Filling a Godh with Insult

-K.13- thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail Networker 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#1

This isn't about the characters because we see Ishita, Raman, the Bhallas, the Iyers, and Ruhi all celebrating and loving Ishita & Raman's symbol of love being born through Shagun.

This is about the women who will never have a Godh Bharai of their own. Or those will have one only after paying $10,000 on treatments, many of which fail before that one blessing from Bhagwan sticks around.

This is the sheer insult and inhumanity of EK, SJ, and SP to have an infertile woman tie a fake baby bump to her and sit in a pooja. This is about the infertile woman who is saying a surrogate is also the mother of her child and fills the surrogate's godh.

-----

Rituals are sacred. From my understanding, a Godh Bharai is done of a first time mother. Shagun had her ritual when pregnant with Adi and Ishita had hers with Ruhi. Does this ritual done for Ishita-Raman's blood child hold more precedence over Ruhi & Ishita's godh bharai?

Regardless is this ritual shown in today's episode consider sacred? Maybe if Ishita had the proper work up for infertility treatments and then turned to surrogacy, we would be more accepting because that is the general path couples follow. Regardless this event should've been just about Ishita and her baby and not had this fake baby bump or passing of all the wishes to Shagun in my opinion.

If Ishita's magical pregnancy wasn't an insult to infertile women to you, then this definitely is.

Step outside of the characters and your hate for Shagun and see the sheer lack of empathy and sympathy women have for infertile women. In all honesty, even during the protests...people hated the fact Shagun was the surrogate mother, not the immorality of the actions. Society watches these shows passively; does this mean they too don't see anything wrong with the shunning of infertile women?

----

YHM has been a decent show and has shown really ridiculous and stupid things in the name of SP's Nayi Soch...but this episode is honestly just disturbing, uncomfortable, and hurtful to the core.

TV shows are for entertainment - so why must they falsely pick up these social issues as a marketing tool but RUIN them in execution? Many other nations' shows don't try to include moral issues and so don't face this issue. So why does desi TV thrive on this false marketing?

I hope SJ, EK, and Star Plus and everyone who passively acts or watches this episode without thinking never has to suffer like an infertile couple. I hope that EK, BT, and SP make all the money in the world from this.

And most importantly, I hope no one struggling with infertility watches this show.


Sorry for the wordiness but I couldn't help myself today! Please understand - this is NOT a cry for change or a plea to the ever heartless makers because that doesn't matter in the face of money and I can understand that...it's just disappointment at the world overall for their general views on infertility of men and women. I know nothing is going to change and no one is going to grow a conscious but the internet is for anonymous sharing of thoughts, na?! 😃

Thanks for reading! 😳

Created

Last reply

Replies

30

Views

2.9k

Users

20

Likes

159

Frequent Posters

kaa1202 thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail Networker 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#2
Word Kri 👍🏼

Reality is bit harsh.. They made a mockery out of the Infertility issue...🤢
AraBearxo thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 10 years ago
#3
K, I would love to say a lot but I won't. This is the girl who spent hours trying to talk to Star, Balaji about the insensitivity shown and was told that the concept was right and quoting the people, 'Ishita wouldn't say yes and that forging surrogacy was the only way Raman could have done it and he was right'.
I've come to realise that I have no control over this no matter how much it hurts me or how much I cry. I am a voiceless viewer and I will always be. So, I've made an active decision not to watch this show or care. I'd just be wasting my time if I did.


Let me not rant.


Edit:


Sometimes, there were moment where an evil part of me would wish that the women on the show go through something similar and traumatising. Then I would sit and realise that a) that wouldn't happen and b) for people who earned tens of lakhs a day, shelling out a mere ten or twenty wouldn't mean anything as they would to someone from a middle class family which is the majority of India. So we are wasting our time here. Truly.
Edited by -Ara- - 10 years ago
Sri1091 thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 10 years ago
#4
Bang on
They made a mockery of infertile women and this godh bharai and dat dummy tummy is heights of insestivity
kras thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#5
Bang on kri
Today's episode was pukeworthy for me
Because they made fun of very sacred ritual
GB where kid gets everyone blessings
A memorable moment for a mother
But they made mockery of it
And specially that fake baby bump that was ridiculous
And then GB of surrogate mother
Which is not right at any cost because that baby is not her
iammayurfan thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#6
Whoever thought about the way surrogacy was shown and today's godh bharai scene is an absolute ignorant pig. I see woman in my profession who go through emotional hell during the infertility treatment. I sincerely hope whoever conceived this idea goes through the pain..in the name of creative freedom it's absurd
Mdwst thumbnail
10th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail Networker 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#7
Krishy bang on
Sporting a fake tummy... Insensitive
The way they've shown looks like infertile woman don't deserve chance for medical treatments. If it was unsuccessful .. May be maybe we would've accepted surrogacy .. But definitely not thru shagun..
You one word " shunned" summed it all up ..,
This godhbarai is to show shagun Matas height of positivism?
Edited by Mdwst - 10 years ago
mar_21 thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail Networker 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#8
Nice post Kri


I would have pardoned the makers of this show for all the crap that they have shown to us BUT definitely not for going ahead with this surrogacy track...because this track is highly insensitive, inhuman, atrocious, distasteful & digusting!!! And what they showed today in the name of Godhbharia was Yuck & digusting!!! There is absolutely no justification for this crap.

#BigShame
Edited by mischief - 10 years ago
-K.13- thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail Networker 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#9

Originally posted by: kaa1202

Word Kri 👍🏼

Reality is bit harsh.. They made a mockery out of the Infertility issue...🤢


Hey Kaartik - I know. The problem isn't even the show itself...it's just that no one cares really about the issues. Meh the world can be a dark and selfish place and we have to find those who are positive to stay sane 😳
-K.13- thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail Networker 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#10

Originally posted by: -Ara-

K, I would love to say a lot but I won't. This is the girl who spent hours trying to talk to Star, Balaji about the insensitivity shown and was told that the concept was right and quoting the people, 'Ishita wouldn't say yes and that forging surrogacy was the only way Raman could have done it and he was right'.

I've come to realise that I have no control over this no matter how much it hurts me or how much I cry. I am a voiceless viewer and I will always be. So, I've made an active decision not to watch this show or care. I'd just be wasting my time if I did.


Let me not rant.


Edit:


Sometimes, there were moment where an evil part of me would wish that the women on the show go through something similar and traumatising. Then I would sit and realise that a) that wouldn't happen and b) for people who earned tens of lakhs a day, shelling out a mere ten or twenty wouldn't mean anything as they would to someone from a middle class family which is the majority of India. So we are wasting our time here. Truly.


See the point isn't making them change because they won't. I just posted this as a conversation point. I know they won't see past their greed and nor will they have any "karma bite them back"

It's just there are people who are suffering and we as a society do nothing but further chase them away it seems

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".