Why judges dont like Prashant?

Amazinggg thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#1
I don know why the judges cant praise PRASHANT sings well? Why, whats wrong with them? When he sang in such a great style BADI MUSKIL HAI.... Javed Jee said "Perfect, flawless, bahut achcha" cant he say some more praising words like "You were fantastic and u sang like Indian Idol or someting" and when Prashant missed one word they make a PAHAD of it and when Amit missed whole ANTARA judges said its a minor mistake. WHY is it so????????

Alisha never supports PRASHANT, ok he did not impress her by his style and looks but what the hell she said 10 on 10 but said nothing else.....why all the judges are being biased to him? I dont know why she is there as a judge who likes the BESURA like Suhit?

Have u ever seen Javed smiling when he commented on Prashant? and even the anchors are biased. I think nobody on the show wants him to be the IDOL. No doubt, Amit is a GREAT---EXTRA ORDINARY SINGER but that does not mean there should be BIASED comments.

I dont know what Prashant might be feeling then. Have u ever experienced when u were not given credits for the GOOD work u have done by putting great effort. Prashant put his sweat and blood to sing those songs and did not even get the comments which he deserve. But he is a GREAT FIGHTER.

He feels very lonely and rejected on the show but thats the time when u have to show your HERONESS and he is doing that....

I respect Anu Malik for letting JANTA know by his courageous comments.

Aap bhi apne haat dil me rakhkar kahiye, Isnt PRASHANT being neglected by the judges and anchors in one way or other?




Created

Last reply

Replies

35

Views

2.4k

Users

24

Frequent Posters

.:Ashi:. thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#2
well maybe they think amit is better 😉
peaceforall thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#3
No because they all are biased..........it's very clear.
musica_1 thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#4
I fully agree with Amagingggg. From the very first beginning he has been neglected. May be this is the main source of his courage and fighting spirit. Of course he is shy, introvert, doesn't mean that he doesn't deserve a praise.

From the beginning I noticed that f***king Mini and Hussain never ever highlighted Prashant in whole shows. Now when only two left, its still visible. And these judges limit thier words to praise him. I don't know why even Udit Narayan backs up praising him wholeheartedly, is he afraid that others will blame him praising a nepali being a nepali?

Such behave and observations developed racism in Indian Idol III which is not good for Sony TV in long run. Whats Prashant's fault? He is honest, kind hearted, innocent, introvert, generous, simple and what not. He possesses all the good qualities to be a human, to be a grandson, to be a son, to be a brother and to be a friend.
Because he is from a family where they speak nepali is the reason to be ignored in whole shows?

But who cares, Prashant own janatas hearts and now in their hearts. He will be there forever.

Mosammad thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#5
well....yeaa...i think they are all biased towards amit..and its a bit unfair...so its good that annuji is there to support prashat...so i've heard 😊
Amazinggg thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#6
😃

Originally posted by: Mosammad

well....yeaa...i think they are all biased towards amit..and its a bit unfair...so its good that annuji is there to support prashat...so i've heard 😊

orchid10 thumbnail
Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#7
I don't know why even Udit Narayan backs up praising him wholeheartedly, is he afraid that others will blame him praising a nepali being a nepali? [/quote]

I understand Udit's delimma, as a judge he can't even be perceived to like one contestants over another. He is in an akward position already. Forget that, when that poor guy voiced his less than positive opinion about Amit, there was hue and cry right from JA downwards.

Amazinggg thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#8

Originally posted by: musica_1

I fully agree with Amagingggg. From the very first beginning he has been neglected. May be this is the main source of his courage and fighting spirit. Of course he is shy, introvert, doesn't mean that he doesn't deserve a praise.

From the beginning I noticed that f***king Mini and Hussain never ever highlighted Prashant in whole shows. Now when only two left, its still visible. And these judges limit thier words to praise him. I don't know why even Udit Narayan backs up praising him wholeheartedly, is he afraid that others will blame him praising a nepali being a nepali?

Such behave and observations developed racism in Indian Idol III which is not good for Sony TV in long run. Whats Prashant's fault? He is honest, kind hearted, innocent, introvert, generous, simple and what not. He possesses all the good qualities to be a human, to be a grandson, to be a son, to be a brother and to be a friend.
Because he is from a family where they speak nepali is the reason to be ignored in whole shows?

But who cares, Prashant own janatas hearts and now in their hearts. He will be there forever.



Well said Musica---dheari ramro
FanofAngad thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#9
because they r baised...and racist.... 🤢 ..
they were never ever fair to prashant...

btw not only judges.. hosts r like that too 😕 😕 😕 ..
i hadnt expect this from hussain n mini 😡
shyamidutt thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 90 Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 18 years ago
#10

Originally posted by: Amazinggg

I don know why the judges cant praise PRASHANT sings well? Why, whats wrong with them? When he sang in such a great style BADI MUSKIL HAI.... Javed Jee said "Perfect, flawless, bahut achcha" cant he say some more praising words like "You were fantastic and u sang like Indian Idol or someting" and when Prashant missed one word they make a PAHAD of it and when Amit missed whole ANTARA judges said its a minor mistake. WHY is it so????????

Alisha never supports PRASHANT, ok he did not impress her by his style and looks but what the hell she said 10 on 10 but said nothing else.....why all the judges are being biased to him? I dont know why she is there as a judge who likes the BESURA like Suhit?

Have u ever seen Javed smiling when he commented on Prashant? and even the anchors are biased. I think nobody on the show wants him to be the IDOL. No doubt, Amit is a GREAT---EXTRA ORDINARY SINGER but that does not mean there should be BIASED comments.

I dont know what Prashant might be feeling then. Have u ever experienced when u were not given credits for the GOOD work u have done by putting great effort. Prashant put his sweat and blood to sing those songs and did not even get the comments which he deserve. But he is a GREAT FIGHTER.

He feels very lonely and rejected on the show but thats the time when u have to show your HERONESS and he is doing that....

I respect Anu Malik for letting JANTA know by his courageous comments.

Aap bhi apne haat dil me rakhkar kahiye, Isnt PRASHANT being neglected by the judges and anchors in one way or other?




Prashant is not that good a singer. He is ok but not good enough to be in the finale. Everyone knows that, but this voting system makes them helpless. They cant just praise him, they did the best they could. You have to be good to get praise.

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".