Of Individuality and Compromise - Page 2

Created

Last reply

Replies

13

Views

2.3k

Users

14

Likes

107

Frequent Posters

cscs thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 8 years ago
#11
A very well written post. Loved the way you analysed the situation of the current track so beautifully. Sonakshi has been an achiever in her life. She is a doctor, a loved daughter and sister. She has always taken her decisions herself and her family, specially her father has given her a sense of pride. He has always appreciated her immensely (more than her brother) and is proud of her achievements. She has been told that she is the best daughter, sister, nutritionist and girlfriend. Just like her father,now her husband also never hesitates to show that how good wife she is. So, all this "good" baggage continues with her at Dixit mansion also. She wants to be a good DIL also. Adapting new culture, rituals, is all what she is doing in her new house and trying to be perfect bahu. I will not say she is loosing her individuality fully, but the day she realises the reality, she will get back to her normal self.

More than this, i feel the fear of losing Dev again is more responsible for this act. It is an internal fear and she hasn't voiced it out in front of Dev. I think she needs to do that soon. She always knew Dev loves her mother the most. During relationship she was scared that he might leave her if Ishwari says no ( before breakup mid night stroll). And her fear turned into reality and he indeed broke up because of his mother. She was hurt, heart broken and felt vulnerable. I may be wrong but after breakup she lost her decision making strength to some extent. Even being unsure she went ahead with her parents choice and agreed to get married. As you mentioned when Dev collapsed, reality strucked hard at her and she left all the practicality behind. Even after engagement fiasco she never get time to get healed. Her fear was always there, what if Dev leaves her again. She said it to Dev in anger and to Elena but never got convinced and then marriage happened suddenly. All she knows is that Dev regards his mother and family more than anything else, so she also has to do it.

I really hope when she realises Ishwari's insecurities, she will come around and will be back to her usual self.

Ps- I have read a lot of old posts on this forum (Ghatiya stalker😆) and i need to tell you that you are an amazing writer. How beautifully you describe the whole scenario. Love reading your old posts and i hope you continue expressing your thoughts. 😊
Silambu thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 8 years ago
#12

Maham, who would ever forget such an amazing writer like you.👏 I used to read your posts to always get a better perspective of the episode when you used to write so regularly. I missed your posts a lot for obvious reasons. Your posts always brightens up my day as sometime when I am so overwhelmed by different emotions and find it at times difficult to express it well. However, after reading your post...I would go like..."Yes that's exactly what I wanted to say...but here Maham has put it across so beautifully and with such simplicity that I am completely floored."😳

I loved the way, how your analysed Sona ...especially the following parts ...even I didn't think like that...but interesting thoughts esp those highlighted. Loved your thoughts.!⭐️

Highlights of your posts

1. Sona and her constant struggle with her own pride and need for validation from Ishwari.

2. Sona does have this inherent issue of pride being her fall. She also fears failure and needs to be declared perfect by everyone around

3. All that went for a toss ofcourse when Dev collapsed during her engagement and for the first time you openly saw Sona embrace her true feelings and ignore all notions of practicality. She listened to her heart rather than her mind that day but her struggle with her flaws still continues.

4. She wants Ishwari's approval and that is all she knows right now. But I can't say that Sona is simply doing this for her own self-satisfaction or that she is driven by some half-baked notion of achieving perfection and feeling worthy only when a figure of authority (In this case, Ishwari) acknowledges her efforts and loves her for the same. I think Sona is also afraid of the power Ishwari has on her relationship with Dev.

5. Instead of actually giving her relationship with Dev time, Sona has chosen to focus her energy on the person who was responsible for them breaking up and reuniting once again. If she can just win Ishwari's heart she will no longer have to live with the fear of losing Dev again.

6. I do understand the concept of a girl trying to live according to the ways of her in-laws simply because she wants them to accept her as one of their own. It's a perfectly real thing and not entirely wrong either. A little compromise is always needed.

And then you went on to say these...about she not losing her identity and be herself - Its ok to be imperfect. ! Wow...

1. on the other hand there is Sona who is trying her level best to mould herself according to the needs of her new family and be considered as one of their own. It's an interesting conflict. Balance is the key here. Your life changes after marriage, you can't really call it your own anymore. Some decisions, some choices you have to make according to the needs of your new family. However this does not mean that you also lose your own identity in the process and forget your wants and needs. I think the best thing in such situations is to sit back and really reflect over how much you are willing to change.

2. Basically Dev doesn't need another Dixit in his life. He needs a Bose. Sonakshi Bose. He needs the woman that he fell in love with and if Sona loses that person in her struggle to be the perfect bahu then the whole thing becomes quite pointless.

3. Sona needs to understand the real extent of her abilities and accept the things she cannot do and beokay with the idea of being imperfect. Perfection doesn't exist afterall.

Reading your post, I understand that there needs to be a good balance and compromise without losing one's sense of identity in the process after marriage. There's a tolerance level of everything and she should really think through this calmly and assess on what's within her capacity without overpromising to Iswari and hurting dev in the process who just likes her the way she was.

As you said marriage does changes some aspects of one's life before and after marriage. She needs to be the person she once was...but I reckon , it would not so easy to be 100% the Sonakshi she once was.

It wont be easy for her to say "NO" to everything but then again too many "Yes" also would not go well with Dev either...so she needs to find a perfect leverage between how to deal with both mother and son, while still retaining her identity but pleasing both and keeping everyone happy.!

Thank you for this wonderful post... You are truly an amazing, brilliant...awesome...writer .! Love this post to the core

So dear Maham, one request...no more disappearing act...pls come to write regularly ...I see you jump into the characters so well and bring out the best of every character to LIFE , while reading...too good!

Here's lots of hugs and kisses for coming back again and for this wonderful post!🤗

Take care

Salute!

Silambu

Edited by Silambu - 8 years ago
Samanalyse thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 8 years ago
#13
YAY!! 😃
It's so great to have you back on the forum, and I'm absolutely honoured to know I played a small part in bringing you back. 😳😆

As always, you hit the nail on the head and I completely agree with your analysis. Sona is still scared that Ishwari has the power to break her and Dev up. Dev assumes Sona knows that everything is different post-break-up, and has spectacularly failed to communicate how much he, and his relationship with Ishwari, have changed from the ramifications almost of losing Sona. Then again, he can't really communicate that without feeling like he's selling Ishwari out, which is a total no-no for him. So he tries to show it in all the small ways he can, understanding her family and culture, being aware of the challenges she might face in his household, and as much as he can, being there to defend her.

Sona, hasn't really picked up on the import of these baby steps, and still does not trust Dev entirely (like father like daughter much? 😆) She feels like the entire responsibility of the relationship is on her shoulders alone, and is proceeding to act from that premise. Until she lets Dev in on her vulnerability, which she has done all of two times till date (Dev's illness, and the engagement), he will assume she is just being stubborn and it will continue to drive a wedge between them.

If the impulsive and insensitive break-up, was Dev's form of rejection, then this cautious refusal to engage fully in their relationship until Ishwari is totally on board is Sona's.. and its going to cut Dev just as deep. I wouldn't dream of saying she is doing it on purpose, but I do think, subconsciously, she is still punishing Dev for what he did to her. She wants to be confident of her position before she lets herself be totally vulnerable to Dev, and waiting is his penance. But in punishing Dev, she is punishing herself as well, and that's where it gets really complicated. If rumours are to be believed, it won't be long until Sona's carefully repressed emotions well up and get her in trouble again!

I was totally just going to leave a note saying hi, but once I start on this show, I just can't stop! 😆
Lovely_KaranIka thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail Networker 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
#14
hello... no i dont remember you 😛😆
okay so i finally red it!! and i do agree with whatever you've written.. but the thing is writers can show all these things by creating less drama, they r busy showing these serious issues without any lighthearted moments inbetween which is leading to annoy all viewers. yeah yeah except some idiots😔 (you know what i mean😛😆)
and.. umm ok i have nothing more to say😕😛

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".