Morana thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 7
Posted: 7 years ago
#1
Well it is kinda obvious !! πŸ˜† Vyom's story is almost entirely fictional especially the love part is completely a lie. It's obvious from 24th Oct episode.
Pointers -
1. Most important and full proof point- " Dimaag bhul sakta hai.. pad dil nehi ! Pyar ka connection dimaag se nehi dil se hota hai. " Bang on point raised by Sharanya and I totally agree. AS she said, there's no ehsaas in her heart for Vyom , just nothing !
Whereas she senses and feels Shiv every where and whenever he's around.

2. The way they high lighted the word "friends" written on both of their palms I think they were just that- good friends !

3. No where even in his fbs , did they show any thing that can surely point towards the fact that he was any thing other than a good friend to her, no look of passion or love from her side in any of them even for a second. Just sweet friendly smile.

4. I believe Vyom shifted many parts of the story , like changing little bits of facts and keeping hush hush on others .
For example , He was the drummer of the college band , not the composer , it was Shiv who was the composer n it was him that Sharanya was in love with . It was him who was shown with a guitar , some thing that is often used by composers. Vyom changed this fact so that if she looks into the faded portion of her memory and hazily remembers some guy playing guitar who was her lover , she thinks it was Vyom. He kept the initial part intact , they were in the same college , then became friends n then very good friends. They say the true art of lying is keeping it as close to the truth as possible. It also makes it helluva easy to remember.πŸ˜†

5. The accident took place on the very day she was going to introduce her lover to her family. Extremely convenient timing of the accident , don't you think ?? Her parents n brother has no idea or way to verify whether the guy they were going to meet were Shiv or Vyom.

6. Such a fatal accident that sent Sharanya into a coma for 2 freaking years , left him hell and hearty , not even any disability !
From Sharanya's fb it was obvious that it was a huge accident , a fatal one.

7. Vyom's dad and mom , both of them have reasons aka motive to cause the accident , which probably killed Shiv n sent Sharanya in a coma.

In case of V's mom , she wanted to get rid of the girl for good , since she's from a simple middle class family who's in love with another guy (Shiv ) and her son is obsessed and heart broken both because of her. So , his mom's target would be Sharanya herself ! Shiv was collateral damage or may be he died in an act of protecting Sharanya.

In case of V's dad , well, he's a smooth player as is obvious from the promos , who can go to any length and level to secure his son's happiness. In his case , target was Shiv to remove him from the path n make way for Vyom in Sharanya's life . But he didn't know that Sharanya was in that car too . So plan went a bit haywire. πŸ˜†

8. In the car , when she was coming back home , when accient took place , we see only her , we didn't see Vyom in the car . They didn't show other passengers ( Or did I miss him ? )
May be it was Shiv with him.

9. Vyom's cryptic words about making new memories and sanak and deewangi.. It's like he doesn't even want the memories to come back.

10. Just because he prayed doesn't write him off as a good character . He's a junoon wala Ashiq , why wouldn't he pray ?? His whole life revo;ves around Sharanya , this part I don't doubt for a second.

We should also remember that the flame had extinguished in his hands the moment Sharanya came back to life , it may indicate that God actually rejected his pooja but returned Sharanya's life as she's innocent .
Plus , the moment she woke up, just before that a gulf of wind enters through the window . Which is similar to what happens when Shiv's spirit makes an appearance . So , it's Shiv who returned her life not Vyom .

Her parents got fooled by Vyom's story , why'd they not ?? They probably know that Sharanya loves some one with no further information , that's why it was so crucial to kill off Shiv before they could meet him.

As for her partial memory loss , may be Vyom already knew that the portion of the brain that stores memory has sustained damage ( Frontal cortex ) , right after the accident , through imagery tests like CECT or plain CT scan , and various sophisticated brain scan. He already knew Sharanya will sustain memory loss , either partial or complete if she survives. Thereafter , he set the entire plan in motion.

11. The colors of flowers that they brought for each other.
Vyom's was red the color of love , passion but Sharanya brought white flowers , signifying innocence , purity and peace. Typical friendly .

12. Last but not the least , I do believe that Vyom didn't actively planned Shiv's murder . He's just doing what we call chance pe dance. πŸ˜†
But the way Sharanya cringes at his touch ( she was almost pulled towards Shiv like a magnet whenever he appears . How could a body less spirit have so much effect on her when her lover has none ?? ) , I do think there's much more to the story.
Of course she gets afraid whenever she sees the ghost form , any mortal being would react that way , especially after a memory loss. But her heart her sub conscious remembers the "ehsaas" in her own words.

I'm yet to see today's episode. SonyLiv hasn't uploaded it yet . I guess once I see it, I'll find some more little pointers.
Would like to hear your views on this matter. 😳
Edited by Lady_Macbeth - 7 years ago

Created

Last reply

Replies

17

Views

2.7k

Users

12

Likes

61

Frequent Posters

beagleboy thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 7 years ago
#2

I wonder what Shiv was doing these two years when she was in her coma. Getting trained in 'how to spook my beloved from beyond the grave', possibly!😊

Given his sexy voice and penchant for poetry, I will happily back your theories. But yes, I think Vyom is telling Sharanya a fantasy tale interspersed with bits of reality. Sharanya wrote and Shiv composed and Vyom was a mere spectator on the sidelines. He is now trying to take centre stage - but leaves behind clues at every turn - his eagerness to create new memories, the words he uses, the red roses instead of the lilies etc.

Still, Ghost is sexy despite all the garish blue.
Morana thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 7
Posted: 7 years ago
#3

Originally posted by: beagleboy


I wonder what Shiv was doing these two years when she was in her coma. Getting trained in 'how to spook my beloved from beyond the grave', possibly!😊

Given his sexy voice and penchant for poetry, I will happily back your theories. But yes, I think Vyom is telling Sharanya a fantasy tale interspersed with bits of reality. Sharanya wrote and Shiv composed and Vyom was a mere spectator on the sidelines. He is now trying to take centre stage - but leaves behind clues at every turn - his eagerness to create new memories, the words he uses, the red roses instead of the lilies etc.

Still, Ghost is sexy despite all the garish blue.


🀣 Good point . I think he was preparing himself for the upcoming battle , which is Mission Save-Sharanya-from-the-clutches-of-Vyom. πŸ˜†

Or may be bargaining with God to bring her back to life. 🀣
aanchalverma04 thumbnail
Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 7 years ago
#4
I don't want to spoil anything, but in today's episode I feel that Vyom is a bit shady, not only because of everything you've mentioned, but even because of the fact that he seemed genuinely shocked when Sharanya told him that her favourite flowers are stargazers. Which boyfriend/lover doesn't know what their girlfriend's/lover's favourite flower is?
Also, I was exactly thinking that Shiv gave Sharanya's life back, not Vyom, mainly because of the fact that how drawn she is to him (a dead person) and how detached she is from Vyom (a living human).

However, having said that, it could also be that Shiv has possessed her and maybe that's why she has forgotten Vyom, because Shiv has taken over her thoughts, due to the fact that she was in her sleep when he came in her nightmare and that's where he could have full control of her, in her sleep where there's no one to look after her.

And... THE ACCIDENT SCENE ITSELF!! I thought I was the only one who noticed how in the accident scene, you could only see Sharanya and not who was driving the car. It is therefore, quite possible that Shiv died in that car accident and Sharanya died in it. What if Rajan was the one to plan this accident? He seems very shady.
PrincessAshVik thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 7 years ago
#5
I'm yet to watch today's episode as well, but all the points you have raised are good! However, there's one thing, and I've raised it in every topic with similar points in spite of agreeing with the points, Sharanya is also a grey character.

There's a voice over of Shiv in one of the trailers Sony shared:
Uss Ne Waqt Samajh Kar Guzaar Diya Mujhe
Aur Main Zindagi Samajh Kar Usse Jeeta Raha
Otherwise like I said, I agree with the points... It's this which is making me wonder how this theory can be right...
May be Vyom made Shiv feel that Sharanya loves Vyom and not Shiv?


Whatever it is, It's very intriguing!
Edited by PrincessAshVik - 7 years ago
Mayavi-26 thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail Commentator Level 2 Thumbnail
Posted: 7 years ago
#6
Good post I agree with ur all four points that vyom truth is twisted , he also dont know sharanya fav flowers when he is claiming to be her bf.
But I don't think his father or mother have hands in accident this is thriller world where they put all characters in suspect list so his parents are shown that way.
Or maybe accident was not plan was real one but after that what happening is plan of vyom.
Sneha.ko thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 7 years ago
#7

Originally posted by: PrincessAshVik

I'm yet to watch today's episode as well, but all the points you have raised are good! However, there's one thing, and I've raised it in every topic with similar points in spite of agreeing with the points, Sharanya is also a grey character.


<font color="#333333" face="Helvetica Neue, Helvetica, Arial, sans-serif">There's a voice over of Shiv in one of the trailers Sony shared:</font>
Uss Ne Waqt Samajh Kar Guzaar Diya Mujhe
Aur Main Zindagi Samajh Kar Usse Jeeta Raha
Otherwise like I said, I agree with the points... It's this which is making me wonder how this theory can be right...
May be Vyom made Shiv feel that Sharanya loves Vyom and not Shiv?


Whatever it is, It's very intriguing!

+1woh lines hi kuch bolti hai πŸ˜‰
Hamlet53 thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail
Posted: 7 years ago
#8
hello gargi what a mindblowing post..I saw earlier you posted something ,but went away to watch the episode 10pm London time... so late... but its spooky although it says PG.. here ,may be for older kids ten and above..
You sure did present some pointers To Vyom being grey..today his mother actually carped about his obsession with Sharanya.. the mother can't stand the girl and her family... intrestingly gargi.. sharanya's parents too seem very keen for her to accept Vyom... to me because I Went by the oriignal promo... i saw Vyom as the positive and shiv as the negative factor... but you are right since yesterday... and today.. specially at the end... we get to see a division in the face vyom puts on before some people and what he can be like...
I used to think.. Shiv.. caused the accident... but then i thought Vyom may be involved... but your post makes me think about the Bedi's especially the mammaa... Loved the way you sequenced the main events of the story so far... so really who caused the near death accident? and why does Sharanya cringe from Vyom's touch? are two crucial questions.. along with how grey is Vyom? what gets me is Sharanya's repeated rejection of Vyom... today she even tells him ,she's not sure if she will ever remember what happened in the past two years of her life... If you ask me.. Vyom will try his hardest to make her fall for him... have to see if she will allow him to make new moments with him?? seeing that he told her parents... he will gradually grow and set himself upon her...leaving a lasting impact upon her...
thank you my friend for a well constructed and thought provoking post... much love hammie
486792 thumbnail
Posted: 7 years ago
#9
Hey GargiπŸ€—
This entire matter looks so simple yet so complicated.πŸ˜†
It feels as if Vyom is playing mind games right nowπŸ˜•Sharanya did fall in love with the composer of the band and Vyom was only shown with the drums whereas Shiv was the composer and the guitarist.

It was really weird when he didn't even know what her favourite flowers areπŸ˜•

Possibly Vyom plagiarised Shiv's story and made a few changesπŸ˜†

Along with this as @Sara said,even Sharanya might be grey.Coz Shiv's one dialogue heavily indicates that.
Or maybe Vyom did create some misunderstanding between SS.

Morana thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 7
Posted: 7 years ago
#10

Originally posted by: PrincessAshVik

I'm yet to watch today's episode as well, but all the points you have raised are good! However, there's one thing, and I've raised it in every topic with similar points in spite of agreeing with the points, Sharanya is also a grey character.


There's a voice over of Shiv in one of the trailers Sony shared:
Uss Ne Waqt Samajh Kar Guzaar Diya Mujhe
Aur Main Zindagi Samajh Kar Usse Jeeta Raha
Otherwise like I said, I agree with the points... It's this which is making me wonder how this theory can be right...
May be Vyom made Shiv feel that Sharanya loves Vyom and not Shiv?


Whatever it is, It's very intriguing!


Yeah , I'm not keeping any one out of my suspicion list , nor am I giving any1 any clean cheat. Mujhe ye Sharanya bhi khuch sidhi sadhi dudh ki dhuli nehi laagi . πŸ˜‰
It could be totally possible that she was two timing with the two guys . In that case scenerio, it's possible that she's faking the memory loss , because she's unsure whether to continue her relationship with Vyom ?? And she was possibly never as much serious as Vyom in her feelings ??

Or may be as you said , Vyom could've planted a misunderstanding between them to separate them , causing the Ghosty angry at both of them .

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".