Only One Question to the Writers ..!! - Page 2

Originally posted by: RollingStones

Why Make Siddhant so Negative to a Point that people just get absolutely disconnected with him ..??

You Introduce a character , make your audience root for him and then make him Fall SOO LOW that the same audience now just Hate him and want him to just Die ..??

I get You wanted to show , One POW negative ...you wanted to show Soldier too can Change .

But Atleast ...atleast make ppl connect with him till his Last Moments ...

If you wanted to show him THIS Negative , you should have not get your viewers attached to him .

This is like Cheating your Readers ...

I seriously feel...Do Hell with Redemption of Siddhant ...

In all his Nautanki/Pagalpanti , His Friend Lost his Life , Innocents life was risked ...

I care Two Hoots now about Siddhant ...

I wish ..writers would have given a Fitting ..A Graceful End to their Creation called Siddhant Thakur ...

- A Disappointed Siddhant Fan

PS : POW Finale is turning out to be such an Irritating and Disappointing Affair ... Meh ...!!!!

Originally posted by: anshvi

I get what u r saying...the problem is these guys left so many unanswered questions when it comes to Siddhant which I have mentioned in another thread

Writers got very inconsistent with his character.

I won't say I felt disconnected to Siddhant towards the end..Infact I felt so bad when he died that I cried !

U know why

Because I saw beyond the fact that he did a big mistake coz of which Sartaj got killed.

I saw how a brave soldier , a lively guy , a loyal friend , a loving brother , a faithful husband , the best student , would be father died an extremely tragic death of a TERRORIST

how his ONE MISTAKE overshadowed all his good deeds.

He helped in release of Imaan and Sartaj

He agreed to die instead of Imaan

He was the man who stayed behind during the war coz his 2 friends were stuck..he did not leave them behind.

He was the man who loved unconditionally..pain couldn't break him but love for a child did

He was also the man who would never see his child's face , who while dying knew that he was wrong and he got played , who knew that he disappointed his sis , mentor and friends and above all his own country.

He was the man who's all good deeds and qualities no body remembered and wanted him to die. 😭

Even Imaan thought of planting RDX and Sartaj went on to plant it but both realised their mistake well before time and rectified it.

But it got too late for SIDDHANT. He had reached a point of no return.

He was the man whose perspective people will never want to understand...that he went through so much for the past 17 years. He was only HUMAN !

Like many had said that they would want to see this reality but I was always afraid that the writers will make a mess of it and they did !

People themselves said that 'A SOLIDER IS A HUMAN AND CAN CHANGE ' BUT WHEN THAT HAPPENED MOST PEOPLE GOT DISCONNECTED TO HIM AND EVEN WANTED HIM TO DIE OR SUFFER.

THEY DIDN'T SEE HIM AS A HUMAN BUT AS A TERRORIST...PEOPLE SAID WHY PUT TOO MUCH PRESSURE ON SOLDIERS BUT HERE THIS IS WHAT WE ALL DID !

HOW CAN SIDDHANT DO IT ! HE NEEDS TO DIE ! THIS IS WHAT MANY OF US HOPED

BUT DID THE THOUGHT CROSS OUR MINDS TO UNDERSTAND WHAT HE MUST HAVE GONE THROUGH..YES HE WAS A SOLDIER BUT HE WAS A HUMAN TOO BUT MOST OF US REFUSED TO SEE THAT HUMAN SIDE AND GAVE OUR JUDGEMENT - HE NEEDS TO DIE ! HE IS A TERRORIST ! AND THAT IS WHAT HAPPENED ! NO BODY UNDERSTOOD HIM AND HE WAS TERMED AS A TERRORIST.

AREN'T WE ALL TOO HARSH NOW ON A SOLDIER...WHEN EARLIER WE WANTED THE MAKERS TO SHOW THIS HUMAN SIDE OF SOLDIERS N TO SHOW THEM VULNERABLE !

BUT NOW INSTEAD OF SEEING HOW HUMAN HE WAS., HOW THE ENEMY USED HIS VULNERABILITY AND HUMANITY AGAINST HIM AND PLAYED HIM WE ONLY WANTED TO SEE A STRONG INTELLIGENT LOYAL SOLDIER WHO SHOULD HAVE APPLIED HIS BRAINS ! COZ THIS IS WHAT IS 'EXPECTED' OF A SOLDIER ...AND WE ALL EXPECTED THAT IS WHAT WE ALL DID!

EXPECTED HIM TO BEHAVE LIKE A LOYAL SOLDIER AND COMPLETELY TURNED A BLIND EYE TO HIS VULNERABLE HUMAN SIDE !

ISN'T THIS WHAT WE ALL WANTED !

WE TURNED A BLIND EYE TO SIDDHANT THAKUR - HE WAS THE ONE WHO WAS WRONGED THE MOST !

A once brave soldier died a terrorist ! I cried ! Yes i cried at the tragedy !

And that is why I BLAME THE WRITERS !

my heart went out to him...I cried for a man he once was and what he could have been if time was on his side.

For me he was the most tragic character of this show who did wrong and but was the one who was wronged the most !

AND MOST OF THE PEOPLE MISSED THE WHOLE POINT ! AND WRITERS ARE TO BE BLAMED FOR THIS !