Can Vividha only love Ravish if Atharv is negative

whispa thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 9 years ago
#1
Lets admit it. The last few days it's been pretty exhausting to be on this forum. And it stems from mostly one discussion. Atharv turning negative.




Of course both sets of fans have opposing views about this, so I thought why not make a topic where we can all try and have a civilised discussion about whether or not Vividha can fall out of love with Atharv and in love with Ravish.

Ravish is a nice guy. He is a great son who loves his family. He married Vividha simply because his mum asked him to. Then fell in love with her.

Vividha married Ravish to save Atharv. Ever since he has come back, she has been shown to be still deeply in love with him to the point that she is willing to leave her marriage to look after him.

And Atharv? He has no clue what's going on. He simply does what everyone tells him to do. But he feels a connection to Vividha. By his own admission, he likes her the best but he doesn't understand why.

So my question is this.

Can Vividha only fall in love with Ravish if Atharv is negative?

Like I said, Ravish is a nice guy and shown to be very understanding to Vividha. He has even told her that as far as he is concerned she is no longer his wife and has promised to get her married to Atharv when he is better. He has risked his family for Atharv and Sujata. He is the perfect guy. So why isn't Vividha's heart softening towards him?

And there is no guarantee that Atharv will get better. Even Vividha has admitted that. Yet she is still willing to break her marriage to look after him. She knows that if Atharv stays this way, she will never be able to marry him. So why isn't she moving on with Ravish? Why isn't she giving her heart another chance. Why can't she let go of Atharv?


Why does Atharv have to be negative for Vividha to fall in love with Ravish?

I have made this post simply so that the forum can have a good discussion. I don't want any bashing of Ravish, Atharv or Vividha and I don't want any mocking of either fangroups. Lets be honest. We are all biased here, every single one of us. If you feel you can't comment without making fun of the characters or fangroups or using emoji's please refrain from posting.

It would be nice if this forum can have one classy discussion without chaos descending. Thank you!




Edited by whispa - 9 years ago

Created

Last reply

Replies

46

Views

6.4k

Users

25

Likes

178

Frequent Posters

ViTharvforever thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#2
cz vividha's love for atharv is so strong that she can go to any extent for him..she loves him irrespective of his state.. n atharv does the same he loves her even in this state...
if vv can fall for any other guy they would have shown it already..bt no instead they showed their bond getting more intense...so its impossible for Vividha to love ravish or any other guy unless CVs purposely turn atharv negative..
ssm97 thumbnail
10th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Visit Streak 30 Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#3
Simply great
Yes, there's no need for Atharva to turn grey or complete negative. Vividha is a mature adult and can take her decision at own

Currently, story of this trio isn't moving anywhere

In case Atharva isn't gonna recover at all, they'll end it in the current manner only with all three Virgins under the same roof :D

In case, he'll get better, surely either of one brother is gonna sacrifice, but what if vividha denies both, for whatsoever reason?

I don't want copy of HDDCS, DHADKAN or end like SAAJAN too

Looking forward for something unusual and unused DS formula
*Reemz* thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Trailblazer Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 9 years ago
#4
They're both two impossible happenings in my eyes.

Of course any show especially our Indian shows can be butchered at any time so that's why there can never be a guarantee of anything and it's also why I find this whole questioning of the endgame rather useless. It's not going to be in our control either way.


Anyway, as far as this show is concerned, from the very beginning it was promoted as Vividha & Atharv's love story (I am talking about the SP Promos) and there was that one line Kya Atharv-Vividha ki mohabbat ka yeh fitoor hoga duniya ko manzoor

I had no idea what it was referring to back then but it makes a lot of sense now. Atharv has always questioned the norms of society and rubbished them straight out, he never gave them importance over what he feels is right and just. Vividha, before Atharv had no real desires for herself - she was a bubbly Happy go lucky kind of girl who didn't realise that she had a voice. In their love story, more than anything else it's the notion that Atharv gave Vividha the courage to speak for herself, to think for herself which sets the love apart from the usual. Even now, when she's fighting for her sister there is a reflection of Atharv in the way she speaks.

So basically she carries Atharv in her wherever she goes, in whatever she does and says. Atharv has made such an impact to Vividha's whole being that he's an absolute part of her. There is a blind faith they have on each other, a soul craving of each other. How do you fall out of love with someone who has given definition to your existence?

The only way they could show Vividha fall for Ravish is via butchering. Isn't the whole point of Vitharv's love story to show that love is stronger than societal norms! I have nothing more to say than that. 😊
Edited by *Reemz* - 9 years ago
Srilathakoneti thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#5
My opinion is if atharv turn negetive then also vividha don't fall for ravish or somebody else.
Atharv turn negetive so she falls for ravish it does not happen anytime. If he turn negative or grey she fights against his bad side and get back her atharv sujatha back.

Atharv is negetive that's the only reason she falls for ravish then there is only understanding or respect
Between ravish and vividha there is no love.

I know it's never been happen,atharv never turn negative it's just my opinion for the post.
whispa thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 9 years ago
#6

Originally posted by: ViTharvforever

cz vividha's love for atharv is so strong that she can go to any extent for him..she loves him irrespective of his state.. n atharv does the same he loves her even in this state...

if vv can fall for any other guy they would have shown it already..bt no instead they showed their bond getting more intense...so its impossible for Vividha to love ravish or any other guy unless CVs purposely turn atharv negative..


This is absolutely what they are showing. That despite Atharv's mental state, Vividha's feelings for him have not decreased. If anything, they seem to be growing stronger day by day. Not even once has Vividha doubted or questioned her feelings for Atharv. So like you said, unless cv's purposefully make Atharv negative, it just seems impossible for Vividha to fall in love with Ravish.
whispa thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 9 years ago
#7

Originally posted by: mas123

Simply great

Yes, there's no need for Atharva to turn grey or complete negative. Vividha is a mature adult and can take her decision at own

Currently, story of this trio isn't moving anywhere

In case Atharva isn't gonna recover at all, they'll end it in the current manner only with all three Virgins under the same roof :D

In case, he'll get better, surely either of one brother is gonna sacrifice, but what if vividha denies both, for whatsoever reason?

I don't want copy of HDDCS, DHADKAN or end like SAAJAN too

Looking forward for something unusual and unused DS formula


Vividha's is staying with Atharv despite his mental state. And it's not because she feels sorry for him or because she blames herself for his condition. She is still deeply in love with him.

So even with Atharv shown to be mentally ill, she hasn't been able to stop loving him. So how is she going to fall in love with Ravish? Only if they make Atharv negative? If I was a Ravish fan, I would want Vividha to fall in love with him because he is a good man, not because the man she loved became negative.

As for the brothers sacrificing, there's no need to show that because Ravish has already told Vividha she can go. And vividha has already decided to be with Atharv.


Edited by whispa - 9 years ago
dreamer.ankita thumbnail
9th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#8
Atharv and Vivdha's love story has been so intense and soulful so far!
Even Atharv being mentally ill.. their bond is still strong!

Atharv can still feel vivdha's pain and for vividha, atharv is still her strength!!

Vivdha's love is so deep for Atharv that even if CVs try to mess Atharv's character and end up him being negative.. i don't think Vivdha will fall for Ravish!
Ravish is definetly a nice guy! He is very understanding towards Vitharv's relation! But that doesn't mean that vivdha will fall for him!!

She will obviously respect him, trust him but love is something that just doesn't comes up with logic and reasoning!
And We know Vividha's love for Atharv, she know that there is no guaranty that Atharv will be back to normal one day.. she knows that it might not happen... but her love is beyond that!

She loves atharv from all her heart and soul so even if Atharv is turned negative, she might just loose faith in love.. she might end up being broken but she will never fall in love with ravish because love doesn't work that way!
Just because one fine day your first love turn out to be a bad guy u will fall for the next best guy in ur vicinity!! NO!! That's not LOVE!!
Atharv turning negative will break vivdha from within because that day she will not lose Atharv but she will loose herself!! She might become lifeless again.. but she will never ever fall in love with ravish!!
Ilovecoffee thumbnail
10th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#9
If focused on current track only, situation is very clear. Vividha still loves Atharv only n hold no feelings of any kind for Ravish. Ravish has one sided love for Vividha but he also knows that Vividha love Atharv only n he respects that feeling of her so far. He knows there is no future of his relation very well. Atharv don't what had happen or happening around him for now. I agree they don't hv to make Atharv negative to Vividha fall for Ravish. If she hv to fall for him, she will anyway. As to love someone reasons r not needed.
But point is story is not moving anywhere n will not move until n unless Atharv become normal. Fighting with society for ur love is hard but to choose in btw ur relations is hardest specially when nobody is at fault. So far Atharv hv fought with society n KK only. But this time his situation would be more difficult. As shown Sujata is the only person who knows that Ravish love Vividha n she considered Ravish also as son, so from my pov she will give her full resistance for Atharv n Vividha relation. So Atharv decision would be second most imp thing.
But the most imp thing is what would Vividha do? So far she is not in any dilemma but she also hv no knowledge how Ravish feels. Since marriage makers hv not spent a second for Vividha to think abt Ravish feelings but they can do that anytime. But personally I don't want any lead to turn negative as I firmly believe good people in worst situations do exist. I want all three to stay positive n sort this mess created by their respective fathers
ARCHRE thumbnail
10th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#10
According to me , for vividha to fall in love with anybody , whether it is ravish or somebody else ... She has to first come out of her love for Atharv ... This is impossible because she just loves him completely for what we have all seen ... The intensity of the love shown between them is surreal ... Now for some reason if somebody you love turns negative .. ( I don't see it happening at all ) what would vividha do ? She will handle the situation because Atharv is involved . Their relationship has not been shown to be so fragile that it could break with a tap . She has fought his demons in the past and she will exactly do that now also ... So Atharv turning negative which is impossible can never be the reason for her equation with ravish to change 😊 ... Also their love for each other is shown such that it's madness for each other . They find their solace , peace and stability in each other ... Having said that they would both put each other ahead of themselves before they do anything that could hurt the other ... having said this Atharv can never ever be negative as the first person to shatter with this will be vividha . PEACE 😳
Edited by ARCHRE - 9 years ago

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".