what is somya's actual condition?

First Previous

Page

Frequent Posters

sparklingeyes

@sparklingeyes

Inactive

Posted: 9 years ago

#11

@naaju

i m 20 now ..i have sister who is 5 years elder to me

i had a normal childhood,going to school having friends etc

but till the day i had my 1st periods i.e during the final exams of class 5 ,i was not aware abt periods or anything relate to it

so saumya not knowing abt periods etc even after having a sister makes lot of sense to me

bcoz thats how Indian families r ..n here nimmi deliberately made sure that saumya doesn't get to know anything

Quote

naaznin

@naaznin

Sparkler

+ 10

Posted: 9 years ago

#12

Originally posted by: sparklingeyes
@naaju
i m 20 now ..i have sister who is 5 years elder to me
i had a normal childhood,going to school having friends etc
but till the day i had my 1st periods i.e during the final exams of class 5 ,i was not aware abt periods or anything relate to it
so saumya not knowing abt periods etc even after having a sister makes lot of sense to me
bcoz thats how Indian families r ..n here nimmi deliberately made sure that saumya doesn't get to know anything

u dint knew anything abt periods till u gt one..becos u must b around 9-12 yrs..bt saumya is 18-20 yrs...i cn undrstnd she doesnt knw anything till teenage bt even at marriage age she doesnt knw anything..hasnt she saw any sanitary napking ads or some lying at home n wonder wat r dose for...dint she noticed her mother n sis using dem.. ...

wat wud have happen if her husband wud have asked wats her date so as to plan suhaagraat...n she will b like "wat r u talking abt t"

u r jst 20 yrs datswhy u dnt knw dese thing im 25 datswhy i knw all dese complications...wen i was also so young i dint knew so much abt sexuality bt slowly v get to knw from different sources..

even talking abt intersex read dis article..where real intersex ppl talk hw complicated their life is ..hw dey have masculine feature n dey r nt completely feminine n even after corrective surgery dey r still nt normal..

http://www.news.com.au/lifestyle/real-life/true-stories/born-intersex-the-people-who-are-biologically-neither-male-nor-female/news-story/5bd9ce6debf9c8b4ab7ca919fb04526c

Edited by naaju - 9 years ago

Quote

Looks like you are new here. Register for free, learn and contribute.

iPerfection

@iPerfection

Navigator

Posted: 9 years ago

#13

Chill guys!

It's just a show that too an Indian show and that too by RS! 😆

Don't put so much logic and knowledge into this or your head will burst! Lol

This is not American show! Indian shows are all like this! With whatever concept they come up they will always play safe as long audience is satisfied and TRP is high who cares about making sense! 😆

Quote

sparklingeyes

@sparklingeyes

Inactive

Posted: 9 years ago

#14

Originally posted by: naaju

u dint knew anything abt periods till u gt one..becos u must b around 9-12 yrs..bt saumya is 18-20 yrs...i cn undrstnd she doesnt knw anything till teenage bt even at marriage age she doesnt knw anything..hasnt she saw any sanitary napking ads or some lying at home n wonder wat r dose for...dint she noticed her mother n sis using dem.. ...

wat wud have happen if her husband wud have asked wats her date so as to plan suhaagraat...n she will b like "wat r u talking abt t"

u r jst 20 yrs datswhy u dnt knw dese thing im 25 datswhy i knw all dese complications...wen i was also so young i dint knew so much abt sexuality bt slowly v get to knw from different sources..

even talking abt intersex read dis article..where real intersex ppl talk hw complicated their life is ..hw dey have masculine feature n dey r nt completely feminine n even after corrective surgery dey r still nt normal..

http://www.news.com.au/lifestyle/real-life/true-stories/born-intersex-the-people-who-are-biologically-neither-male-nor-female/news-story/5bd9ce6debf9c8b4ab7ca919fb04526c

i even saw sanitary pads in my childhood in my house ...my mom never told me abt them even when i asked bcoz yes i saw ads on tv but they were not clear to me till i studied abt mensuration or got one

so its not abt age ...our country is not a western country where we talk abt these things openly ...even now when i know abt periods ,me n my sister never talk abt it ..rather it is not even a topic of discussion ..n here nimmi made sure saumya don't get to know abt this..its as simple as that

n i have read innumerable blogs ,articles on net about intersex n there was even a case of the girl who after treatment was able to conceive n she was feminine n another case of a girl who after treatment had a normal sexual life but not children..n male n female intersex r different ..n its not always female having male genitals or vice versa ,they may even have ambiguous genitals ..so its a wide term ..reading one or two articles cannot give u knowledge abt it ..there r no. of different types of cases

so there r chances they can show saumya after treatment having a normal sexual life if not children ...n having children is not a big deal these days

Quote

naaznin

@naaznin

Sparkler

+ 10

Posted: 9 years ago

#15

i cnt argue more...😛

bt d only thing i wud say lastly is why r u ppl hell bent on showing saumya as intersex wen did RS said dat wen was it shown in d show??

Quote

sparklingeyes

@sparklingeyes

Inactive

Posted: 9 years ago

#16

Originally posted by: naaju
i cnt argue more...😛
bt d only thing i wud say lastly is why r u ppl hell bent on showing saumya as intersex wen did RS said dat wen was it shown in d show??

they always said saumya is adhuri i.e incomplete which points her to be intersex n which is the case most acceptable in saumya situation as u all say she is too feminine which happens in many case of intersex n this my friend who is in medical profession told me

n intersex r born with defects but tgs not always

so if people want saumya to be intersex its only to make shakti more realistic