Amit spoiled tanhai tanhai(lyrics)... - Page 4

Originally posted by: ZHCool

the fact of matter is that in finale amit fans are totally unable to defend their beloved 😆

why do we have to defend him? amit has proved himself time and again. he pulled off bulla ki jaana with aplomb, and was very good with hamma hamma too. it's 2/3 for amit and 1/3 for prashant. it's just prashant fans who're trying to create trouble here.

Amit has redefined consistency..
Even the best in other shows have had bad days..but not Amit in the galas..
Amit will make us proud... Hope he wins this time..He so deserves the title now.
I support AMIT..Do you?
Yes? then what are u waiting for.....

SMS AMIT to 52525.
Or Vote via Landline dial 19024242525 01 (MTNL/BSNL)

Originally posted by: Pseudonym

why do we have to defend him? amit has proved himself time and again. he pulled off bulla ki jaana with aplomb, and was very good with hamma hamma too. it's 2/3 for amit and 1/3 for prashant. it's just prashant fans who're trying to create trouble here.

u just manuplating every one knows that amit was far far behind than prashant in gala also in concert. in concert amit was totally outclass, the only performance which amit fans shows was bhulla and they r asking votes for only bhula kii jana.. so prashant have many thing in his sides, like tanhai, bari muskil hai, and the concert of mumbai where he rocked

amit wasn't bad in the mumbai concert by any stretch of the imagination...a lot of people i know found him brilliant so please stop passing YOUR opinion as a widespread truth. you'll come across many members here on this very forum who enjoyed his performance as much as you enjoyed prashant's. and amit's hamma hamma was extremely well sung. if prashant has those performances behind him (according to you), then amit has all his gala performances to speak for him.

Originally posted by: Pseudonym

amit wasn't bad in the mumbai concert by any stretch of the imagination...a lot of people i know found him brilliant so please stop passing YOUR opinion as a widespread truth. you'll come across many members here on this very forum who enjoyed his performance as much as you enjoyed prashant's. and amit's hamma hamma was extremely well sung. if prashant has those performances behind him (according to you), then amit has all his gala performances to speak for him.

i dont think u properly following the finale. amit was really good singer of 60 and 70's songs and before final he sang many of same types of songs and get appreciations however he havent try new thing and that limitations of amit effects his performance at finale and at finale whether u accept or no he totally outclass by prashant. expect one song bhulla he has no performance at all.

and i think you should stop trying to pass opinion for facts. i've watched every single gala episode and amit has proved his versatility with fast songs like gustakh dil, disco tracks like yaad aa raha hain and fun songs like main hoon jhumroo. i think you're just looking for something to pick on. when emon was around, people tried to put him down by constantly accusing him of trying to imitate sonu, with amit it's all about how he's not versatile. seriously, prashant fans need to organise a committee that is creative with finding flaws in the other contestants 'cause the present ones are just too old and baseless.

Originally posted by: r_tvfan

People are treating this like some game show or game of cricket. In singing you have to be consistent. If you have bad days and cannot sing well in the recording studio, the music director won't call you again. Both Prashant and Amit forgot the tune or lyrics. Why are we comparing who forgot more and less? Is this some memory test? The tanhayee song was not the deciding song. All 3 songs were equally important. Amit scored in 2 of them, so he is still ahead.

Agreed. Amit was way ahead and he stays ahead...

Originally posted by: Pseudonym

and i think you should stop trying to pass opinion for facts. i've watched every single gala episode and amit has proved his versatility with fast songs like gustakh dil, disco tracks like yaad aa raha hain and fun songs like main hoon jhumroo. i think you're just looking for something to pick on. when emon was around, people tried to put him down by constantly accusing him of trying to imitate sonu, with amit it's all about how he's not versatile. seriously, prashant fans need to organise a committee that is creative with finding flaws in the other contestants 'cause the present ones are just too old and baseless.

i think we have to put the decision on public and public is the ultimate authority to chose their idol if they think amit is good then they will vote and if they think prashant was better than amit they vote for prashant. and i have full confidence on public that this time they will definatly do the right decision

Originally posted by: yahoo123

Ya I also felt he was completely lost in that song. When prasant missed a beat in his first song the judges made big issue out of that but they did not say anything to Amit. I think Anu Malik gave comment from his heart. Prasant ne sacchinme aag lagadee.

Prasant Rocks!!!

uh hell no.. they didnt make a big deal outta prashant they jus said he missed da lines listen to it again cuz i did nd only anu said a lil bit nd so did javed but they ALSO said he was awsum too...

There is no need to degrade any contestant. It will not be tolerated here. Saying so and so spoiled a particular song is insulting and degrading a contestant's performance, and hurting their fans feelings. Be careful of how you word your thoughts and opinions.

This topic is creating a non-friendly environment therefore is being closed.