Aradhya's Perspective! #AaiWill AlwaysBeProud #MyTake - Page 3

@Chandrima...

Originally posted by: _innocent_

The mere fact that Kumudini lost her daughter does not dissolve any of her wrong doings. She was the master pulling all the strings and always told Tulsi, nothing was more important than her revenge and hence begging the question of, has she truly been punished?

Acting most of the time comes from the directors' cues. But yes lets agree to disagree.😆 But if we go with @bold, then perhaps the makers were on a mission to ensure her character was butchered to the same extent as that of Aryan's post the jail wedding drama. The makers wanted to promote equality I guess!😆

@Red, that is very true and sometimes our own downfall as it forces us to indulge more than we ought to in the storyline.

I do not agree that Aaba is a murderer. He is a moron who caused the scenarios indirectly, but he is not a murderer. Lets take the example of where Poorva tried to murder Aradhya by stabbing her. Aryan was the one who brought Poorva into the house stating she will be the bahu of the household, however, we did not hold Aryan responsible for the attempted murder, did we?

I would appear that the makers ought to give PVR some monologues so people can comprehend his stance post the baby swap revelation as we never truly got how he felt. Kumudini always get lone scenes where she expresses her feelings and now its high time the same is done for PVR so the audience can have a better understanding of him. However, I agree that he is heartless and his behavior towards Aryan was wholly inappropriate.

For me presently, Kumudini and PVR are the real culprits and sadly the strings that are going to be pulled now will serve as a big divide in how we feel about the characters unless the makers spend time in showing us exactly how each of the characters are feelings.

Aradhya is trying to prove who killed her Aai, that's how I am saying it. 😆

Thank you so much for such insightful replies.😃

Eh, I need to get back to work, but couldn't help replying to that one.😃 @bold, this is not what I meant at all when I called Aaba a murderer. For your example, I would call Aryan a murderer if he made a plan with every intention to push Aradhya, but Purva happened to push her first. Because the intent there is important. Aryan brought Purva to the house intending to make Aradhya suffer and pay her back for the forced marriage. Immature, stupid behaviour, nothing to be proud of. But he never wanted to kill Aradhya, never made a plan to do so, never held a gun to her head intending to pull the trigger in cold blood.

I'm not saying Aaba is responsible for Jairaj murdering Tulsi. That way you could argue that Kumu is responsible for Aaba trying to murder Aryan, as the instigator. I'm not analyzing in that way at all. Irrespective of who caused which scenario, ultimately Jairaj is the cold-blooded murderer of Tulsi because he planned a death and executed it by pulling the trigger. Okay so he killed the wrong person, but he meant to kill and he did. And Aaba is the cold blooded near-murderer of Aryan because he too planned the death and nearly executed it by pulling the trigger. The fact that he did not succeed is down to other people's (Jairaj and Aradhya) meddling. He meant to kill and failed by a whisker. Even he said nearly as much to Shashwat. So you can say Jairaj is a better or more successful murderer than Aaba, but Aaba is a murderer as well, if not a successful one, because his intent to kill was crystal clear.

@Atria, I thought you were going along the line of 'BUT...FOR xyz's actions" thus my reply being along those lines, my bad!!!

Originally posted by: _innocent_

@Atria, I thought you were going along the line of 'BUT...FOR xyz's actions" thus my reply being along those lines, my bad!!!

Seeing how PVR had reacted yesterday once it dawned on him that Tulsi had been shot, tells me he is a mere shit chatter to try and show himself as the big man when in reality he is a mere coward. But again that's how I perceived his behavior. i did not watch the episode where he held the gun to Aryan's head as I could not be asked to watch Aradhya lecturing Aaba. The intent automatically does not make one a murderer as that along will never stand in a court of law, the actus reus ought to be there too. But again, we'll agree to disagree.😆

If time permits, do try and be active in the forum, I had a jolly good time reading your replies! Have a good day!😳

Well let us keep it accurate and call it attempted murder then, that is a crime that fits Aaba to a T. He had the intent and action both in place. Let us take the intent and preparation as a given. As for action: (a) He lured Aryan to a specific place, which qualifies as a direct step (b) he took an even clearer direct step to murder Aryan, holding the gun to his head and releasing the lock. Aaba can't claim renunciation as a defence, he went to kill, was convinced otherwise, then went back again. Maybe impossibility, since Aradhya can say there were no bullets so Aaba could not have killed Aryan, but Aaba did not know that, so I can imagine a prosecutor having all sorts of fun with that defence. In real life of course, in the serial we know that will not happen.😆 Legally I do think since Aryan, the target, was not actually hurt, life imprisonment would not result but with a half-way decent prosecutor a ten-year jail term would be a shoo-in. That he is a coward etc wouldn't really matter, his actions were damning. Morally to me an attempted murder of this sort shows that the character of the person is fully capable of murder, and is as good as a murderer, many cowards are murderers too you know.

I do read on the forum a lot but am too lazy to post. Will try now and then. Was good discussing with you.😊

Have updated my post in pg 1

Mary, I have no words or comebacks to your analysis.😆 You've written it so beautifully.😳 Your explanation on how she was willing to occupy herself with other things rather than face Tulsi's dead body, is so apt. It makes a lot of sense. And funnily enough, that is one part of how people try to run from the emotion grief.

@Innocent - Nice analysis changing your take on Aradhya.

But I am with Atria, Ruchi and Chandrima.

I find the Raos bigger villains. They used their money to oppress and coerce people.
Not a single character in that family is worthy of pity. Aba Saheb is a Master Criminal.

And to me he is the one who started the game of vengeance and not Kumudini. He insulted Kumudini and threw her and Tulsi out of the village. I am sure he knew about Maharaja's will - that the property will go to Tulsi and Kumu was afraid that he will be after the blood of Tulsi's kid that is why she swapped the babies so Tulsi's child will be safe under Aba's roof.

Kumudini has turned into this in self defense and I really give her credit for turning the tables on Aba.

Now regarding Aaru it will be very hard for me to forgive her because of the harsh treatment she gave to Tulsi. Also I think she should have been grieving and mourning and by her husband's side and not with her newly found Biological family. In fact she should have left Aba and Pavitra and come to stay with Tulsi and Aryan. It is hard for me to digest that she forgave Pavitra so easily. And again she had no time to mourn and grieve for her mother yesterday. No not done Aaru! Disappointed by your behavior and act! I won't be able to forgive and justify you!

Loved Shravan's acting yesterday. It was brilliant- his grief, his anger, his helpless were portrayed brilliantly. Sana clearly lacked in performance. Just my opinion, no offence meant to anyone. And I respect everyone's opinion.

Juhi,

@ Innocent- yes I agree Kumudini is evil but PVR has a huge contribution towards it. She grudges that despite being loved by the Raja and bearing his only child, and despite being a single mom raising her kid by herself, she and her child did not get any respect or sympathy from the society. Whereas the Raos are enjoying a life of respect, pleasure and prosperity on borrowed money and property which do not rightfully belong to them. I agree Kumu took it too far taunting Pavitra, Gayu and Shaswat but this is a woman who has been wronged by the Raos and the village. I think to atone for her wrong deeds like baby swapping and killing Shankari she needs to serve time in jail along with PVR. Both deserve to spend time there. Aba did not kill Aryan but he should be tried and sentenced under attempt to murder both Aryan and Aradhya (cave incident).

Well if CVs can shoot a scene to show a flashback where Aaru talks to Tulsi and cries and ask for forgiveness that will be great but not sure if Jayaji is available to do that. That will absolve her of her wrong action to some extent. However I will not forgive her for making the wrong decision to stay back with her Biological family ditching her husband and mom after truth was revealed. How she could forget the mom of 22 years and a husband who loved her so much just because her biological grandpa and mom blackmailed her. Kumu was ok to take her with them unlike Aba who openly asked Aryan to leave them.

Shravan is an extremely natural in any scene. Sana was brilliant in the post marriage break up episodes and also on Hypnotized episodes. Perhaps CVs did not give her proper direction in the last 2 days episodes and concentrated more on Shravan's role.