HR - 'You sang well, BUT'

"You sang well but Aneek will also sing well."

Is anybody else getting tired of these constant comparisons? I don't see any of the other mentors talking about another contestant when giving their judgement. It's not fair on Amanat for somebody to constantly steal his thunder. I don't understand why HR can't just comment on Amanat, and leave it at that. It's getting really tiring!

HR is really pathetic it seems 2 me like he has got no faith in Aneek or something like that.

I am getting so tired of that crap.

Not only with Amanat. After Raja's singing, he fights with VS every single time and makes Raja accept whatever crap he is saying. He is really annoying. Why is he so insecure of other singers.

omg i was just talking to my sister about that. he is such a disgusting guy. he is never genuinely happy for any of the contestants except aneek.

yea, no matter its Raja or Amanat, whoever gets praise from other judges or guests, HR immediately says "mere sweet sweet Aneek also..."
I am tired of hearing this...when he is praising Amanat , why to compare with Aneek, he can say at the end, ki all sang well or one got over the other...

like wat da hell he is suppose to comment on their singing how they sang but he starts talking anout anik like wat da **** 😡

OMG EXACTLYYY and he does in every single episode and have u noticed no other judge that besides him ..
this is what i posted in another discussion and i willpost it here as well
maybe its just me but everytime a performance that happens before aneeks (or after) goes really well.. he praises that participant and then a second after he brings aneek up and makes some sort of comparison like he steals the limelight from that participant and just talks abt aneek on and on .. again mayb its just me but he always does that when amanat delivers an amazing performance.. its just annoying to watch.. like HR buddy we underdstand your obsession w/ aneek but when the judges along w/ yrself r judging another particpant please stop w/ yr aneek bakwaas.. we hear it enough to begin w/..and btw he probably PAYS everyone to come on the stage for aneek

Originally posted by: divya_p

"You sang well but Aneek will also sing well."

Is anybody else getting tired of these constant comparisons? I don't see any of the other mentors talking about another contestant when giving their judgement. It's not fair on Amanat for somebody to constantly steal his thunder. I don't understand why HR can't just comment on Amanat, and leave it at that. It's getting really tiring!

I don agree HR doing right last time vinit lost from his home...this time he is serious..thats all so he has to push and lead everytime cause this is WAR place not a friendly place no one will share who will win...so no dosti just WAR ...and get the title...so HR doing 100% right..thats why ANIK is number one together india and also international....cause they didn't come here for dosti they came here for fight not dosti...so HR doing right pushing....i m proud of it...thats how a bathroom singer won the title in Indian Idol if someone like HR would push AMIT PAUL he would have the winner...so HR DOING RIGHT 😃

While watching the episode just before HR started speaking after Amanat's performance... my friend (who was visiting me)and me both had a bet as to which sentence it will be when he brings in Aneek's name while comparing.. 😆 And I won. 😆 😆