Who deserved greencards in Oct 13 round?

Who do you feel deserved greencards in Oct13 ( aired on Oct17 in USA) round?

My vote -- Debu and Himani.

- Salil

Twinkle was good in expressions only but hardly appealed to me with her singing. She was also greatly supported by good catchy music. Wheras Himani sang a more difficult number. And going by the advantage once she had because of choosing a more difficult number when Swnanda had also sang sooooo well, I guess Himani should have been in. I wonder how same singer gets advantage both ways when she sang tough one and when she did not! I do not like her attitude as well. When mentors were criticising on he singing, she was giving a strange kind of facial expression as if she did not care much about them! The biggest problem she has crated fo herself is that AS and JL both do not like her so much and if she needs a break they are the ones who make tunes suited to her. She can be at the best an item number singer. Himani will come back and give her a fight someday. Twinkle will be exposed moment same song she is asked to sing together with others. She chooses songs of her own comfort and we will see her "real" performance when she will be given fight on equality.
Among boys, Debu was good but he has been always without feelings. IMHO, these four singers and Irfan are not going to make to the final four. But let us see. Rajev is very unpredictable. I know he sings "besura" but believe me, his voice has a very different kind of "kashish" and that mesmarizes anyone. He is "truest" and "natural" singer. He will go a long way among all of these contestants. There will be many such challanges (2006, 2007...like Antakshari..may be for next 10 years, Zee is known to extract as much as they can!),and evey year there will be few winners but rarely one would come across singers of Rajeev's calibre. He is "the" find of Challange 2005, IMHO.
But I felt that Debu deserved yesterday, so I voted for Debu and Himani.

We get to see the episode late in Mid east.I saw the episode only yesterday.I think Debu was good..Rajiv very ordinary.I like Twinke and think Ismail Darbar brings out best in his Shisyas,but Himani was definitely better and desrved a green card.
Kumar Sanu sat with a grumpy face all alonge.
I thnik Rajeev's quality of voice is good and he sings with feelings but after so much training and competition it is sad to see someone so Besura reach the finals.
Kumar Sanu said Debu did not sing like Kishore Kumar...how could he..Kumar Sanu himself could never sing like the one and only Kishore Kuamr

Twinkle was rubbish. there was so much of a breathing sound. between himani and twinkle, i think the decision was a no-brainer that day.

as much as i like rajiv's voice i actually thought debojeet should of won that round and between twinkle and himani it should of been himani. i didnt like that comment made by kumar sanu about being spoilt it was just uncalled for. the advertising for hum paanch made me cringe too just no need for it, i missed 5 mins of it and just tuned in for the results.

Debu and Himani (all the way!! 😃 )

My opnion is Debu and Twinkle 😊