if you could change something - Page 2

Originally posted by: chatterbox

yaar LL i know that

but topic is what wud u like to change

and as it is i think whatever the plot it was perfect

snape was goin to die

but my point was mayb i wud hv wanted him tolive and mayb show things differently

but yes james and snape had too much hatred between them to change the feelings

bt ur last line

james hate club and snape love club haha thas funny

and see james was shown as good guy from beginning and later on went to show how arrogant he was and enjoyed mischief but he was ok later with lily and james and sirius used to tease snape

see the point here is james and lily say were in guest appearances

where as snape was there from the beginning and from the first book only his character is mysterious

no one likes him or trusts him as he was a death eater

thas why i felt he shud hv been given one chance i guess to clear with harry mayb

yah i think its snape 2

The only person i'd think of bringing back would be Fred, dont wanna bring Snape, DD, or Serious back cause all the important characters are the one's that are dead but Fred's death was totally out of place, the only thing wrong with the book, everything else was perfect i think it was nice(heartbreaking though) that at the end all the former high school classmates ended up dying for the same cause.....

Originally posted by: zaara_13_9

The only person i'd think of bringing back would be Fred, dont wanna bring Snape, DD, or Serious back cause all the important characters are the one's that are dead but Fred's death was totally out of place, the only thing wrong with the book, everything else was perfect i think it was nice(heartbreaking though) that at the end all the former high school classmates ended up dying for the same cause.....

this point i also liked though

all the former classmates died and it was like end of an era and new era began

why i wanted snape back or mayb just mayb i think it wud hv seemd even better if snape had been able to tell harry the truth direct instead from his memories but otherwise the plot was perfect

and of fred death i think one of them wud hv died i didnt like it but i think it was ok

one of the weasleys was bound to be killed

if u remember molly boggart

she always knew she wud lose someone