Doctor's at such a young age?

ts9787 thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#1
So Ranbir and Suhani are very young...not more than 22-23 years old, with Suhani being 18, right? Then how is it that Ranbir is already a doctor and Suhani is studying to become a doctor? In the US, becoming a doctor is such a long process. It takes a person until they are around 27 to be done with med school and then they start residency. Unless Ranbir is a genius and went through school very quickly, there is no way he is already a doctor. He would probably be in his first year of med school. As for Suhani, she has to go through undergrad first and then get into med school. She still has at least 8 years to go, since she started college recently.

The writers are horrible with making things realistic. At the very least, they should have done some research.

Created

Last reply

Replies

19

Views

2.1k

Users

12

Likes

33

Frequent Posters

Indian_Drama thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#2
I agree, The Credit of these illogical understanding of how it goes with medical profession goes to the CH Nivedita Basu ... She seems to have very less knowledge of the whole medical profession tenure & she brings the characters who are 18-22 become docs or already proficient in the field...

Even Nishi she was aspiring & got her married off to get Neil to India ... Really what is realistic what is right the writers & the creatve head have no clue & they think audiences & virwers who know these aspects are fools to watch & digest the tracks
-Rimsha-sizzles thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 10 years ago
#3
Tell me about it!
I live in USA & 20 years old an undergraduate (Junior) student in a regular college... NB is so messed up!
Even if Suhani is 18 years she should just finish High School or must be a freshmen in college/university...
d3c3nt thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#4
These kids are in BT Land ruled by NB. They are going to do it in reverse order.

Its not only about Ranbir and Suhani, but the new kid intro Suhani's boyfriend is 22 Kartik Kumar and he has already done wonders on IVF.


DiscoDhokla thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#5
Nivedita basu's illogical answers to these questions-- watch grey' anatomy 👎🏼
Danseuse thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#6

@ts9787 : Very apt title. Even I was baffled.

Though the initial storyline was indeed promising and v different from the saas-bahu sagas (which I am proud to say I hav never watched),has now been reduced to vague concepts to test a viewers intelligence!! Strangely, the reason for the separation of the two lead protagonists was laughable. 😆 Four kids in five years (aren't we all educated enough to follow family planning) and which showed that they must hav spent lots of time in bed!! (LOL)...

After being so close and in love, the reason was so trivial. They don't even discuss the issue and just turn around and walk away and split the family!! 😕 Now after 15 years they fall in love again and again separate! 😲 Further, Ragini's kids are good for nothing's, while Nachiket has made his kids super humans!! Interesting economic and social divide. As a viewer I would hav admired the Creatives if they had shown Aarav to be a mature kid since he lives with a single mom. Boys are usually that way!! Here, Nachiket gives him money, is solely responsible for sending him to jail ( as Ragini had warned him about Aarav's immaturity) and is gloating in US about his achievements.

So a single mother who works hard to make a living, is honest and upright (thou full of pride) and takes care if her children /mother/ grandmother is painted a villian; whereas a single dad whose sister takes care of him and his children and can therefore spare enough time to become a good Doc is painted a savior. 😲 😲

Now its his children's turn to become larger than life... 😃

Very immature script, makes me wonder the quality of Creatives in daily soaps? What is actual criteria for selection? Does the merit lie in dragging the serial for years with absurd content? Maybe...


-Rekha
Indian_Drama thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#7
@Danseuse perfectly put
More agreeable

Very immature script, makes me wonder the quality of Creatives in daily soaps? What is actual criteria for selection? Does the merit lie in dragging the serial for years with absurd content? Maybe...

The CH does minimal research thinks they know story telling , & when corrected on twitter they bring their horns up & say we criticize.. An urban educated crowd is watching this show & knows that to expect not just random people who need awareness & education like in shows which r trying to reach out to areas...

Lots of flaws ..
d3c3nt thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#8
@Danseuse well said.

Now its his children's turn to become larger than life... 😃


Exactly where this is all going.

Danseuse thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#9

I guess it's time for Creative writers to ensure that they are good at what they do. No taking viewers for a ride pl. What amused me the most was the dramatic entry of Ronnie for making some scathing remarks and then disappearing into thin air!!! 😃 Was it really necessary to introduce that character to be gone so soon? Now that he has come and gone, am sure he wl be re-introduced later when the writer is at her wits end. 😃

In today's era, we hav a mature audience who accept diverse scripts like Piku /PK/ Tanu weds Manu returns etc. TV serial producers need to embrace this change and admit to themselves that from Teens to Sr Citizens, there is a very intelligent audience out here and respect the same. Even when an element of mystery is introduced to keep the audience glued to the sets, its not carried thru well by the Creatives of Itna karo na...! 😕 Relationships are shown to be fickle and destructive.

Well, a change is always welcome...in the storyline, to make it more realistic and challenging.


-Rekha
Indian_Drama thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#10

Originally posted by: Danseuse


I guess it's time for Creative writers to ensure that they are good at what they do. No taking viewers for a ride pl. What amused me the most was the dramatic entry of Ronnie for making some scathing remarks and then disappearing into thin air!!! 😃 Was it really necessary to introduce that character to be gone so soon? Now that he has come and gone, am sure he wl be re-introduced later when the writer is at her wits end. 😃

In today's era, we hav a mature audience who accept diverse scripts like Piku /PK/ Tanu weds Manu returns etc. TV serial producers need to embrace this change and admit to themselves that from Teens to Sr Citizens, there is a very intelligent audience out here and respect the same. Even when an element of mystery is introduced to keep the audience glued to the sets, its not carried thru well by the Creatives of Itna karo na...! 😕 Relationships are shown to be fickle and destructive.

Well, a change is always welcome...in the storyline, to make it more realistic and challenging.


-Rekha

you have spoken my words.
Simplicity & giving good layering in storytelling and getting audience to feel the reasoning of life with the show lacks big tine the creative head has limited knowledge of the relationship aspects derives some immature knowledge seen bits pieces here & there gluing & making it a deliverable lacks quality 👎🏼 ..Again whats in phase two of post seperarion & for ehat sake & the etra above superior one set of kids while the others suffer have to see.

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".