Character Roshni -doormat or not ?

Just_Smile thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 9 years ago
#1
I read few comments about character roshni as female lead in JR that she is just doormat and not having major part or contribution to story🤪..she is just their to romance hero 🤣...and its waste of Nia's time and talent😲 ..

i wont say who said it..its a comment from general viewer of JR .. i was very angry at first...😆but later just laughed at regressive ppl be it trp aunties or online viewers both are same...bcoz of ekta and rashmi sharma's show ...ppl are still in backward days thinking female lead to be a powerful superwoman like simar fighting dayaans🤢...and like gopi to be complete sanskaari saying maaji ,ahemji🥱..or like typical ekta leads marrying diff ppl and still in love with one person ,lying and cheating their life partners😲 ...if either of above characteristics feature are not present in any FL that female lead is unfit 🥱😆

I mean if a FL is realistic ,having her own views about situation and not taking anybody's shit and who can question her hubby /mom when they are wrong are doormats ..like seriously if young audience have such opinion i wont blame SNS for topping trp chart 😆

I think except shiv and ayesha track i felt roshni had equal role and importance in every episode like DD and Sid..just that story is about Sid..they show his POV and him taking charge of solving problems 😛..but if we see ,this story JAMAI RAJA is running only bcoz of roshni 😆.whatever sid is doing from episode 1
is for roshni ..If she is not there what would jamai Sid do 😲

current shabby track is also bcoz of roshni...as shabby is jealous of roshni and want to ruin her life ..Sid or raghu track is also to kick shabby out ..which is again done by sid to make roshni happy...whole story is revolving round roshni and ppl say that she is having nothing to do😲

I agree that presently cvs are showing her dumb inorder to drag the track but i personally never felt her like doormat...nor never Sid or DD treated her like that 😆

P.S...I dont know why i made this long post😆 but felt like sharing my thoughts, seeing how regressive ppl are

Edited by ChandzLoveSidNi - 9 years ago

Created

Last reply

Replies

12

Views

972

Users

11

Likes

58

Frequent Posters

naz1312 thumbnail
Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#2
Very well said CHANDZLOVESSIDNI Bang on post !! I totally agree with you . JR revolve around Roshni ! Nia's character is as important as Ravi and Achit . I think most of the Tv Bahu s or female leads are all doormat LOL , haven't changed in recent times .
TVs FL over the years been so lame it's always Ekta's shows that ruined women's image and point of view . Viewers are so used to seeing ignorant FL that's why they can't digest Roshni's character which it self is a far more better then most of the current female leads . 😆
Edited by naz1312 - 9 years ago
Harmony10 thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#3
Tell me more about it Chandu I have gone blind seeing such a post every other day and now I just ignore like I saw nothing 😆 That statement when I see "Roshni is only used for romance; Jamai takes all the footage" gets me super irritated 😡 People do not see Jamai exists because of the heroine; if there is no heroine where will the hero come from. In order for a story to run we need both the hero and heroine Like you mentioned if you look at it the story does revolve around the FEMALE LEAD Roshni and not only the JAMAI. The difference is in this story Jamai is used to solve all her problems instead of the opposite like we see in typical Saas bahu drama where the bahu's take stance to solve their husband's problem 😆 People need to accept the reality this is called Jamai Raja hence he will be getting more footage but that doesn't mean the Female lead is being ignored; she is getting equal importance as the other leads but yes in some tracks like the Misha and Shiv track she was ignored but not completely.
Edited by paru10 - 9 years ago
rosesidni thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#4
Oh God!!! Again doormat theory, it looks like it will exsist till the end of the show😆 Anyway, well said Chandu, u have brilliantly put it👏👏
APART FROM MISHA TRACK, I have never felt Roshni doormat. I want to ask what is the criteria of NOT BEING DOORMAT?? Just because Roshni is an emotional person and cries or romances, that doesn't mean she is doormat. Realistically, no person is superwomen like Simran, Gopi, Ishita or Ishani🥱 Apart from these, please give me the list of some heroines of successful show who are not doormats, so that I can understand what people mean by doormat😕

For me a doormat is a person, who doesn't respond and takes everyones crap w/o a word.. By that definition I will say Sid is a more doormat in the show (I love him but it is the truth)😆 How is Roshni who responds to every person in the show, whether it is DD, Sid, Raghu or Shabby (whether it is in anger or in love) a doormat?? She has most of the time stood with and fought for right, commited mistakes, accepted it, was honest most of the times, spoken her mind without fear or favour, how would u call such a character doormat??🥱 And as Chandz puts it every track and the entire story revolves around Roshni, whether it is DD imp track or Sid imp track.

Anyway, some people just live with this notion for life😆 and whatever anyone say or whatever logic exsist they won't budge or change the view. So, I know my long answer is just a futile attempt, just that I felt like commenting on the topic😆

ChurriBurri thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#5
You can't compare Roshni with the other bahus of other shows...those shows are the typical female oriented dramas and this is the opposite. If you look at it then Sid is the bahu and Roshni is the jamai in terms of those shows...lol!! Just like in those shows we see bahus fixing problems in their saasural here we have Sid fixing his saasural's problems. In those the bahus stand up for their husband's respect and happiness, here that is Sid.
sumaiya-kay thumbnail
21st Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 90 Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 9 years ago
#6
Roshni and doormat doesn't even go in the same sentence...Whoever is using this term for her seriously needs to consult a dictionary...A doormat is one who takes things lying down without protest, basically one who allows others to walk all over them...Roshni is anything but that! I actually find Roshni to be a very realistically written character and that is very rare to find these days on television...
madhuharini thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 9 years ago
#7
I am not going to agree with the word "Doormat" for Roshni's character when she is being everything for her husband and a great strength & support for her mom... Roshni is a bold, well-educated and independent heroine of tv soaps unlike other saas-bahu soaps. But at present (specially after leap), I am not happy & satisfied with her character chandu😕 She is going very dumb and showing as very dependent also... I am not saying tht Roshni should stand against Shabby and defeat her alone. But wht I want and expecting frm the character is she shouldn't be shown always crying and going weak against Shabby. By now, she should ve tried something to prove Sid's innocence in MMS scandal... She never shouted or asked the police strongly whether thy are searching for her husband in all this 6 months... When DD is shown a working woman and Simran also, then I wish Roshni should also do something... not everytime, but atleast in this 6 months, when Shabby took over their property she shouldn't have depend on her when she has her own school. I am lil disappointed with her character portrayal after leap
abinaya98 thumbnail
10th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#8
Bang on post chandu...u wrote it perfectly..nthn more to add👍🏼👏
pree8714 thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#9
I think Abi explained a lot of things which I wanted to say I completlyy agree roshni is not a doormat but yes Roshni character is been shown dumb post leap I agree the show is about Jamai and he is given the responsibility to sort the problems but what I am not happy is roshni is jus dependent on sid and DD to sort her problems she jus believes whats thrown her way be it by sid or DD well blame it on CVs their has been no character growth in roshni sid and DD Roshni was way better before leap she would not give up on situations and ppl who are saying its all about roshni sorry its not about roshni not once their has been a track on roshni even during yash drama roshni had no say and that was the most useless track what my problem with CVs is she is equally important as DD and sid so why not introduce a track on Roshni where she is shown sorting her problems to move her life why she needs a support of DD and sid she is been really shown weak offlate or probably CVs can introduce a guy for Roshni well I am not saying ignore Sid or DD when their has been a complete track on them then why not Roshni if only Jamai is their to sort the problems then why give importance to any characters they have given importance to simran also even villians have got more footage then Roshni at times
Yes I am a nia fan and I am more biased towards her if you want to bash me please do but I wish in future we get a track on roshni as I am sick of seeing girls coming and lusting over sid I would love to see a new guy for ROshni or a track where she starts working rest I would never say she is a doormat
skinnypal thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 9 years ago
#10
Roshni is not a doormat. If she was then you wouldn't have seen her kicking and beating the shit out of the ML! 😆 Like Rose pointed out, its Sid who is a door mat in the show - and in order to run a show of this genre one character has to be the Mahaan doormat to take the crap of others! 😛
Roshni being used only to romance sid - is a very hilarious comment that i have often come across. What's the harm in that? Why do people want the character to be an inspirational one in terms of the "deeds" they do in the show? Why can't you just relate to the character in a personal level rather than trying to get inspired from it? And yeah, i do love her - but i cannot disagree with the fact that she is being shown laid back post Sid's death! 😕
Edited by skinnypal - 9 years ago

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".