Amber??

Amber is my favorite charater, but no it is not right 2 do somethin wat ur mom doesnt want u 2, she cant do that 2 Dhara also, D doesnt wanttttttt that.

This is a really hard question. I would say both yes and no. Yes, she does have a right to follow her dreams, and it is obvious that she felt like she never fit in in Panchgani, or never adapted to it. On the other hand she might be making a really rash descision leaving her parents and home just because some man told her she had a good voice. She did it without thinking, and disobeying your parents is never a good thing. But I think her mom just wants to protect her and not stop her from following her dreams. That is why she has to leave! Also, the worst part of it all is that if she does go to Mumbai then she would be completely changing Dhara's life, and it is apparent that Dhara is happy in Panchgani. So anyway you look at it one of the sisters is going to have to make a sacrifice for the other.

Since Amber lives ina a small hilltown..i do't expect her to know tht ppl struggle thruout their lives to make it big in Bollywood ..fer being singers, actors, directors, etc.

So she's naive in this sence ..n also immature as she seems to forget many times tht she shares a life w/ dhara..n they always hav to chose the middle way rather than her forcing decisions on dhara.

since we already know how anuj is as a person, i wuld say NOOOOOOOO Amber shulnd't goo!!! it'll be the biggest mistake of their lives.

Originally posted by: misanthrope

Since Amber lives ina a small hilltown..i do't expect her to know tht ppl struggle thruout their lives to make it big in Bollywood ..fer being singers, actors, directors, etc.

So she's naive in this sence ..n also immature as she seems to forget many times tht she shares a life w/ dhara..n they always hav to chose the middle way rather than her forcing decisions on dhara.

since we already know how anuj is as a person, i wuld say NOOOOOOOO Amber shulnd't goo!!! it'll be the biggest mistake of their lives.

i know right!....she doesnt know that life is all about stuggling and stuf...she shouldnt go!

I am also partly in favour and partly not..
Amber is rite in sum ways sayin that she has the rite to dream and fulfill her dreams like every human.. Since she stays in panchgani its nt piossible for her to do so thus she wants 2 go to Mumbai but sadly she isnt aware of the things there.. She also is rite in the sense that she wants respect from ppl and not sympathy..
But then she shudnt run away like that and she shud also think about dhara and her mom.. Also Anuj isnt a nice person and she may land herself into seep trouble by accepting his offer..

yes and no...
yes because she is right in a way by syaing that her and Dhara also have a right to fullfill their dreams and make their identity known to the worls as normal people not conjoined twins

no because she is forgetting that Dhara is also associated with her...but she should try to blackmail Lata and Dhara