Only One Question to the Writers ..!!

Page

1019702

Suspended

Posted: 8 years ago

Why Make Siddhant so Negative to a Point that people just get absolutely disconnected with him ..??

You Introduce a character , make your audience root for him and then make him Fall SOO LOW that the same audience now just Hate him and want him to just Die ..??

I get You wanted to show , One POW negative ...you wanted to show Soldier too can Change .

But Atleast ...atleast make ppl connect with him till his Last Moments ...

If you wanted to show him THIS Negative , you should have not get your viewers attached to him .

This is like Cheating your Readers ...

I seriously feel...Do Hell with Redemption of Siddhant ...

In all his Nautanki/Pagalpanti , His Friend Lost his Life , Innocents life was risked ...

I care Two Hoots now about Siddhant ...

I wish ..writers would have given a Fitting ..A Graceful End to their Creation called Siddhant Thakur ...

- A Disappointed Siddhant Fan

PS : POW Finale is turning out to be such an Irritating and Disappointing Affair ... Meh ...!!!!

Edited by RollingStones - 8 years ago

Quote

Frequent Posters

drHfan_in

@drHfan_in

Beginner

Posted: 8 years ago

Sid to sad jouney is horrible...un necessary...that is what am crying about very disciplined way...irked guys ladies say then why bother to watch ???

STvi is still wanting...let sid die...but as sid thakur...and national hero less painful then total betrayal ...

Forumists few of them using rather misusing writers freedom...all the rt wing line thinking is hindu bs for them...they even not appriciate some fine details ecohed else where...JNU so pampeted has resulted in terror prone harbour...we see daily...this pushes rt wing mass so much...resulting in mass anger MORE...and conciquancies...the shame ... Intellect are escorted by same military !!!!! in kashmir Floods army role is ...these guys say " what is new ??? Its their duty to perform.."

This generates and is epicenter of all - ve techs...politics go on...

Quote

Looks like you are new here. Register for free, learn and contribute.

Rafangirl

@Rafangirl

Stunner

+ 5

Posted: 8 years ago

U just spoke my heart out...can't write more...sad n depressed today

Quote

Battu

@bajarbattu

Navigator

Posted: 8 years ago

LOL... but have you ever thought of the fact, that this is how the young people are brainwashed into becoming terrorists. What you may think is bad writing, could very well be someone's life.

Young people who are indoctrinated to do bad things on the behalf of politicians who keep their own hands clean. And these young people may not necessarily be terrorists, they could be even political goons or henchmen.

I find the serial very realistic and closer to home. I loved today's precap, when Sadiq becomes Siddhant again just in one single moment, as Afreen tells him the truth about Lala. Can you imagine, we are getting worked up about a serial, and one guy because he caught our fancy in the serial, but think about the countless young men who find that when they sign up for this indoctrinated BS, they are signing on a form that is actually a point of no return.

It's more than sad. ANd when a serial addresses this issue, it is actually addressing the chaos that an individual goes through when s/he realises that he made one little mistake - s/he let emotion cloud their judgement. 😕🥱

So don't question the writers, in fact applaud them for having the guts to show something that most mainstream production houses don't dare to show, in the trp related conundrum of daily soaps. I say kudos to Star Plus too... for letting it run, even after dismal trp's .

-
Love
Battu.

Quote

582445

Hibernated

Posted: 8 years ago

Sure it's frustrating .. in fact, I never felt this frustrated watching a Hindi show. But, I won't call it bad writing .. it's not bad writing it is just too real and that's why we are feeling depressed. Don't we feel this way everyday while reading newspaper? No Hindi T.V show ever felt this real to me and perhaps this is the reason it's all raw emotion that's affecting our sense, mind, and heart so deeply.

Quote

1019702

Suspended

Posted: 8 years ago

Originally posted by: bajarbattu
LOL... but have you ever thought of the fact, that this is how the young people are brainwashed into becoming terrorists. What you may think is bad writing, could very well be someone's life.

Young people who are indoctrinated to do bad things on the behalf of politicians who keep their own hands clean. And these young people may not necessarily be terrorists, they could be even political goons or henchmen.
I find the serial very realistic and closer to home. I loved today's precap, when Sadiq becomes Siddhant again just in one single moment, as Afreen tells him the truth about Lala. Can you imagine, we are getting worked up about a serial, and one guy because he caught our fancy in the serial, but think about the countless young men who find that when they sign up for this indoctrinated BS, they are signing on a form that is actually a point of no return.

It's more than sad. ANd when a serial addresses this issue, it is actually addressing the chaos that an individual goes through when s/he realises that he made one little mistake - s/he let emotion cloud their judgement. 😕🥱

So don't question the writers, in fact applaud them for having the guts to show something that most mainstream production houses don't dare to show, in the trp related conundrum of daily soaps. I say kudos to Star Plus too... for letting it run, even after dismal trp's .

-
Love
Battu.

I applaud the writers for going this route .. Kudos to them for going Bold for actually picking up this Indoctrination subject and presenting it through a Soldier like Siddhant .

Infact I even mentioned in my main post 🤔... that I am fine if they want to show Indoctrination Issue , I know Its reality , its exits and its needs to be addressed !!!

But I do have right to question them, If I feel disappointed as a reader/watcher .

My main issue lies with the Connection that I had with Siddhant/Sadiq which got Lost today . I connected with the vulnerable Sid who got manipulated by Lala and stood up with his screwed concept of Humanity .

He may be Negative , he may represents Shrewd Reality , but He also represents a Young Soldier who fell Victim in this Trap . And a slight Human Arc to him could have helped me to remain connected to him till his last Journey .

Please note : My post is not a complain on the content but about Character presentation .

Edited by RollingStones - 8 years ago

Quote

zenjoe

@zenjoe

Navigator

+ 3

Posted: 8 years ago

Originally posted by: RollingStones

PS : POW Finale is turning out to be such an Irritating and Disappointing Affair ... Meh ...!!!!

EXACTLY my point too! This one amazing series is not exiting with a bang but with a whimper. Inconsistencies, super long and repetitive FBs and poor logic is ruining the memory of the good and gripping episodes for me.

I found Sartaj dying stupid direction. 4 Jawans already inside the basement with just one terrorist to handle. They barricaded the basement entrance with 2 heavyweight iron shelves. How come the terrorist removed the barricading without being shot by the Jawans? And how come he had such direct shots at Sartaj and that too so many!

They just had to kill Sartaj so they did, else for me that scene was really stupid. Shows that the director has a long way to go.

P.S. Lesser said the better for Sidhanth. I want to see him dead in his tracks when he sees Hussain alive in front of him. 🤢

Edited by zenjoe - 8 years ago

Quote

naq5

@naq5

Rocker

Posted: 8 years ago

Originally posted by: zenjoe

EXACTLY my point too! This one amazing series is not exiting with a bang but with a whimper. Inconsistencies, super long and repetitive FBs and poor logic is ruining the memory of the good and gripping episodes for me.

I found Sartaj dying stupid direction. 4 Jawans already inside the basement with just one terrorist to handle. They barricaded the basement entrance with 2 heavyweight iron shelves. How come the terrorist removed the barricading without being shot by the Jawans? And how come he had such direct shots at Sartaj and that too so many!

They just had to kill Sartaj so they did, else for me that scene was really stupid. Shows that the director has a long way to go.

P.S. Lesser said the better for Sidhanth. I want to see him dead in his tracks when he sees Hussain alive in front of him. 🤢

@red exactly his killling dint make sense. it was forced to me. sadiq is anyway dying why kill sartaj. i hope they dont kill iman off too. though life is a living hell for him now. i actually dont want to imagine the pain with which he will live now

Quote

drHfan_in

@drHfan_in

Beginner

Posted: 8 years ago

Such a technical guy...story needs him to die..

But he could have been saved...other ground police jawab were there karta remembered buddy body not to let behind so very stupidly re enters to be shot at. And dramatics bg scene window watch by harleen...the lower rank army guy...showing ashok chalta achievements and ...that identifier pak guy injured but comes for tea-party and seats...sartaaj ends the game by grannade !!!! Last clip. Who is aiming Sid. Now. As laptop talks ...screen revelation did occur...is it Ibrahim. Or. Vikram ??

Messing up...twist turn tragedy for sake of T3 is wasting good past work...that is painful..no doubt about talent mastery in filming...but. Marathon is about to finish why. ...careless. and sudden overdramatic ???

Edited by drHfan_in - 8 years ago