Meghna's hurtful wards of Karan - Page 3

Poll

Do you think they re justified or not

Login To Vote

Created

Last reply

Replies

23

Views

1.4k

Users

9

Likes

88

Frequent Posters

malikakas thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail Visit Streak 30 Thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
#21

Originally posted by: adhyakumarijha

Meghna has anger issues and she always ends up messing up

Agree or not she does needs to concentrate on that

I agree with most of her point but the fact that she is always right is a wrong conception



Sorry I should explain.. I don't think Meghna is always right. But I do respect her ability to stand up against injustice. I get frustrated with Naina's passivity. Personally I think both sisters balance each other out. Naina can help Meghna slow down *sometimes* and Meghna can help Naina stand up for herself *sometimes*.


This is one place where I do think Meghna is right because it was something that should've been addressed much much earlier. For all intents and purposes, Karan is an ill person not capable of fulfilling a normal marriage from a general standpoint. That doesn't mean he should be discarded or uncared for but I don't think that's what Meghna was saying.


She is saying it shouldn't be Naina's duty or responsibility to look after Karan at the expense of her own life. Naina shouldn't have to sacrifice her ability to have a normal life to accommodate for his disabilities. Not when the marriage happened as a condition. Even if Karan is the nicest guy in the world that is still not a fair trade for Naina.


Naina can say she is okay with it... but is this really the happiest version of life she could've had? That's what Meghna was asking her. Meghna also claimed she was okay with letting go of Kunal but Naina knew that that wouldn't be the happiest version of Meghna's life. So Naina didn't let Meghna make that choice. So now its Meghna's responsibility to ensure the happiest version of Naina's life.
Agni_Jytsona thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
#22

Originally posted by: malikakas


Sorry I should explain.. I don't think Meghna is always right. But I do respect her ability to stand up against injustice. I get frustrated with Naina's passivity. Personally I think both sisters balance each other out. Naina can help Meghna slow down *sometimes* and Meghna can help Naina stand up for herself *sometimes*.


This is one place where I do think Meghna is right because it was something that should've been addressed much much earlier. For all intents and purposes, Karan is an ill person not capable of fulfilling a normal marriage from a general standpoint. That doesn't mean he should be discarded or uncared for but I don't think that's what Meghna was saying.


She is saying it shouldn't be Naina's duty or responsibility to look after Karan at the expense of her own life. Naina shouldn't have to sacrifice her ability to have a normal life to accommodate for his disabilities. Not when the marriage happened as a condition. Even if Karan is the nicest guy in the world that is still not a fair trade for Naina.


Naina can say she is okay with it... but is this really the happiest version of life she could've had? That's what Meghna was asking her. Meghna also claimed she was okay with letting go of Kunal but Naina knew that that wouldn't be the happiest version of Meghna's life. So Naina didn't let Meghna make that choice. So now its Meghna's responsibility to ensure the happiest version of Naina's life.


See you are entirely missing the point I don't have any issues with Meghna standing for what is right I only and only had prob with the words she used for Karan just with that and nothing else
Her anger was justified and I have always loved her for standing up for what is right
even I get frustrated from Naina sometimes that girl needs reality check on sone of the matter

Lastly I agree that both sisters balance each other
SilverBell thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
#23
I Know Meghna Is Protecting Her Little Sis Naina. Still Calling Karan A Medical Person Wasn't Right. Karan Heard Her Saying That. Aww. That Was Mean Of Meghna.
--Amulya-- thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 8 years ago
#24

Originally posted by: malikakas


If she loses Kunal she loses Kunal. I don't want Meghna to change the core aspects of her personality which stands up against wrong things. What happened to Naina was wrong.


For me, Meghna yesterday wasn't about anger. She would've been able to tell Sharda if she was that short tempered and impulsive. She was thinking.


I guess for me, I agreed with Meghna because I do think Naina has been Karan's nurse. What happiness has Naina gotten post marriage? Karan is a lovely person but Naina hasn't gotten the joy of marriage. Obviously as an audience we know that she will in the future.


But if things were to stay as they were-- Naina got duped. Why was she forced into marrying a man who couldn't give her a proper marriage?

Bang ON!!

I could've totally stood up for Karan or his family if any one person was frank with Naina and she was given the choice to marry an ill person, even after marriage Karan was outright harsh and played tricks on Naina instead he could've just chosen to reveal the truth. If Naina ever knew about Karan's disease it was by accident otherwise she wouldn't. Why are you girls missing out on the simple thing that Naina din't willingly chose to marry an ill person!! she chose to marry a person with whom she thought she can lead a happy life someday and how can you forget she too had hopes for a happy married life before knowing about Karan's illness.

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".