why cant people bear a positive shagun - Page 4

Created

Last reply

Replies

39

Views

4.8k

Users

21

Likes

127

Frequent Posters

Mehak_KPian thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 10 years ago
#31
Because Shagun role has ended in the show! She is not needed in the show anymore. The day Adi declared Ishita as his Mother. Shagun ka chapter Khatam hogaya tha! It's not about Negative or Positive. It's about her role in IshRa love life and Kids. Her role has ended! It has ran its due course. There is no space for her in the story!
(Ignore grammatical and spelling mistakes.)
3fra thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#32
Apshagun shagun only in the show to tourtures the audiences nothing elc I really miss old days vamps mandira, kamolika etc vamps you enjoy there present not this apshagun shagun
nancysa thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#33
Shagun is no longer required in the show..it is obvious that cvs shagun ko ghussa rahe hai story mein without any reason.. people who cant see this are dumb or are blind...
wendy25 thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 10 years ago
#34
people are not that miffed with positive or negative Shagun but the undue importance given to that character even over leads.
They can't bear the way story is being butchered just to accommodate Shagun!
sririt thumbnail
10th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 10 years ago
#35
See, i won't say we can't have positive Shagun, but the problem is whenever Shagun enters in life of Raman and Ishita they have issues within their relations. The biggest reason for this is Raman. He hides lots of things which comes in their life related to Shagun. As part as Ishita is concerned, life partners are always insecure, if they are deeply in love with one other. Here the insecurity is ex-wife, no wife can see her man getting close to other woman. And with ex-wife there was once a relation and were deeply in love.
As you all know, after Shagun came Raman hide lots of things. He always tells after Ishita find out. Its not the correct way. He should share all to Ishita on his own. You yourself recall the moments after Shagun re-entered the show. Not only re-entry before also and that has always been a tough time for their relation.

Raman willingly told about Shagun after Manoj informed that she has changed. But before and after that

1. Mumbai fight. Raman first fought. If ishita misunderstands he should calmly explain her not by fighting.
2. He made friendship with Shagun. He should tell Ishita that he is in talking terms with Shagun, why not telling. If Ishita would do same how he will feel.
3. Also remember phone call in bus, he called Manoj but co-incidently Shagun picked up the call. He talked to her. She told that ask Ishita to keep Elaichi. He told to himself that Shagun has become old Shagun, but he should have shared what Shagun was saying and how he ended up talking to her instead of Manoj. These small conversation secure your partner.
4. CPR: He should have told Ishita on his own. I know situation was a problem, but in all that Ishita told about Rinki right, then also he was shouting that you should have told me earlier. He explained her after seeing footage.
5. Surrogacy: He took Ishita Signature, the other women was not fit so chosen Shagun. At this point he should have told Ishita. He should know the consequences of making his ex-wife a surrogate mother.

--After this I don't know if anything happened because I am not watching the show.

What kind of character Raman is playing, that do whatever you want if wife comes to know then explain else don't explain. Raman has major TRUST issues because he doesn't share lot of things with his life partner. Ishita also hides things but she discloses all after she solves the issue.

It's always advised not to hide things from life partner it always land you into trouble, and here its second marriage for Raman and second love for both, apart from how they came into this relation. The relation is always delicate. Subbu is not in Ishita's life because there is no connection of Subbu with present life of Ishita but for Raman, Shagun has always been the part of his present because of the kids. So, relation of Ishita to Raman is much more sensitive that Raman to Ishita, because Raman has no such deep-rooted insecurities.

I won't be saying anything more but relations are to be respected. The partners shouldn't hide things from others if he/she has blind trust towards the partner. If there is no love then also you can handle relation but if there is no trust relations can't be handled. And after breaking trust, even if the relation is of much love, relation is very difficult to handle as its always a heart-break

No offence please.

My opinion is on characters portrayed by actors not on actors
Edited by sririt - 10 years ago
hdivan thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#36
Him kaha par shagun KO hate karti hoo 😕 we r fighting for shagun so that she can get married and ek sukhi,anokhi family pasake . 😲 then production house continues... Nnn.then one fine day shagun meet with an accident .
Annthew thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#37
If u had been watching frm the very start of the serial l'm sure u would understand why most yhm viewers r having a problem with Shagun now. Her role is actually over, Raman had got over her but sadly the cvs hadn't.
Neena_14 thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#38
Because whether positive or negative, Shagun has always created problems in Ishra's relationship right from the beginning of the show. So I dont know about Ishita or Raman, but we viewers always feel insecure whenever we see shagun hover around Ishra!
zeny_Nian thumbnail
10th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#39
to be honest if dey show now all of a sudden dat shagun was all faking it to get back to bhallas n raman it will look hilarious n OTT caz we have seen her self talkin abt how she really cared for ishra n her children nd witnessd hw she's a changed person nw! If they make raman repent only by showin her negetive its d awful taste of dem..nothin to say! If dey turn her to negative after a point it still make sum sense! Waise m hoping nothin' just statin my pov:p i ve long given up on d show
to d tm i partially agree wid u human makes mistake and life gives dem chances to repent too but till now we have only seen shaguns MISTAKES but never got a chance witness her process of REDEMPTION instead we only met wid d material n mental luxuries she is given without for her even asking!!
aathiradevanand thumbnail
Visit Streak 90 Thumbnail Visit Streak 30 Thumbnail Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#40
no problem with shagun's positivity.It could be shown that she has become independent and leading her life in a good way...gaining the trust of her children and be allowed to meet them once in a week or something and have a cordial relationship with Ishra..why all this interfering in ishra's baby issue ..seems illogical

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".