leavesandwaves thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 10 years ago
#1
I am in two minds about ganga. One part of me says, she is right in not showing too much warmth and acceding to the request. It is not because they ill treated her. It is the present that makes ganga apprehensive. If mannu comes to know the truth, how he may react.She knows mannu is sensitive and this truth may upset him. His bond with Jagya may not be the same afterwards. Even his bond with abhi may change.

While Jagya is confident that he can deal with mannu and his trauma. Thats why he is encouraging ganga to tell the truth and get it over once and for all. Otherwise it will always be like Damocles's sword hanging overhead.


Created

Last reply

Replies

3

Views

713

Users

4

Likes

6

Frequent Posters

Mehek134 thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#2
Ganga is in dilemma not because Mannu's bond with Jagya and abhi may change She is only in dilemma that Mannu will have a heart break knowing what kind of person his real father is No child will be happy to know he has Ratan Singh as his father . Mannu will surely want to know about his biological father she cannot make him accept this by saying Jagya is not biological father Ratan is . Ganga will have to tell him even if she does not tell all details of her life sufferings by ratan singh but why her marriage did not work with Ratan why Mannu is with them not with his father . Mannu is not going to be most happiest knowing the monster Ratan is his father The child will surely break down
Jagya is complete right The matter of fact they cannot hide this truth from mannu life long Before he comes to know from any outsider which will be shocking for him Ganga should tell him on his own He did not judge what will be Mannu's reaction Even he says i don't know what will be Mannu's reaction but they have to deal it They will have to make Mannu understand and handle his trauma Coming to know from outsider will not be good It may be shocking and can cause misunderstandings if Ganga tells him it will be shocking heart breaking they will support him but there will be no misunderstanding in his mind
GoodDoc_2105 thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 180 Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 10 years ago
#3

Originally posted by: leavesandwaves

I am in two minds about ganga. One part of me says, she is right in not showing too much warmth and acceding to the request. It is not because they ill treated her. It is the present that makes ganga apprehensive. If mannu comes to know the truth, how he may react.She knows mannu is sensitive and this truth may upset him. His bond with Jagya may not be the same afterwards. Even his bond with abhi may change.

While Jagya is confident that he can deal with mannu and his trauma. Thats why he is encouraging ganga to tell the truth and get it over once and for all. Otherwise it will always be like Damocles's sword hanging overhead.


Well Ganga's fears regarding Mannu Ratan issue are understandable but the way she is handling the issue will make things worse.

How Mannu will react is a big issue that has made her push this thing under carpet for too long.

Now Mannu got to know about Jagya Anandi child marriage issue. This issue may not affect Shivam and Anhi that much since they are small kids and don't as of now know what a failed marriage means But Mannu is a little older than these two kids and he just becoming aware of man woman relationship.
Jagya did tell him in a very tactful way and yet without hiding the truth about his child marriage.
But still Mannu's mental image of his father received a dent.

In this scenario if truth about biological father comes out Mannu may not take it well.

One secret which was hidden all these years from them had come out and soon after that another truth comes out it will be too much for him to take.

This would have been much better if Ganga agreed to Jagya's stand tackled the bull by it's horns way back then.

Now Bimla will try EB and she is so desperate she may even scheme and plot to make Mannu Ratan meet happen without Ganga's consent or knowledge then things will get uglier.

It is not about Ratan's rights to see his son but about people's behaviour towards a dying man on one side and Mannu's right to know the truth.
It would be so much better if the truth comes from his mother and not Bimla.
If he gets to know from Bimla it will be even worse I hope Ganga realises that.
It is better she reaches him first before anyone else.
Only two options Either she tell Mannu about Ratan or risk the consequences of Mannu knowing it from Bimla.

If truth is hidden it comes out in the most ugly manner - Mannu doesn't deserve that.The fact thta J is adopted father and Ratan is biological father is not going to change it may come out on it's own.But it is better for him if Ganga tells him.


RTee thumbnail
21st Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#4
I am still of the opinion that if the truth is likely to come out through a third party and can do more harm to Mannu, it should be brought out in the open by the person who can do so most gently i.e. Ganga herself.

However if there is no chance of the truth coming out other than when told by Ganga, she can decide what is best for her family.

She is the best judge since she will have to face the consequences if things go wrong in either case. Other people can only guide her based on their knowledge and experience.
Edited by RTee - 10 years ago

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".