I likr alya and its very sad that all the reqtion she gave importance ended on a bad note wheather it was with manio, dhruv or harshad... With harshad she cant even end thinks and move on...
With manik they were never ment to be and she was at fault but considering that both of them were childhood frnds and were together for 7 yrs she did deserve a second chance... We all love manan and their romance so her not getting a second chance wqs gud for us but in real she did deserve a second chance... Except for sending goons behind nandu she was a gud gf... Itz just that manik and her couldnt connect well... She understands manik but didnt knew how to get through him like nandu does...
With dhruv she did try a lot to save the relation but dhruv insulted her beyond limits... I think dhruv hurted her the most coz she never expected something like thaf from dhruv... She knew that manik will break up with her if he comes to know abt the goons and she knew harshad was not trustworthy... So when her relation eith them took a wrong route it didnt affect her much... The sadest part is dhruv didnt even apologized to her properly and started to show his right on her when aryaman came to the scene... He kind of sees her as an object rather than a person which he owns and alya certainly dont deserve that...
With harshad, initally he did care for alya but cv's ruined his character beyond repair... Initially alya was more imp to him than his evil plans and manik... He was ready to jepordize his image a in front of navni to save alya by keeping numb on thr goons feasco and went with alya to search her car keys leaving his plan to hurt manik... Her relation with harshad went down the hill coz of bad writing...