Upon request- my opinion on the ishaana issue and precap - Page 3

Created

Last reply

Replies

27

Views

2.3k

Users

17

Likes

90

Frequent Posters

tejaswiniwenham thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#21

Originally posted by: Tunasnah

Omkara mother drunk true but she don't use her son to con people.


immaterial what her folly is, but the fact is that she has a folly and it cuts him everytime he hears someone say it. so to expect someone else to stoically listen to their parents being badmouthed is just impractical.
muktha_cute thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#22
dont know from which angle soumya is like anika as character wise
anika would never do what all soumya did with rudra
she never chooses wrong path even to teach someone a lesson
so plz dont compare anika with soumya or any other character just to prove ur fav ishana as some unique
dont understand why anika is dragged whenever ishana topic or matter is discussed
tejaswiniwenham thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#23

Originally posted by: muktha_cute

dont know from which angle soumya is like anika as character wise
anika would never do what all soumya did with rudra
she never chooses wrong path even to teach someone a lesson
so plz dont compare anika with soumya or any other character just to prove ur fav ishana as some unique
dont understand why anika is dragged whenever ishana topic or matter is discussed


Hi muktha! good to see you in this forum after swaragini! i quit after SwaSan wedding. 😊 it got too ridiculous for me to tolerate. but ya good to see you! ok now coming to the soumya annika vs ishaana thing, i find soumya to be a subpar copy of her. their styles are similar but ya i agree that their moral ground work is a bit different. annika is fine the way she is, she treats shivaaye the way she does cos he's insufferable and although the behaviour is more than borderline unprofessional but i accept it cos shes right- he's been cruel to her. but with soumya i literally dont understand what her problem with rudra is. she pretends to be comfortable being fat but she lashes out at rudra for not feeling her and saying shes fat. but fundamentally they are 'good' in the same sense thus i aliked them and ishaana is not, which in this case does make her a unique- an anti-hero lead. and actually if you read my original post carefully it was about how baseless it is to compare anika and ishaana cos they're chalk and cheese. this post was written in response to other posts comparing them. 😊
muktha_cute thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#24

Originally posted by: tejaswiniwenham


Hi muktha! good to see you in this forum after swaragini! i quit after SwaSan wedding. 😊 it got too ridiculous for me to tolerate. but ya good to see you! ok now coming to the soumya annika vs ishaana thing, i find soumya to be a subpar copy of her. their styles are similar but ya i agree that their moral ground work is a bit different. annika is fine the way she is, she treats shivaaye the way she does cos he's insufferable and although the behaviour is more than borderline unprofessional but i accept it cos shes right- he's been cruel to her. but with soumya i literally dont understand what her problem with rudra is. she pretends to be comfortable being fat but she lashes out at rudra for not feeling her and saying shes fat. but fundamentally they are 'good' in the same sense thus i aliked them and ishaana is not, which in this case does make her a unique- an anti-hero lead. and actually if you read my original post carefully it was about how baseless it is to compare anika and ishaana cos they're chalk and cheese. this post was written in response to other posts comparing them. 😊



oh,sry i didnt recognize u bfr.but was thinking had seen this id somewhere
i was a fan of swara bfr but what she have turned into now
now im in love with Anikas character
i just love strong girls who stand up for themselves and as per now i find Anika as the best of what all i have seen abt female leads in other serials
hope gul dont spoil anika like she did with zoya character
what i find diff abt anika and soumya is
Anika is vry hard working,which i dont think soumya is or atleast til now she is not shown in that way.she doesnt need to work hard to get what all she has.
Anika never gives up she fights whether she win or loose it which i dont find in soumya
i like the way she stands up for herself and puts her point and proves it too like abt her surname or abt her birth
most importantly what i like abt her is her moral stand it is easy to say all the moral stuff and many ppl do but when it comes to put those things in action ppl fail.
i just love anika and watching IB mainly for her
so im just posessive abt anika
coming to soumya she is sweet but not strong and independent
if she is really strong im not even talking abt right or wrong ways here,its simple there was no need for her to do anything which she had done with rudra
soumya could still can put her point in other way and prove her point that she is not a looser just bcz her size is diff.
i just dont like anika to be compared with anyone
ishana yes her character is diff but gul messed it up
so now they might show ishana with proper characterisation
ishana is like she is.better for everyone to accept it then try to make her look flawless or give excuses for her actions this was ur point i think
why to justify any character bcz all the characters are adults and they know very well what they are doing,they might have there reasons for doing so but still it wont change the fact that they intentionally choosed an wrong way or hurted others in the process
its there own choices and actions and the result will also be based on it
Edited by muktha_cute - 9 years ago
1002384 thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#25
god di👏👏
bang on post...👏👏👏
Shopnila thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#26

Originally posted by: tejaswiniwenham


ty for slightly agreeing with me but its not really true that shes not appreciated by anyone considering she has her own fan base, im guessing you meant you dont connect with her. frankly i dont either and i think thats fine. i dont connect with most antihero ish characters on the show so thats fine. as for why hurt Om and break up him and ridhs cos that was her plan and neither of them really matter to her. she felt bad conning a good person in the same way i felt bad killing a lobster for dinner last night. thats normal and indeed to be expected that she'd feel some kind of remorse but thats not going to override her plan. and im quite amoral with a lot of issues and i just dont think breaking up ridhs and om was that big of a deal. it happens in most stories. the hero falls for the heroine and then ditches the girl who was with him before this girl came into his life. she the doesnt 'mean' to take hero away from the girl in his life- fiance, bachpan ka dost who loves him, girl friend, lover etc etc- it just happens. it'll happen with tia, romi and ridhima is therefore nothing special. the story usually goes- shes innocent and great and he just falls for her and leaves his home girl cos shes suddenly too flawed in comparison with the new sati savitri in his life. its all circumstantial. i personally think its all bs and hiding a rather crude truth under the pretext of love and goodness- which is, the hero is going to have to break up with the girlfriend to be with the heroine. thats just it. so i dont particularly care if ridhs and om break up. and honestly he didnt seem that upset either. for such an emotional person like omkara id have expected some heart and art work to make me feel like riddhima mattered to him beyond a friendship, which i never got, so wasnt honestly that involved in the break up. infact i find it quite intriguing that ishaana comes into it without any pretense and danke k chot pe goes for it. and ofcourse she couldve gone for many other targets than omkara but considering that it is their story that would be a bit of a moot point if she went for someone else no?

interesting thought- SvetKara, but i do find father and son sleeping with the same woman a tad bit distasteful- too bold and the beautiful for me. 😆

but yes the mala bela track was terrible and ishaana is rather terrible at her job. that i think we can all agree. she focused on too many characters rather than staying focused on om alone. the intro of mala was silly. bela was fine. ⭐️



"she felt bad conning a good person in the same way i felt bad killing a lobster for dinner last night" lol., it literally cracked me up.

Actually, I think I could not make it clear. I am an actual neutral fan here or you can say I am equal fan of the 6 leads (maybe less for Soumya) and as the post was based on fan's complain about Ish, I thought to bring forth the logical parts.

Even, for me father-son having same GF was too bold and I think for most of the fans here. BUT they were ready to accept even that. So, Ishana being a con girl is not the problem. At first we knew Ridh is all positive character and there will be an intense story for Ishkara. Then the CV introduced Mala/Bela crap, breaking their relation was not the big deal but to "loot" him she needs to be his GF, this idea was. They needed quick money, but she chose the longer route. She can easily con Om or other in different way. When Ish was beaten and broken and Om consoled her, that was beautifully portrayed, they could be friends and Ish could teach Om that life's not all about black and white and sometimes truth is not the choise. The story could progress from here. Ishana as a character is loved by all but Ishkara is not because it seems forced. It's all CV's fault. But , now after today's confrontation, I think this intense story will proceed.


tejaswiniwenham thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#27

Originally posted by: abshcool

god di👏👏
bang on post...👏👏👏


🤗
tejaswiniwenham thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#28

Originally posted by: Shopnila



"she felt bad conning a good person in the same way i felt bad killing a lobster for dinner last night" lol., it literally cracked me up.

Actually, I think I could not make it clear. I am an actual neutral fan here or you can say I am equal fan of the 6 leads (maybe less for Soumya) and as the post was based on fan's complain about Ish, I thought to bring forth the logical parts.

Even, for me father-son having same GF was too bold and I think for most of the fans here. BUT they were ready to accept even that. So, Ishana being a con girl is not the problem. At first we knew Ridh is all positive character and there will be an intense story for Ishkara. Then the CV introduced Mala/Bela crap, breaking their relation was not the big deal but to "loot" him she needs to be his GF, this idea was. They needed quick money, but she chose the longer route. She can easily con Om or other in different way. When Ish was beaten and broken and Om consoled her, that was beautifully portrayed, they could be friends and Ish could teach Om that life's not all about black and white and sometimes truth is not the choise. The story could progress from here. Ishana as a character is loved by all but Ishkara is not because it seems forced. It's all CV's fault. But , now after today's confrontation, I think this intense story will proceed.



ah! ty for clarifying! well as far as logic is concerned, the whole con process and the bela-mala track was bs^infiinity. 😆 they shouldve atleast established a timeline like you have 3 months...ok thats doable. but unless she robbed a bank, who else other than a boyfriend or a husband would give you 2 crores i guess 🤔 but at this point, with daily threats pouring in, theyd be better off looting a bank 😆

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".