Farah - right judgement???

in yesterday's show farah made a comment about srgmp and other shows

she said like she was also judged a show and never came across talent like this and she praised the top 3 .

last year were was her judgement when she supported sandeep over karunya, did karunya was poor than these 3 contestants and sandeep?

wah wah farah kya judgement.

same thoughts crossed my mind.karunya is extremely good.

I do not know if Farah supported Sandeep over Karunya since I have not watched Inidan idol much, but her comment that she never came across singers like these in her earlier show is absolutely true.

These 3 are truly gems & rare finds. Karunya is also very good, but I think these 3 are better.

Promotion of her movie is more imp than anything else.Joypal u cant say these 3 guys are better than Karunya.Karunya is brilliant and is technically flawless and composes his own songs .Indian idol has not given them a chance to make them sing all kinds of songs.You have not heard Karunya sing classical so you do not know.
Last year singers there was not this much hype too.

It is Farah Khan Kundar's opinion, she said what she felt and it is true that she said so.

The way our three finalists gave their peroformances on saturday 29-09-2007, i also felt that i have never come across such performances in any of the shows before, now this is just a feeling i had which cannot be proven or discredited by arguments!!

Originally posted by: amukta

Promotion of her movie is more imp than anything else.Joypal u cant say these 3 guys are better than Karunya.Karunya is brilliant and is technically flawless and composes his own songs .Indian idol has not given them a chance to make them sing all kinds of songs.You have not heard Karunya sing classical so you do not know.
Last year singers there was not this much hype too.

i agree !

If she said that; Let's face it, it's a fact. I know Karunya and Amey and Antara were awesome last year but that was about it. Then we got Sandeep and Anuj in top4; both of whom had no sur and singing. Whereas in saregamapa, we have exceptional singers one after the other, amanat, raja, aneek, sumedha, mussarat, junaid, harpreet..etc. If she commented, that means in "overall performance".

I would agree with Farah on this....SRGMP has produced the best singers 😊

Originally posted by: amukta

Promotion of her movie is more imp than anything else.Joypal u cant say these 3 guys are better than Karunya.Karunya is brilliant and is technically flawless and composes his own songs .Indian idol has not given them a chance to make them sing all kinds of songs.You have not heard Karunya sing classical so you do not know.
Last year singers there was not this much hype too.

I already admitted that Karunya is a very good singer, but I find the 3 on this show better than him, It's my opinion and I think I'm allowed to voice it.

farah is right, indian idol 2 has only kanurya which can sing well however the three contenstant of srgm are more talented and from past performance we saw that they are not only good in normal filmi playback singing but also in traditional gazals, qawalis and pops.