Why Shivaay Both Over AND Underestimates Mahi-And How It Will Cost Him

napstermonster thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail + 7
Posted: 8 years ago
#1

Shivaay knows that Ranveer is involved in all this. There was that odd beat of a pause between him being addressed by Ranveer as Mahi, and the cool "why are you being so informal?."I think it was to indicate a lightbulb moment for our SSO. Ranveer's weak ass excuse- "Sorry, I got carried away" makes no sense, if you think about it. Ranveer has never used anything but the respectful "aap" and the formal Mr. Oberoi/Shivaay, even during the Roka. Now, suddenly Ranveer uses "tu" with him, which, other than Om, no one has ever even THOUGHT in relation to SSO? Come on. Too odd, and Shivaay realizes it-- he looks at Ranveer, struck. So. Let's assume, for a moment, that Shivaay knows.


So why would he still expose the plan?


I think Shivaay, with this split second realization dawning about Ranveer's link to Mahi, changed his initial plan. Tonight, we cut to Soumya being smart as all hell, and when we come back, Ranveer is looking grim and Shivaay is calmly telling him about Fake Shivaay and the need to INVESTIGATE him.


Not about the Oberoi's plot to capture him in their own net. The portion of the plan Shivaay exposed to Ranveer this evening, is not the fake Khanna murder bit-- but about him being a police officer, and looking into this fake Shivaay, finding out who the mastermind is, finding out what his motives are. These are completely normal things to look into-- but the counter plan of the murder plot by the Oberois was not revealed.


This is a common tactic in war. You take the battle to the enemy's home turf. You set HIM on the defensive, you reveal you KNOW him, you suspect him, you are coming for him. Since these three have been counting on NOT being caught, the sudden realization that
(A) everyone knows about Mahi (B) Shivaay is back home, with his entire family and all his resources behind him and (C) they suspect this plot to be BIGGER than Mahi. All these suddenly coming out will freak Ranveer and Kamini out. Good for you, Shivaay-- you will force them to make a mistake out of panic or nervousness.


Obviously this is an incredibly risky move, but Shivaay Singh Oberoi is nothing if not a risk taker. The problem is, actually, he is so used to making these huge decisions by himself, expecting others to be perfect as well, and executing his strategies, he forgets the core issue--- he is human, with a human being's vulnerabilities. As is his family. In dismissing Mahi as just a pawn being played by bigger players, he has forgotten one essential thing--

Mahi is a deeply disturbed, mentally troubled man.

All the cute tapori dialogue and pity inducing back story should not blind us to this-- Mahi is emotionally on a hair trigger. He has a vicious temper and he is uncontrollable when he is angry or threatened. I swear, this aspect of his nature makes me think he's Shivaay's twin more than anything else they could've come up with-- but while Shivaay retreats behind icy plotting and controlled destruction when enraged, Mahi goes for fire and violence.


Mahi has already revealed his corrosive, deep envy for Shivaay himself. It was one thing to be so unlucky while looking like Shivaay. Whether because he is Shivaay's illegitimate brother or just as a coincidence, looking like him has already played a number on this guy's head-- now he knows Shivaay's blessed life, too. Mahi compares them, and enjoys the thought of never letting Shivaay come back to his home. Not to mention, we have Mahi's new found need to take over Shivaay's life. More than just getting money for his mother, Mahi has his own plan. He wants to enjoy what his doppelganger has, to never return to the chawl that spawned him in the dirty "naali". If Shivaay or Anika do anything to challenge Mahi's ability to GET these things for himself, he will react much more violently than either the cool Ranveer or the greedy Kamini will.


If Anika's reveal to Mahi is real-- which it looks like it might be, since she names Ranveer to Mahi as one of the plotters-- Shivaay's juggling act will crash to the ground. Why has Mahi simply revealed himself to Anika in the precap? Because he knows the game is now up, with her knowing about them. He will attack her. Best case scenario, he will stuff her with Soumya. But I think it's going to be-- worst case scenario. He will put a gun to her head or a knife at her throat to try and fight his way out of the Mansion. He was never in this for the money, he panics when the situation gets tough, and I think he is becoming just a touch manic right now.


I think we are building to a show-down with the whole family, (including Shivaay), and to a full reveal on who the hell Mahi is and why he hates the Oberois. Why he needs them to HURT. And his biggest envy, the focus of his twisted desires and his full fledged jealousy by now is Shivaay Singh Oberoi, the man who has everything. Mahi has no feelings for Anika. But if this is the final showdown-- Mahi won't go down without taking at least SOMETHING away from the too blessed, too lucky, too perfect Ram Bhagwan who has a huge family, a proud name, unbelievable money, and even love.

He will take the only thing from Shivaay he can take quickly, something that will END Shivaay, gut his nemesis if he loses it. He will take Anika. That gun will go off, or the knife will strike, and my gut feeling, my loves?


It wont be Khanna falling.

Edited by napstermonster - 8 years ago

Created

Last reply

Replies

19

Views

3.1k

Users

17

Likes

125

Frequent Posters

LilyJames0194 thumbnail
9th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 30 Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 8 years ago
#2
Hi Napstermonster!!! You seem to be back with a bang! 😆

1. Thank you for mentioning that weird pause (SSO and Ranveer Scene)... I was actually confused about it..but then with SSO's usual behaviour of flipping from being Smart Singh Oberoi to Stupid Singh Oberoi, I am still uncertain whether he has actually thought any of these 😆


2. You are absolutely right about Mahi slowly revealing his absolutely maniac side - I feel that apart from now becoming rather comfortable in play-acting SSO (the scene where Annika and Khanna are so obviously trying to push his buttons...his dismissive nods..words - I actually was unsure myself whether this was SSO or Mahi? 😲)...it is now becoming increasingly apparent that this man is actually really disturbed. He has had a miserable..almost tragic past (which in no way justifies what he is doing) is supposed to be explanatory for his almost-maniac like need to get away from all of it.

And the way he has now seen how Shivaay is treated here at OM, I doubt he can go back to being the uncared...forgotten..rejected person.



If the CVs are still planning on pursuing the Half-Brothers/Twin theory, I think this parallel if executed well would indeed be beyond beautiful. Because as you mentioned, SSO and Mahi are really polar opposites yet almost beautifully similar in so many ways - oxymoron.

Also, there is another beautiful underlying concept that I think could be well - explored in this instance... the paradox of the ignorance veil. While Mahi was 'just Mahi' he was used to his life - it angered him, made him bad...(not very bad though)...but now this.. having had a chance to be SSO... having now known what it almost-feels like to feel accepted.. I doubt he can go back to being 'Just Mahi' again. Thus leading to two scenarios - turning completely negative (easy), or flipping to the good side.

Did you ever see Rizwaan-Preet? Something like this in a way no? And wasn't it Harneet who was the writer even there? 😲😆

Uff... too heavy suddenly! 😛😆
Anyway, have missed your posts!! xx
Edited by LilyJames0194 - 8 years ago
ShruthiLuv thumbnail
Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
#3
You got a point, I was confused for a while why he is not telling Ranveer about Murder plan.because he changed the Plan.
Woww I am loving this drama..
AnnzSageflower7 thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 8 years ago
#4
And Navin returns in style !! 👏 what a post my friend, I MISSED YOU!!
Imagine if SSO engaged Ranveer (I am doubting he is an ACP at all right now, nothing but a con-fraud) , to get the proof he needs to catch the mastermind.

All this started with Ranveer and the appearance of Kamini. The only two strange new individuals swelling around their lives right now with plenty to gain from a scandal.

He keeps mentioning CCTV to monitor and catch everything. He needs proof of accomplices. I bet Oberoi security is busy surveying everything and keeping stock.

My guess is Kamini and ACP will knock Shivaay over the head and take him away again. And Mahi will threaten Annika with his safety, and she will have to play along with him.

There must be a reason, all those comedy scenes have been put there. The family will realize that Annika is acting weird, with their code words: Bablu and Oye-oye, she can communicate and inform.

Plus the murder staging scene is still top secret. If Mahi remains as Shivaay , that maay create a lot of troubles for him.

I just am not sure how the Kamini-Shakti affair angle will be brought in. Perhaps at the end, after a big showdown. There's still Prinku's pregnancy to reveal.

What a tangle..

But what fun! SO looking forward to next week!
Good to see you back !!
Edited by AnnzSageflower7 - 8 years ago
Rachna.KG thumbnail
9th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
#5
I am so glad that you are back. I was missing your words, terribly...love reading your analysis and insights. It just makes so much sense. Well I couldn't detect change in Shivaay after hearing from Ranveer. I usually tune out when it comes to not so positive parts... Sometimes I wonder if Gul had to make this as a Romantic Thriller because I find that the writers always mess in the name of "thrill". I know many on the forum would like to see hurt Anika and caring Shivaay and I have to admit I wouldn't mind it either. Expression of love in any form is welcome :)

What you are saying does make sense because he has been calling Pinki and Anika as his strength a lot lately so both of them are going to get hurt, one emotionally and other physically.
ancy19 thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
#6
That was well analysed and it looks like I misunderstood or underestimated Shivaay here. I for one found the Murder trap unreasonable and full of flaws...Going with that flow ...thought Shivaay made a royal mess of it. by confiding in ACP...

When pushed to extremes Mahi resorts to violence ( tht was shown in FB) and he is likely to hurt Annika now that his game is up. No way is he going to give in easily ...he has nothing to lose...So he might end up hurting Annika

Right now ( based on what we have seen) Mahi hates Oberois for all those he is not and doesnt have. The wound of rejection is festered by Kameeni .Mahi's hatred for Oberois is a byproduct of Kameeni's evil plans.



Ultimatewinnerr thumbnail
8th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
#7
Brilliant post
Now as everyone is speculating i too think somebody is gonna hurt in the end, not sure who, but most probably mahi or anika, mahi because CVS had to end the track of mahi orelse anika as it will give lot of shivika n trp😉, but we might also see a smooth ending to this track too, who knows
But i hope these questions get answered properly during this track

1) exact connection of mahi n shivay
2) reason of mahi's haterd towards pinky
3)who will save sawmiya
4) purpose n effect of this track on characters of ib
5)is ranveer positive or negative
6)is prinku pregnancy real or fake
PS: thanks for making post
farinaks thumbnail
8th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 8 years ago
#8
I too had a feeling dat something will happen to anika ..coz cv's r making it is cheezy nowadays nd it will end in something so horrible
chandran.rudra0 thumbnail
10th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
#9
Thanks for being back navin.
Really missed you in the forum.
Next week will be ultimate showdown.
Mahi is slightly revealing his maniac side.
But i still think shivaay underestimated mahi.
I hope they end this imposter track next week.
pickachu thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 180 Thumbnail + 8
Posted: 8 years ago
#10
Amazingg post!
I also feel that shivaay did not tell abt murder plan to ranveer.
I made post on it too🤡.

Yep shivaay and mahi r opposite but their anger is same.Shivaay express it in different way and mahi express it differently

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".