Why is the audience unable to accept a changed Shagun ? - Page 5

Created

Last reply

Replies

48

Views

5.1k

Users

30

Likes

169

Frequent Posters

Jinvera thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#41
bcoz it's Unreaalistic..We r interested in Watching Raman and Ishita not Shagun it's LOVESTORY not some Creepy..If u want to see Shagun u can 😡
sunitas123 thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#42

Originally posted by: wendy25


I dont know about the marriage but yea CVs are trying to hard to keep Shagun's story alive even if no one is interested to see how she interferes in IshRa's life.
Now i feel that its not Shagun is there to trouble IshRa but more like IshRa is there to get troubled by Shagun.


Very well said and Krishy too. It is not that she is positive or negative, but since last November we r fed up of her hogging all screen space and all else taking a back seat!

Abhilasha, it is 180 deg turn u r talking of not 360. 360 would mean Shagun back to square one, that is no change!

I think the Cvs were supposed to show her positive after leap which wud have made sense since there wud have been a considerable time lag and ishra wud have moved forward in their relationship. However, she has been a constant pain and reason for them scrapping all their dates/holiday plans..

Now they have got her back in a month and that too so famous? Anita herslef is not that famous in a city like Mumbai after so many years in movies and TV and after having so much Ekta support! Then how did Shagun become so well-known in Mumbai in less than a month? i cud have understood if she was living in a shady town...LOL

And her sudden overwhleming love for Ruhi? Or even Ruhi seeing her in her dream?

Fact remains that no matter how positive she becomes, her motive will be to get back her kids from ishra or break ishra. Else, she has no relevance in the plot. So to me, Shagun is always negative as far as Ishra are concerned.

As for Bhallas, they may forgive her after all she has given them GKC, which ishita is unable to do...

However, I dont see any impact on ishra except for her again spoiling all their personal time, as uaual. And if Cvs show Ishita cancer and Shagun back with Bhallas, we can forever stop watching. Even now watching her with better wardrobe than the leads and so much screen time is annoying!




Springlover thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 10 years ago
#43
its not realistic to change like this so suddenly..may be after yrs if its shown its okay.but it has not even bcme 1 yr.
iffanvidz thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#44
If she was shown like working under a person facing some problem to live and struggling.. I wud hav digested..but again showing like indepenent work nature..she dont hav any experience ..how come she can start ngo ,who is helping..even raman didn't think about starting his own firm..after all he got more experience in his field..if they showed shagun struggling for life, and rewind her mistake ,i wud hav enjoyed,they didn't even show this..still travelling in luxury car doesnt make sense..even toshiji and ishitha are using auto..let her change i dont mind..but show some struggling part or else it won't match the story..
The_Imane thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 10 years ago
#45

Originally posted by: iffanvidz

If she was shown like working under a person facing some problem to live and struggling.. I wud hav digested..but again showing like indepenent work nature..she dont hav any experience ..how come she can start ngo ,who is helping..even raman didn't think about starting his own firm..after all he got more experience in his field..if they showed shagun struggling for life, and rewind her mistake ,i wud hav enjoyed,they didn't even show this..still travelling in luxury car doesnt make sense..even toshiji and ishitha are using auto..let her change i dont mind..but show some struggling part or else it won't match the story..

I somehow agree
They could have given her a poor job and make her sruggle
That would have made some sense..
The NGO angle is anyway OTT
iffanvidz thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#46
Let shagun work in ngo as an employee..but not the owner.
ananya10 thumbnail
10th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#47
There is nothing wrong with a changed Shagun. But the way its been shown is what is unacceptable. I do agree that people do change but here the change is totally OTT. Shagun has always been portrayed a selfish character. Such a character being all selfless and fighting for others' welfare is unacceptable. Not everyone who has a change of heart goes on opening NGOs. It would have been better if they showed Shagun as a normal independent working woman regretting her doings towards Adi-Ruhi rather than this new version running a NGO and giving out OTT dialogues. Also her sudden love and affection towards Ruhi. It would have been better had she worried baout Adi rather than Ruhi .
Other than that, its really difficult to tolerate Shagun on screen for a good 15 minutes of a 22 min epi regardless of her being positive/negative/grey. After being through an overdose of Shagun from January I really dont think its wrong if the viewers would want some time without her specially when there is no need of her presence in the story right now. But CVs and their undying love for Shagun.
shivangi838 thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 10 years ago
#48
people do change in real life but this complete turnover of shagun is few days looks forced , cannot digest her in dis positive avatar till now 😕
iammayurfan thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#49
It is very unconvincing that Shagun needs to change this much for YHM story to progress. How much ever we ignore can't help if it is more external influence. It cannot be its only coincidence that Anita is Ekta's bestest buddy, Karan and her proclaim they are more comfortable. She is not happy with negative vibes. So if I was Ekta's why would I not get my production house to portray her as a better character and see if she gets more praises. It has TrPs now so do the friend a favour

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".