Seraphina231 thumbnail
9th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 8 years ago
#1
Hello all! This is a one-shot on Karna and Kunti, something of a challenge given to me.
It is kind of an AU, and I am going to post one chapter now. Depending on your responses, there may be a sequel to it. For now, do read, and drop your comments, and answer the question below with your reasoning. :)


P.S.: Banner, my Donut <3 Ramya, --Elara--

P.P.S.: Chappals allowed. 😆
Edited by Shrinika13 - 8 years ago

Created

Last reply

Replies

26

Views

2.3k

Users

12

Likes

60

Frequent Posters

Seraphina231 thumbnail
9th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 8 years ago
#2

Perspectives


His eyes shut, he lay at the banks of the Ganga, listening to the gentle gurgle of the river, the sound comforting the turmoil in him. His hands made patterns in the sand. With a sigh, the King of Anga sat up.


He knew where his loyalties lay, yet the proposition the Queen Mother brought him was a little too attractive to him. He sighed, unable to decide what to do. If only he had someone to ask, someone like Krishna. A flash of what could be interpreted as envy ran through him. His brothers had a confidante, a guide in Krishna, who just seemed to know. Know everything.


"You are my son, Karna!" said the Queen Mother, in a burst of emotion. "You are my eldest, the elder brother to Yudhishtira, Bhima, Arjuna, Nakula and Sahadeva. You should be the crown-prince of Hastinapura, the king of Indraprastha!"


"And, Rajmata, you should have thought of this when you cast me away," he said, calmly, in stark contrast to Mata Kunti's emotional outburst.


"But, Karna, I was a maiden! Imagine the sha..."


"And in the Rangabhoomi? When your sons, my brothers, insulted me? Called me a Suta-putra? What then? Did you know then?"


She didn't respond, but the fact that she dropped her gaze was affirmation to him.


"You knew, yet you didn't claim me then, Rajmata," he said, levelly. "I cannot lie, the prospect of knowing who I am is, to say the least, comforting. Yet, I have pledged myself and my loyalty to Suyodhana, your sons' enemy. I cannot forsake him."


"At least allow me to tell them, Karna"


"And what, Rajmata? Yudhishthira in his dharma, will hand the kingdom over to me, and I will be unable to deny Suyodhana. I am not heartless"


A hint of a smile crossed Kunti, but it was quickly eclipsed by the true meaning of his words.


"Karna, please rethink.."


"I have thought, Rajmata, he said. She noted the repeated use of the name, but decided to ignore it. After all, it was not his fault. It was her own. "I am sorry, but I cannot accept your offer that I leave my friend's side."


"Do you not see it as I do, Karna? A maiden who begot a son through the grace of Surya Deva, who would be condemned for it? A widow, whose son was older than her marriage?"


"And do you not see it as I do, Rajmata? His cold voice plunged through her like a sword. "I have been maligned all my life, and yet, you ask me to betray the one who showed me some respect, some affection? Who took me in despite my 'lineage'?"


Her eyes filled with tears. Kunti was a strong woman, but in that moment, she felt incredibly weak. She had cherished a hope, that was dashed to the ground. But then, hope bloomed again.


"Karna, I do not want you to rush into a decision, she said, her voice steady. "I know that all of this has been a lot for you to take in, and it is your decision, but I want you to consider it."


"Consider what?"


"I can give you a choice."


Karna's hands seemed to have a life of their own, as he threw pebbles, one after another into the Ganga. His ears were ringing with the offer the Qu- his mother had made.


The choice, she said, was clear. He could choose between Suyodhana and his brothers. If he chose Suyodhana, he would have to spare them. And if he chose his brothers, well... he sighed. He was breaking his word, his dharma, if he indeed chose them.


He thought of the Pandavas. Each so different, yet the same. Yudhishthira, honest, upright. Nothing moved the man's honesty. Nothing induced him to lie. The day at the Dyut Sabha showed him how far he would go to keep with dharma. He remembered his scathing words as he parted. Indeed, he thought, when provoked, he would be ruthless.


He thought of Bhima, the aggressive warrior. Bhima was fiercely protective, he would go to any extent to avenge his loved ones. Any extent. But then again, his bark was worse than his bite, for he knew for a fact that Bhima could be quite the softy.


He thought of the twins, Nakula and Sahadeva. He knew, that contrary to what his friend thought, they were both different. Nakula was light hearted at his best and positively awe-inspiring at his angriest. He may not have been the warrior Bhima was, but he was skilled with the sword. By observation, he also knew that he regarded Yudhishthira as a father-figure, more than a brother.


Sahadeva, while similar in his beliefs and views to Nakula, was the quieter twin, the more contemplative one. He had a way with words, his eyes held a quiet passion, that somehow barely ever was on display. He too, like his eldest brother and twin, showed that unwillingness did not guarantee incapacity.


Finally, he thought of Arjuna. His arch-enemy, his competitor, his brother. There was no doubt, in Karna's heart of hearts, who was the better warrior. He would be up against him in battle if he chose Suyodhana, but the question was, despite his claims to Rajmata Kunti, would he succeed in lifting his bow against Arjuna?


Contemplatively, he walked towards his father's house, in Hastinapura. Perhaps, he would get answers there? But how could he choose?


Edited by Shrinika13 - 8 years ago
Seraphina231 thumbnail
9th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 8 years ago
#3
Now, this brings me to my question.
There are two possible things Karna could have done:
1. He left the Kauravas, after realising where dharma lay.
2. He decided not to fight the war.

Remember this is an AU, and do drop in your opinion along with your comments on this OS, and I will write a sequel that depends on your answers.

Ciao for now.
Like thoko, review karo, and I will be back. :)
RamKiSeeta thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Achiever Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 8 years ago
#4
Wow Shre, I loved this! 👏 The conversation between Karna and Kunti was well written, but my favorite part was Karna's introspection regarding each of the Pandavas. Despite being their "enemy", he truly understands them, and that's part of the tragedy in his death. He was not as evil as Duryodhana, and yet he too had a flawed sense of Dharma that prevented him from making the right choice.

Regarding a sequel, I would love to read one on Karna joining the Pandavas, but somehow...I simply cannot see him doing that. I feel like Karna kind of did have a point, in that it would be disloyal of him to fight against Duryodhana, because Duryodhana did provide him with friendship when he was insulted by everyone. Of course, I have my own beliefs about Duryodhana's intentions being not so pure, and him using Karna for his selfish reasons, but from Karna's perspective, he kind of owed it to Duryodhan that if he didn't fight for him, he at least wouldn't fight against him.

I think the realistic and most ethical decision Karna could have taken was to remain neutral, and to not fight in the war. He could be like Balarama, supporting both sides in different ways but choosing not to fight himself due to personal dilemma.
MJ_1009 thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Achiever Thumbnail + 7
Posted: 8 years ago
#5
very well written ...great job
Ramya_98 thumbnail
Book Talk Reading Challenge Award - Pro Thumbnail 10th Anniversary Thumbnail + 7
Posted: 8 years ago
#6
This was beautifully written. The conversation, the contemplation and the way karna thinks about each of his brothers was brought out well.
I personally don't think Karna would've sided with the pandavas. Nor would he have chosen to step out of the war because not only was he loyal to duryodhana but he also wanted to prove his supremacy over arjuna and his worth as a warrior in a way. But still, i would prefer the second option.
Update soon!
Edited by --Elara-- - 8 years ago
sambhavami thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
#7
So well written! Loved Karna's thoughts about the Pandavas! Do continue soon!
Dreamer3003 thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Trailblazer Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 8 years ago
#8
I have always wondered wat wouldve happened if karna sided with the pandavas😳
But as far as i've heard,read and understood about karna is that he was always loyal to duryodhana and considered him as his dear friend!!😊
Excited to read the nxt part of this😳
MsChanadlerBong thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 8 years ago
#9
beautiful os Shri! This event is one the most disappointing event of the epic for me. Being a Karn admirer, I just get annoyed thinking how selfish Kunti was acting.
The conflicting feelings of Karn was well shown. Now thou I always wondered what would have happened if Karn chose the Pandavs, I really don't think he would have. First of all, he was debated to his friend. Being the loyal friend he was, he obviously would have chosen his friend over those who had insulted him all along. He was in a promise with Duryodhan as like said in Bahubali, a Kshetriya's dharm lies in his promise. Karn neither would have turned his side to greater Dharm cause for him, his dharm was towards his friend and nor would he have betrayed his friend and left the battlefield.

SenAnu thumbnail
10th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Networker 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
#10
Amazing idea!!
In my opinion, what Karna did was his Dharma and what he did not was His Dharma :)

*Detailed Part Later this Week*

Love
Anu !

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".