Nach baliye a show gone awry

BombayTroll thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Achiever Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 8 years ago
#1
I have to say this years nach baliye has fond off track

There is no originality and then there is no moral compass

It is clear

Vaibhav who is choreographer of dt and dahiya is plagarising most of his earliwrwork

And you would be astonished to find that robot act which dahiya did was a ripoff from Vaibhav own rajini act he did and that too with sanam on did years back

I would also like to point out that I did not appreciate the act mohit Sanaya did on 26/11 mumbai attack

It was most horrific tragedy in the history of Mumbai and to recreate that just for a good score was inflicting more wounds on the city and ppl who were devasted by that tragedy


And finally it is clear that ppl who do not deserve it are going ahead in show

Created

Last reply

Replies

7

Views

1.5k

Users

5

Likes

31

Frequent Posters

luvakanksha thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 8 years ago
#2
I m not at all a divek fan but calling vaibhav's work plagiarism is a bit unfair according to me yes its repetitive but not a copy.
Because the definition of plagiarism is-
the practice of taking someone else's work or ideas and passing them off as one's own.
Its his own work which he is using on some other dancers.

Also i guess dance is an art where u can n u shd express yourself. Now that expression could be a highly sensitive matter too. Monaya's act was emotionally draining but sometimes dance can b that. There are many dance acts both indian n international on wars, martyrdom, etc. Their are even many songs. There is a film made on 26/11, there is a film called border on india pak war. There was a film called sarbhjit neerja etc. Art is a way of expressing now to limit those expression only to comfortable subjects would not b right.

N i dont think undeserving are going ahead monaya, sanam abigail even sidharth trupti deserve top 3 according to me.
Edited by luvakanksha - 8 years ago
SimiSays thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 8
Posted: 8 years ago
#3

Originally posted by: RightWingTroll

I have to say this years nach baliye has fond off track

There is no originality and then there is no moral compass

It is clear

Vaibhav who is choreographer of dt and dahiya is plagarising most of his earliwrwork

And you would be astonished to find that robot act which dahiya did was a ripoff from Vaibhav own rajini act he did and that too with sanam on did years back

I would also like to point out that I did not appreciate the act mohit Sanaya did on 26/11 mumbai attack

It was most horrific tragedy in the history of Mumbai and to recreate that just for a good score was inflicting more wounds on the city and ppl who were devasted by that tragedy


And finally it is clear that ppl who do not deserve it are going ahead in show


@bold

In that case, Bharti Harsh shouldn't have performed the contemporary act where she paid a tribute to her late father, because it would inflict wounds on everyone in the world who lost their fathers.

In that case, Ashka Brent shouldn't have performed the trio act with Sneha where they show the parents died, since it will inflict wounds on everyone who is an orphan.

In that case, Shoaib-Dipika shouldn't have performed the army act, since every other day, army officers are dying at the border, so it would inflict more wounds on people with an army background.

In that case, Sid-Trupti shouldn't have performed that emotional act where Trupti dies, since it will inflict wounds on people who have lost their spouse.

The whole point here is, Monaya did that act as a part of art, expression, which is exactly what dance is about.
In Remo's own words: Dance to express not to impress, and that's exactly what they did.

They expressed!
The sadness, the melancholy, the mayhem, the helplessness.

And in the end, gratitude.
For the brave soldiers who perished while rescuing those trapped and also to god, for giving us two hands, two legs and a life to live! Like San said, we complain a lot but we should just be happy to know how blessed we are that we are okay!

I don't understand why you have to bring in such an angle for that act.
You didn't like the performance-- Cool! It's your opinion.
But saying it was recreated just for ''good scores'' is too shallow of an opinion.
BombayTroll thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Achiever Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 8 years ago
#4

Originally posted by: luvakanksha

I m not at all a divek fan but calling vaibhav's work plagiarism is a bit unfair according to me yes its repetitive but not a copy.

Because the definition of plagiarism is-
the practice of taking someone else's work or ideas and passing them off as one's own.
Its his own work which he is using on some other dancers.

Also i guess dance is an art where u can n u shd express yourself. Now that expression could be a highly sensitive matter too. Monaya's act was emotionally draining but sometimes dance can b that. There are many dance acts both indian n international on wars, martyrdom, etc. Their are even many songs. There is a film made on 26/11, there is a film called border on india pak war. There was a film called sarbhjit neerja etc. Art is a way of expressing now to limit those expression only to comfortable subjects would not b right.

N i dont think undeserving are going ahead monaya, sanam abigail even sidharth trupti deserve top 3 according to me.




Well

Then it is called stale choreography

When you repeat nearly same act it is called copying or plagarising even if it is own work


Once it is ok but many times is not done

BombayTroll thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Achiever Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 8 years ago
#5

Originally posted by: Simi1711



@bold

In that case, Bharti Harsh shouldn't have performed the contemporary act where she paid a tribute to her late father, because it would inflict wounds on everyone in the world who lost their fathers.

In that case, Ashka Brent shouldn't have performed the trio act with Sneha where they show the parents died, since it will inflict wounds on everyone who is an orphan.

In that case, Shoaib-Dipika shouldn't have performed the army act, since every other day, army officers are dying at the border, so it would inflict more wounds on people with an army background.

In that case, Sid-Trupti shouldn't have performed that emotional act where Trupti dies, since it will inflict wounds on people who have lost their spouse.

The whole point here is, Monaya did that act as a part of art, expression, which is exactly what dance is about.
In Remo's own words: Dance to express not to impress, and that's exactly what they did.

They expressed!
The sadness, the melancholy, the mayhem, the helplessness.

And in the end, gratitude.
For the brave soldiers who perished while rescuing those trapped and also to god, for giving us two hands, two legs and a life to live! Like San said, we complain a lot but we should just be happy to know how blessed we are that we are okay!

I don't understand why you have to bring in such an angle for that act.
You didn't like the performance-- Cool! It's your opinion.
But saying it was recreated just for ''good scores'' is too shallow of an opinion.




I haven't commented upon their performance Perse

I just did not like the idea of using an massive tragedy in city history

It was indeed for marks as they did get marks for it

And I find it shallow to use This for dance act

SimiSays thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 8
Posted: 8 years ago
#6

Originally posted by: RightWingTroll




I haven't commented upon their performance Perse

I just did not like the idea of using an massive tragedy in city history

It was indeed for marks as they did get marks for it

And I find it shallow to use This for dance act


To each their own.
Selective thinking has no cure.
Zennia thumbnail
Most Posts (December 2024) Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 8
Posted: 8 years ago
#7
Monaya are improving their performance. So I don't mind them. But I don't like divek at all. Also the Marathi couple. The lady is overweight and doesn't know how to manage it
nik1310 thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Commentator Level 3 Thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
#8

Originally posted by: ZadayKiDaig

Monaya are improving their performance. So I don't mind them. But I don't like divek at all. Also the Marathi couple. The lady is overweight and doesn't know how to manage it


To each their perspective.

I infact commend Trupti (if you are meaning them) for being a part of this show. She is comfortable with her looks and so is her partner, I do not see the problem then. Being on the heavier side is not shameful, its perfectly ok and Trupti is showing that weight should not prevent one from having a good time dancing. This would give confidence to other women who restrict themselves from having a good time. It is a dance reality show alright but there are other facets to it that are equally vital than just dancing skills.
Edited by nik1310 - 8 years ago

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".