Rani an analysis - Page 3

Originally posted by: darkknight420

first of all mixing laxatives are not that big crime,if it comes to matter of love.it is known laxative will effect him for just few hours,nothing harmfull gonn happen to him.

Like seriously? You mean to say mixing laxatives in food is not a "serious" crime? Then what is? You "love" a person ( I mean not you if anyone) they can mix "laxative in the food or "spike" their drink and get them to "bed" or rape or stuff like that ? Saying all is fair in love and war . Don't know how that saying came into beling but if there is manipulation then love dies. and mixing anything in the food specially like laxatives causing them discomfort when they are least expecting it is a serious crime. In fact it is more serious crime than murder . Nobody has any right to do that and then "defend" it saying it is not that serious a crime. I know a person who mixed laxative in a person's food saying he is relieving them of "constipation" but the other person was travelling and it hurt for days and they did not know what caused the condition. when a person eats laxative on their own they do it at their convenience . Not at some inconvenient time or when they are travelling. Yes to me it is serious crime . I bet it is for many others too. Not to be justified.

secondly,she is not the main lead,so its not must that she sud be the fair one.

I don't know about that. But as a person who goes behind Amit and Sarla I feel her own criminal actions are not justified. Be it pushing Sarla into the well or mixing laxatives in the food.

thirdly,u have not seen her that sarla or amit gave her hope and deceived.but i saw in episodes that sarla uses her for household chores and giving hopes.so in this her fault is one and thats 'believing sarla'

Sarla gave her what type of hope? Like she is going to be the bahu? that is before Amit saw Riya? I have not seen it much . May be they did not show it that much. If Amit told her he loved her and would marry her then yes it is bad. But does not justify what Rani is doing. one can break engagement or GF/BF thingy and the other partner cannot stalk . Marriages break in this day and age. For that Rani is taking revenge . I feel she is doing the wrong thing.

fourthly,you told,' marrying Amit is something she can do only if Amit is fine with it.'
but dear what is amit doing to riya,amit totally deceiving her.so for this kind of people that kind of rule is not applicable,bcoz they r mean

Does not justify. If Amit does not want her then he does not want her . Amit is mean . How much has he borrowed from Rani? How much work has she done for Sarla? Does that mean she can do all this criminal stuff just because she is deceived. It is against the law means against the law.

fifth,pushing sarla to well.ok,lets we keep all sarla,s evilness aside,just come to the 'pushing to well' matter.sarla was pushed to well,shivam saved her,but after geting saved,she again started planning evil against shivam.so do u thing she deserves sympathy,or right wrong criteria.

All that is true. But a crime is not justified. A crime is a crime. Attempt to murder by Rani . No excuses. no justifications. period. Sarla plots . Sarla will get punished. But what Rani did is what Rani did .

sixth,its a serial.not reallityso any character cud go any limit,no boundary

Sahi kaha aapne. Cvs make and break characters. so ....

seventh,for some people gandhibaad is not totally applicable,otherwise you will be dead,with hanging a jaimala in your photo.

I don't understand this . kindly explain. what is Gandhibaad?

Originally posted by: ASH_99

And that qualifies Rani to be part of Sarla Family... 😆. That proves only Rani can be Sarls's DIL..

Originally posted by: pyaaribehna

Rani loves Amit.

Rani is desperate

Rani is an orphan

Rani's aunt gives her ultimatum

Rani visits Sarla's house from childhood

Rani loves Amit who does not love her or rather does not want to marry her.

Sarla calls her servant. Sarla can afford servants? I wonder

Rani is brave and fights.

All that is fine. But when Amit does not want to marry her Rani is behind Amit even at his wedding. Is that a right thing to do?

Rani mixes laxative in Amit's food saying maaf karna but I love you . Is that right? If she loves Amit why mix laxative of all things in his food?

Now bothering him to marry her is that right?

Amit and Sarla are bad people . That is a different issue

But doing what Rani does under the name of love isn't it wrong/

Rani is going to help Shivam and Riya yeh baat alag hain.

Rani is necessary for the story to move forward. That is a different matter

But Rani bothering Amit even as he gets ready for the wedding is that right?

Last but not the least Rani pushing Sarla into the well isn't that a criminal thing to do?

Maa bete ne mil kar golmaal kiya hain. But pushing Sarla into the well is that the right thing to do? Rather isn't that a criminal thing to do?

Rani may have known Amit since childhoold but that does not give her any right over Amit.

Forget that Amit is the bad guy here. Whatever he is what Rani is doing is wrong.

What does anyone think?

Originally posted by: sweet_tehs

Just because Rani is playing the bechari here she is gaining sympathy...

N just because Amit is shown in bad light people think that poor rani...

But she is doing nothing less than what Tanveer was doing for Asad in Qubool Hai..

She even claimed to have slept with him on his wedding night ...

So rani here is no different from Tanveer just that they have been treated differently.

Originally posted by: pyaaribehna