Why Aditya's 10 minutes with Jhanvi was key

KhatamKahani thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail Networker 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
#1
I really have to appreciate the writers for what they did. Jhanvi did the right thing by cutting herself off and trying to move away and go on. While they teased that Jhanvi may go inside the house while Baba was having his breakdown, etc, she never ends up going in. And she continues to ignore Aditya's calls.

In all of this, Jhanvi is right. Because there comes a point in romantic love where you cannot just give, give, give, help, help, help--and fall deeper, become more entangled and hurt yourself further.

But Aditya showed up and asked for 10 minutes. What he needed those 10 minutes for was key. If Jhanvi had picked up his calls, it would not have made clear whether he needs her for her 'super helping/problem solving skills' or whether he needs her as a companion. If Jhanvi had walked into the house that morning, again she would clearly be the problem solver for Adi and the family.

I am not saying Aditya thinks of Jhanvi only his problem solver and not his friend or companion. He sees her as a companion and friend whom he can always turn to and who will help him in his problems.

But what was made clear with Aditya's visit, is that Jhanvi does hold a high place in Aditya's life and heart. He turned up at her door not for help, not for ideas on how to solve his newest problem, but simply because he needed to confide in her and talk to her. He doesn't tell her about Nisha's blackmail (because if he had she would not have been surprised when Babasa told her), but sought her out and needed to talk to her just to tell her of what had happened to his daughter and pour out his grief of all that's happening.

And then after he left Jhanvi's he calls Nisha and agrees to have her back. Because he needed to get some sort of comfort with Jhanvi's presence before subjecting himself to the defeat/hell.

So today, when Jhanvi goes back to Aditya's house. It is because she has seen that not only does Aditya and his family need her help, but that Aditya himself needs her, Jhanvi.

Created

Last reply

Replies

9

Views

1.6k

Users

5

Likes

22

Frequent Posters

alpha78 thumbnail
9th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
#2
Totally agree with you. Aditya was totally broken & needed some energy, comfort whatever you say to accept the reality. He can't show his pain, anger in front of his family because he cares for them but he really gets some strength to face the problem from Jhanvi.
I totally agree with Jhanvi's mothers words that he didn't know what he feels for her. But he really needs her. In the meeting he didn't asked her why she didn't pick her call or why she is behaving like this but only tell her what happened to him. It was the best scene of yesterday's episode.
KhatamKahani thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail Networker 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
#3
^ Yes, I watched that scene a few times. And today the look between them when Aditya saw Jhanvi, then again in Babasa's room where he quietly just remembers asking her to stay and going to her the night before.

Not quite sure what he was thinking, but somehow I think he realizes she didn't leave due to him.
Minionite thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
#4
So far I've been a silent reader here, but reading your post I felt like I just had to comment.

I agree with you. There was a lot in that scene. I read so much more into it. Aditya went to her drunk. Not because he couldn't face the situation he was in, but because he couldn't face Jhanvi sober and just talk, just let out his grief. If he had gone their sober, he would have ended up questioning Jhanvi on why she's acting the way she is. He went their drunk because he needed to let those inner feelings out. It's often said that we speak the truth when drunk, but not only that we often speak what is hidden when drunk.

One thing I noticed in that scene is how Aditya sat outside. He didn't come in. For me that said more than the words. It said that Aditya wasn't imposing himself on Jhanvi. If Jhanvi didn't want to hear him, she didn't have to. But if she did, he would stay only the 10 minutes. Not a minute more, which is what happened. It also said that he respected Jhanvi and her decision. She wanted to leave. She wanted to move. And she didn't want to tell him why. He respected that and if he went into the house then he might have turned to that topic again. Instead he chose the safety of the outside so that he would speak to her and let his grief out before going back to his sad world.

Why did he ask for only 10 minutes? And why didn't he stay back? That question was haunting me so I went back and watched that scene a few times and then a few of the scenes from today. And I realized that he asked for 10 minutes because he didn't want Jhanvi's reactions. He didn't want her care, her solutions, her sympathy. Nothing. Not because he didn't care about her or because he was angry, but because if he stayed back to those reactions, he would break down and he wouldn't be able to leave and do the thing he did, which is call Nisha back. And even when Jhanvi made a move to stop him, he just left because he had to move on to the hell that was coming before he became weak.

I agree with you on how the scene showed that Aditya needed Jhanvi. Not just her companionship or her friendship, but her as a person. It was the closest he came to speaking of the love that he doesn't even know of yet. Will he ever realize it? I hope so and indications are that he might. He is slowly starting to see that Jhanvi isn't just his friend or a problem-solver. She's more to him. When she announced she was going to Dubai or she tried to pull away from him, he became angsty. He felt like he was losing someone. He asked her again and again to not leave, to not go, to stay. And now that she's back in the house, it's quite visible that he sees her in a new light. I just hope that while both go up against Nisha, Aditya does realize that Jhanvi is right for him and that an age difference doesn't stop him from saying it.
KhatamKahani thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail Networker 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
#5
^^Beautiful analysis. You have gone even deeper and I agree.

Aditya and Jhanvi have talked outside her house like that a few times, but here it tells so much more. Also, Adi stopped her from giving any answer or explanation when he said she wasn't picking up his calls. He wasn't there to ask why or question it, like you said.

And today, Aditya the way he seemed to be either slowly realizing something, or seeing Jhanvi in a new light as you said. I watched it a few times. It's just really beautiful.
celina30 thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
#6
Poor guy is just getting over an awful marriage- they all need to give him time. I think the last thing on his mind right now should be re-marriage - his emotions are probably in turmoil and his priority is his children. Janvi and Baba should just be his friend and support for now- im sure his feelings will start to grow in a different direction, given time and space
KhatamKahani thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail Networker 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
#7
^^ I agree, Babasa was too early in bringing up marriage for Adi, let alone to Adi. Jhanvi and her mother also should have realized and pointed that out.

Jhanvi's decision to confess was not wise, either.

However, her reactions after hearing Adi say he won't get remarried is understandable and just. Because Babasa had brought hope to her, whereas earlier she had not any expectation and hope. She only realized earlier what she would have realized later on anyway. That she keeps falling in love with him, and it's not good for her to be in this situation.

Now that she's back, things should just happen as they happen in its own time and space.

All that being said, I hope we see Jhanvi working, or at least let us know that she's working. Is she still 'caretaker' of Babasa? Is that her work, now?
KhatamKahani thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail Networker 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
#8
And this subplot of Jhanvi 'moving' ended nicely today.

I believe Aditya knew she wasn't leaving, and simply was getting confirmation. I really do appreciate the character of Aditya, how mature he is and how he phrased it. He let her answer him in the negative, hence continuing the unimposing nature of his visit the night earlier.

And Jhanvi gave a complete answer that she wasn't going anywhere and not leaving him. :)
Minionite thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
#9
I agree that Babasa shouldn't have brought up the topic of remarriage so quickly. I was flabbergasted when he first said it. I was like "Seriously dude? The guy just got rid of his first wife. He hasn't even divorced her. And you're asking about remarriage? You're f----ing mad."

I did like that closure as well. What I liked best was how Jhanvi ended with "and not you". She's opening up, but subtly. And Aditya's expressions said that he was surprised, but glad. It's like he didn't expect to hear that, but was glad to hear it.
Poulami11 thumbnail
9th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
#10
Just love what you have written, & how beautifully you have explained the total emotions out there.👏
Indeed the scene was from the most brilliant one.
Adi himself didn't know how much he became close to Jaanvi.
What we have seen is tht Jaanvi is in love with Aditya, though we know Adi has also came a long way crossing tht barrier of just Friend, but still the LOVE is not confirmed for his side, We still don't know if he loves her or not.. For jaanvi it was tough to leave Aditya but it was equally tough to live infront of him hiding her love. There were still some barrier between them.
But tht 10 minutes part has broken all thr barrier. A man in his such extremely vulnerable condition try to find a place where he can sit with peace, try to find someone to whom he can trust blindly , try to find a strong shoulder, a tight embrace of trust, love & mental peace. & For Adi unknowingly Jaanvi became tht place, tht person, tht shoulder, tht embrace.
Jaanvi became the light of his darkness.

A very special thanks to CVs for such brilliant storyline, brilliantly shaping up the characters. Hats of to them..

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".