Welcome To The World of Fake Relationships - Page 2

Created

Last reply

Replies

13

Views

1.2k

Users

8

Likes

45

Frequent Posters

ltelidevara thumbnail
Visit Streak 1000 Thumbnail Visit Streak 750 Thumbnail + 8
Posted: 8 years ago
#11

Originally posted by: NBT-BV


I fully agree with you - the whole show is fake. There are contractions in every character.

Every character analysis done by you is bang on.

I find too much in consistency in Sona too. I can't understand what attracted her to Dev. IMO it was just a crush / infatuation on a successful businessman else how come a girl can love a person who is week, indecisive (impulsive decision to break engagement and relationship is not decision), can't protect his love. He did not show any courage in telling about his love to Ish or even to his sisters.

This show has started getting on the nerves and as usual CVs have started destroying it in the Ekta kapoor style.

Thanq. Agree with you Sona's ch also is inconsistent.But compared to others hers is a better sketched one.
dikshat thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 8 years ago
#12

Originally posted by: Riddikulus

I think it's a matter of perspective, really. I see where you're coming from and the basis of the arguments you're making is pretty clear. But my view, though based on the exact same instances, is very different. I had different expectations from the promos, first of all. I did not see in them a hitherto unexplored mom-son relationship or a completely new kind of male lead. What I saw was a very interesting space within a love story - the idea of two people not being together and yet being together. That was actually what attracted me towards the show to begin with. And that space is yet to come on the show, I think. Supriya ma'am's Instagram update had given me hope of that too recently...that we're at the moment somewhere between the first break-up promo and the remaining two. And as much as I long for them, I know that the way DevAkshi have parted ways, the follow up cannot immediately be stable. Explosive hona banta hai and so far, it's actually lived up to my expectations in that sense.


The mother-son relationship too, just like Dev's character, has seemed consistent to me since the beginning of the show. The way Dev is behaving is in my eyes quite in line with the way he is. Sona's entering his life had melllowed him down a bit, and her going out of his life has completely disoriented him. A love this intense can bring out both the best as well as the worst in people, and that's what's happening with Dev. For me, it fits.

And as for his being the loyal son or the committed lover, what I have loved most about Dev is how inexorably human he is. And to be human is to be flawed. I personally prefer not to try and fit him into a 'loyal son' stereotype. He does everything he thinks he needs to do for his mother. And the fact that he didn't think of the consequences of hiding his love from her simply point to the fact that he isn't perfect. If he wants to have something just for himself for once in his life, it makes him more relatable to me at least. The same goes for his regretting his decision within hours of making it - he is an impulsive guy. Always has been. And he did what he thought he needed to - what he thought he had to, at that moment. He thought it would be enough for him to know that this is what's best for his mother. But it wasn't enough. Because he has real feelings for Sonakshi that can't be done away with like a faulty business contract. He is a complicated man, but sometimes I've found that his view of life is a very simplistic one. Add this, subtract this and you get a balanced equation. But life doesn't work like that, especially in matters of the heart, and he's experiencing that now in its most raw form. Which is why he doesn't know what to do with himself. He's completely directionless and frazzled. And I'm loving that, honestly.

Stability coming after this would make a lot of sense to me. The way they parted, the anger, resentment, disorientation that followed...and finally a sense of resignation ki jo hai, yahi hai should logically follow. I don't know what the writers have planned, but so far - as painful as it is to watch - they seem to be on the track they carved for the show in the beginning. I just hope they don't stretch the Ritik track too long because then the story will begin to stagnate and become repetitive. It's already hinging on that right now, so I hope they have something concrete planned for the coming weeks.

Respect your opinion, and this is mine.



I have the samw views
AnnzSageflower7 thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 8 years ago
#13
Interesting views!
Actually I was very impressed by Dev's direct nature from the start. He is stubborn and obstinate too, he practically bulldozed Sonakshi's life for his mother's benefit. Ruthless type.

But he was disappointing right back from when he hid their love story from everyone. She deserves to be loved in the open. She is an awesome woman, not to be romanced in secret.

People defended that it's normal to keep GFs a secret from the family. "He wanted her for himself" "for once he chose something for himself" etc. i didn't find it very romantic. She worked in his house, and he was possesive of her from the start. They would meet in his room, have cutesy convos. She had to lie about why she was waiting late for his return from work. She comes home late everyday because he says so or he will be upset with her.

He was disrespecting her by keeping her a secret. If he told his Mother from the start, she would have been forced to either accept or tell him outright that she did not approve. But no. The whole secret part became the giant issue and became a huge "mother and son" tiff, rather than a "GF-BF" unsuitability issue.

Sonakshi became the loose end, the convenient thing to cut out. Everything about Dev is his mother's and family's wants and needs. He never did make her a priority. He expected her to just fit into his family somehow and join him in making his family her priority too. He met her family before but never after they fell in love. He never asked of them only until after they broke up, that too only as a conversation piece, not that he really cares.

He is too wrapped up in his own selfish needs. "Sonakshi is wrong to marry Ritwik. She's doing this to punish me."

How dare he? Make everything about him only. Brat!

harsh? Maybe. Remember when he found out his mother didn't approve of Sonakshi?
"Everything was fine before... Ma was happy. And I did this. Sonakshi has to go."

facepalm XXL .

Dev has a long way to go before he can bring Sonakshi into his house and keep her happy. He'd just be forcing her onto his mother, and and forcing Sonakshi to deal with 2 women who openly displayed their disdain for her. Heck, however cute the guy was, no girl would put her toe into these waters!

Whatever grouses I have with the path the writers have chosen, I cant deny that the dialogue and drama is effective. it is going somewhere we would like to see, but before we get there we have to see them at their worst.

DevAkshi will be back together, but after a lot of life lessons.
Edited by AnnzSageflower7 - 8 years ago
ltelidevara thumbnail
Visit Streak 1000 Thumbnail Visit Streak 750 Thumbnail + 8
Posted: 8 years ago
#14
People defended that it's normal to keep GFs a secret from the family. "He wanted her for himself" "for once he chose something for himself" etc. i didn't find it very romantic. She worked in his house, and he was possesive of her from the start. They would meet in his room, have cutesy convos. She had to lie about why she was waiting late for his return from work. She comes home late everyday because he says so or he will be upset with her.

He was disrespecting her by keeping her a secret. If he told his Mother from the start, she would have been forced to either accept or tell him outright that she did not approve. But no. The whole secret part became the giant issue and became a huge "mother and son" tiff, rather than a "GF-BF" unsuitability issue.
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Ya. Agree with you. That is why I wrote had he told Iswari in the begining itself the outcome may be different though I am not sure about Iswari. Atleast Dev need not have to feel guilty for hiding their love and Sona would have been saved from embarrassment Dev disrespected both his mother and Sona by keeping it a secret.Even I did not find it romantic.

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".