of elder one can have in a family. K dadi is realistic.bua dadi isn't. Bua dadi was far worse during akshara's time.😆

Also they slowly brought in that scene where kirti asks naksh not to be over sweet. That's definitely.not inconsistency.
anu023 thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 7 years ago
#10

Originally posted by: ShadowImbue


Problem definitely lies in writing but it has nothing to do with leads. Also nok jhoks, misunderstandings, fights and reconciliation are a part of every couple's life who love each other but turning Kirti and Naksh like Karthik and Naira would be wrong. Same writers are writing brilliantly for Suwarnish too.

sorry to say but there are hardly any suwarnish scenes and even in those manish steals all limelight with his fabulous acting. I cringe when suwarna says maneesss ji.. Her hindi diction is bad . I like manish solo scenes or manish n akhilesh scenes. They are good.

Related Topics

Yeh Rishta Kya Kehlata Hai Thumbnail

Posted by: Lucifer666

3 months ago

Why the U turn Ruhi?

I am not at all a Abhimaan supporter and Ruhi craving for Armaan made me furious at her. I am somebody who has my whole sympathy and empathy for...

Expand ▼
Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".