Simply Shocked!

Page

Next Last

@-HJ-

Rocker

Posted: 10 years ago

Hey everyone!

Ok so let me start with the MaNan scene today, which was no doubt outstanding and perfectly acted by Parth and Niti.
But understanding the story I am extremely surprised. Why is Manik angry? Just because nandu lied? When he knows that she did it for him then why this much drama? Did he ever listen to her for anything related to Soha? And now he is not even trying to find out whether she is dead or not. Soha is the main cause for their trust issue and he least concerned for that now. Why can't he just tell nandu that nyo told him about pandit visiting her house? Isn't he lying now? He claims that lie can separate them. Earlier it was trust. Like what he wants?
Why does he wants to see her first reaction of nandu on knowing about pandit? This is a bit strange.
The greatest lie Manik told was about the sacrifice for Dhruv and so I don't think he should scold nandu for that.

I wish that CVs show fab5 apologising to Nandini for whatever they did to her and especially Manik as he sacrificed her without even thinking twice. I don't think that friendship is so important that u cant even ask for approval of the person whom you are going to leave for your best friend. That was too much!

P.S. This post is strictly related to the character Manik. It isn't about Parth so please refrain yourself from misunderstanding me. 😊

Thank you! Share your views.

Quote

Frequent Posters

Witcher

@Witcher

Voyager

+ 5

Posted: 10 years ago

Wow I am glad that someone pointed that out

He wants to see her face when she comes to know about Pandit? She obviously won't be happy, she is suspecting that there is something fishy about Pandit but what can she do?

Has Manik thought that Nandini has only one goal and that is to do her very best at the concert and have Manik back. That girl can do literally anything for Manik despite thinking she comes second to him. She can't share her worries about Pandit because if she does what will Manik do? He will get angry and destroy Pandit.

Besides the principle also told her that he doesn't want any problems this time.

Nandini first cried at musicana and couldn't perform (not her fault)

Nandini was kidnapped by Soha and fab5 lost their deal (again not her fault)

Nandini is suffering the most here

Still she is fighting

Thats why I love her

Quote

Looks like you are new here. Register for free, learn and contribute.

Mimi2609

@Mimi2609

Sparkler

+ 4

Posted: 10 years ago

truth is i agree with you!

i understood Manik's anger, but why that the anger was so much i didnt at all

and besides Manik doing same as Nandini, because Nyo is again playing games with Manik and Nandini is ignorant of everything, so how exactly is Manik protecting Nandini from Nyo here?

but i'll let everything pass because anyway Manik seem to think only Pandit is the vilain, but Pandit is only a temporary vilain while Nyo is a permanent vilain, and Nandini should know Nyo's truth and scheming ways to be able to deal with Nyo in future...

let's hope maybe after Pandit fiasco, Manik will open up about Nyo to Nandini

Quote

Sayali_23

@Sayali_23

Rocker

+ 3

Posted: 10 years ago

Thr is a difference between two situations...

in Soha's case Nandini just warns Manik to be careful of Soha when she was feeling jealous... but once she saw Soha talking to Manik's guitar she didn't tell him that... she chose to share that with Cabir thinking Manik will walk out frm the album...

in case of Pandit... Manik is warning Nandini again and again about Pandit's intentions are not good towards her... and still Nandini is ignoring thinking Pandit is AMS student and he will never have bad intentions towards her...

Manik's has a short fuse so he bound to get upset with Nandini for hiding Pandit's visit to her residence for dinner... and once she explained her reasons he immediately cool down...

let's just give him a break after all he is just trying to protect Nandu...

Edited by Smiley_23 - 10 years ago

Quote

shibz

@shibz

Inactive

+ 5

Posted: 10 years ago

Originally posted by: Smiley_23
Thr is a difference between two situations...
in Soha's case Nandini just warns Manik to be careful of Soha when she was feeling jealous... but once she saw Soha talking to Manik's guitar she didn't tell him that... she chose to share that with Cabir thinking Manik will walk out frm the album...

in case of Pandit... Manik is warning Nandini again and again about Pandit's intentions are not good towards her... and still Nandini is ignoring thinking Pandit is AMS student and he will never have bad intentions towards her...

Manik's has a short fuse so he bound to get upset with Nandini for hiding Pandit's visit to her residence for dinner... and once she explained her reasons he immediately cool down...

let's just give him a break after all he is just trying to protect Nandu...

In addition to that..

Nandini was really worried seeing Nyonika the other day.. after that Manik brings her the Hope seeds to boost her confidence and bring back the optimism.. So he may have thought it's not a good idea to let her know it was Nyonika..besides it doesn't matter really.. if you see where he is coming from.. the reason for their trust break in the first place too wasn't Nyonika.. it was Nandini's own doubt.. and they're trying to build it up again.. We can't blame external factors when the weakness is in us..if you're getting what I mean..

Soha? Is she really important from the story perspective? Nahh!

As for Pandit..Manik was still patient with her.. trying to get it out from her.. but she chose to hide.. that is bound to hurt him.. but he couldn't stay mad at her.. this rootna manana is a thing b/w couples.. isn't it?

@Manik's lie for the sacrifice track-that was way back! It isn't about you and me. It is Manik and Dhruv.. and their friendship was really important.. not saying what Manik did was right.. it wasn't ofcourse.. and that was a mistake but we shouldn't forget that they are kids.. even elders make mistakes.. and we all learn n grow that way..

But yes..I'd love to see Manik apologize to Nandini for leaving her for Dhruv! And that-in front of Fab5!

Quote

charminggenie

@charminggenie

Stunner

+ 2

Posted: 10 years ago

First Manik is assuming Nadini doesn't trust his version of Pandit which is not the case , since long she is looking for tangibles just lie him- Dhruv talk, Chachi prodding. Also even though she is bound because Pandit is Amms student, the girl hasn't bought his world tours, mentoring shit or Pandit as her "Guru" her facial reactions should be enough to validate that. Their interpretations differ , but Nandini doesn't consider Pandit "good" .

Second, they both have lied to each other in the past.

Here Nandini was sort of justified that she was in controlled environment and there was nothing to worry about . But problem is Manik is himself hiding Nyo's intentions from her which I am sure will out soon ,to balance the lies and hiding.

Edited by charminggenie - 10 years ago

Quote

LIKEDMG

@LIKEDMG

Sparkler

Posted: 10 years ago

I think it is totally justified as Manik's anger...bcoz He knows how innocent Nandini is...He can feel the intension of Pandit...But Nandini's whole world around only Manik ..as protective...It is very natural to be angry of her lie... Manik is worrying about her ...in this case small lie cud be dangerous rt?

Quote

Aarti

@__Aarti__

Dazzler

+ 2

Posted: 10 years ago

Manik was right today...nandini shouldn't have lied about pandit...bcoz this guy is dangerous ...more dangerous than soha...so obviously manik is being extra cautious about nandu

And he also said that " Hume bas ek he cheez alag kar sakti hai aur wo hai jhoot "
This tym the situation is quite serious ...and they can land in a very big trouble ...sooo they ,specifically manik have to be extra careful this tym bcoz nandu is still not aware about pandit's true intention...she is still in a dilemma

Quote

@-HJ-

Rocker

Posted: 10 years ago

Originally posted by: chair1992
Wow I am glad that someone pointed that out
He wants to see her face when she comes to know about Pandit? She obviously won't be happy, she is suspecting that there is something fishy about Pandit but what can she do?

Has Manik thought that Nandini has only one goal and that is to do her very best at the concert and have Manik back. That girl can do literally anything for Manik despite thinking she comes second to him. She can't share her worries about Pandit because if she does what will Manik do? He will get angry and destroy Pandit.

Besides the principle also told her that he doesn't want any problems this time.

Nandini first cried at musicana and couldn't perform (not her fault)
Nandini was kidnapped by Soha and fab5 lost their deal (again not her fault)

Nandini is suffering the most here
Still she is fighting
Thats why I love her

I agree. I don't say that Manik isn't suffering at all but please if he can think of nandu once.
I seriously want her to leave Mumbai and let Manik come to her.

Thanks for the reply!

Quote

@-HJ-

Rocker

Posted: 10 years ago

#10

Originally posted by: __Aarti__
Manik was right today...nandini shouldn't have lied about pandit...bcoz this guy is dangerous ...more dangerous than soha...so obviously manik is being extra cautious about nandu

And he also said that " Hume bas ek he cheez alag kar sakti hai aur wo hai jhoot "
This tym the situation is quite serious ...and they can land in a very big trouble ...sooo they ,specifically manik have to be extra careful this tym bcoz nandu is still not aware about pandit's true intention...she is still in a dilemma

Sorry but I disagree. Soha was equally dangerous. She tried to kill her so how cone she was anything less than pandit?
Why always Manik acts impulsively?

Quote

1 2

Simply Shocked!

Related Topics

Explore Topics