Ammi kehdeejiye ki yeh jhoot hain

Suvika. thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 365 Thumbnail + 7
Posted: 10 years ago
#1

Today once again Harshad Sahir Chopda spoke a lot. He spoke non stop for 9 minutes 35 seconds. With his silence. Every second of his silence screamed with so many emotions that all I could do was just... try and not blink. Starting from his "Ammi aisa nahi hosakta haina" to the final blow from his ammi as she points her finger at him and says "kisi gair ke haathon kaise jaane deti.."

It started with disbelief mingled with fear. A war between hope and despair.

And every word out of her mouth was a weapon slashing at that hope.



Until that very hope lay dead at his feet. Leaving nothing but despair in his shattered heart.



This guy doesn't need words. Who needs dialogues when his eyes speak so eloquently. At the fag end.. with logic down the drain and story gone awry in every which way, he still makes us connect with the show and SAC. šŸ‘ šŸ‘ šŸ‘


Edited by Suvika. - 10 years ago

Created

Last reply

Replies

10

Views

1.9k

Users

9

Likes

55

Frequent Posters

947708 thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#2
Harshad chopda is rockstar a small presence is enough for us he does the scene were he sets his mark today his broken voice modulation with tinne drop from his eyes and the dead expression was enough to convience the audience what sahir felt at that moment the motherly figure too betrayed him just for money and power used him and is going to throw him .
Wow such a selfish family good final he can move out with his love
Aazeen02 thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 10 years ago
#3
Hey Suja di!
You've made this forum your new home eh? šŸ˜‰
Bhai humse kaisi narazgi...
Kabhi-kabhi wahan bhi darshan de diya karein...
After all we the old members are still hovering over that archieved place... 😳
664269 thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#4
Undoubtedly, the best actor of indian tv, an alternative of Harshad Chopda will be very tough to find out..
prettypri thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#5
Very well said Suvi!
Thanks to Sony's exemplary programming I can only see the episode online as I don't have the HD channel!

Read about the episode before I saw it and when I did it was amazing!

What HC said about Sahir feeling multiple emotions at one time was so much in evidence today! In that scene with Alvira there was disbelief,shock,vulnerability,pain,a feeling of being lonely and betrayed...all without one word! He was simply superb! Especially when Alvira referred to him as "gair" that expression was heartbreaking 😭.

Only he can hold us captive and desperate to watch the episode even in such pathetic circumstances where the channel is treating the viewers with such scant regard!
Soaps1 thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Trailblazer Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 10 years ago
#6
Don't get me wrong but with illogical tracks, bad story telling the only one who brought show this far is Harshad as Sahir ... i don't want to take anyone away from the one who conceived the character or who wrote him ... but fact is they did go haywire so much so that almost turned him into a villain ... even in those days merely with his acting and showing mixed emotions was the only thing standing between SAC a grey shaded character and a villain ... Any other actor and the character was gone back then itself ... He kept it together ... he kept it going ... and even till the very end he keeps it going ... iss ko praise na karien tou kia karien?
Mujhe nahi pata why the PH messed a beautiful show, nor i know why channel treated it so bad ... I don't even know why every time an actor as good as him has to see his shows/characters meet a bad ending

But I do know one thing I am glad SAC happened ... because it took him as an actor to another level ... The actor Harshad Chopda even in all the mess that became of Humsafars, stands a winner! And I am so proud of that!

There can be no greater success for an actor than the fact that every character he played till date people watching it thought it can't get any better than this ... till he came back with another and took his acting to a whole new level ... again we are left thinking what can be better than this ... Well we have to wait and watch am pretty sure there is a lot lot lot more yet to come from the acting bag of Harshad Chopda Insha Allah


aardhan thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 180 Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 10 years ago
#7
Suvi, he stood there like a statue but his eyes spoke a thousand words. And without ever opening his mouth he made me stare at him as if I was mesmerized! It was a power packed performance.😳 šŸ‘

All I can say is he continues to surprise me everyday with something new... and not for a moment did I think the show was about to end! What a stellar performance even at the fag end! šŸ‘

And those last few minutes held me spell bound. Alvira was talking but Sahir's eyes were reflecting her words. And his one 'Ammi' at the start.. the break in his voice, as if doubting if he could even consider her that anymore, did he have the right to call her that anymore?

When he saw the will everything fell into place in his head... he is a sharp man, he catches on quickly. šŸ‘šŸ¼ He looks up from the file, looks at Arzoo as if knowing how the encounter is going to end... and yet when he questions Alvira, there is still that sliver of hope that the Will was wrong He so wanted it to be wrong... he so wanted Alvira to tell him she was not ruled by that Will... to tell him all the love and support she had showered over the years was not dictated by that Will! Yet, when he heard that yes from her... he know it was all over! He had nothing to say, except stand there and bear the brunt of all the wounds that Alvira was inflicting... the 'Gair' was the deepest cut of all! His look at that instant said... 'Eu tu Brute!'

Disbelief, realization, and primarily hurt in those eyes... in the end just a fatal acceptance when the truth sinks in that indeed he was no one, the last vestige f hope was shattered at that point! The false sense of belonging that he had been ensconced in was brutally snatched away leaving him exposed and vulnerable again. I hope we get to see his reaction tomorrow in the private confines of his room... am sure Arzoo will be with him there. 😃 For once, I'm glad he followed his heart and snatched Arzoo for himself... probably the only selfish act he has done in his life! But thank God for that!

And one could also see the mask fall on his face again... Sahir opened and closed his mouth in sheer disbelief when he heard the word 'gair' and the next moment the shutters fell in place... he suddenly realized that he was not going to show any more emotion in front of all these people who don't care, never cared for him! The desperate hope he had clung to when he came to question Alvira was well and truly banished at that point.
Edited by aardhan - 10 years ago
Ecrivain thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 10 years ago
#8


Hey suvi ...

Yep tht was a well done scene ..the intensity was there n also the Acting was bang on 😳

HC was great as always and the show would have been nothing had the guy not been there ..period

He emotes like anything šŸ‘

Btw he has been nominated for some award from paki ppl 😳
Suvika. thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 365 Thumbnail + 7
Posted: 10 years ago
#9

Originally posted by: prettypri

Very well said Suvi!

Thanks to Sony's exemplary programming I can only see the episode online as I don't have the HD channel!

Me neither . I read Rockstar's summary first through phone and then went online to watch. šŸ˜†

Read about the episode before I saw it and when I did it was amazing!

What HC said about Sahir feeling multiple emotions at one time was so much in evidence today! In that scene with Alvira there was disbelief,shock,vulnerability,pain,a feeling of being lonely and betrayed...all without one word! He was simply superb! Especially when Alvira referred to him as "gair" that expression was heartbreaking 😭.

Only he can hold us captive and desperate to watch the episode even in such pathetic circumstances where the channel is treating the viewers with such scant regard!

Sony is just...so... 😔 🤬

Suvika. thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 365 Thumbnail + 7
Posted: 10 years ago
#10

Originally posted by: aardhan

Suvi, he stood there like a statue but his eyes spoke a thousand words. And without ever opening his mouth he made me stare at him as if I was mesmerized! It was a power packed performance.😳 šŸ‘


All I can say is he continues to surprise me everyday with something new... and not for a moment did I think the show was about to end! What a stellar performance even at the fag end! šŸ‘

And those last few minutes held me spell bound. Alvira was talking but Sahir's eyes were reflecting her words. And his one 'Ammi' at the start.. the break in his voice, as if doubting if he could even consider her that anymore, did he have the right to call her that anymore?

When he saw the will everything fell into place in his head... he is a sharp man, he catches on quickly. šŸ‘šŸ¼ He looks up from the file, looks at Arzoo as if knowing how the encounter is going to end... and yet when he questions Alvira, there is still that sliver of hope that the Will was wrong He so wanted it to be wrong... he so wanted Alvira to tell him she was not ruled by that Will... to tell him all the love and support she had showered over the years was not dictated by that Will! Yet, when he heard that yes from her... he know it was all over! He had nothing to say, except stand there and bear the brunt of all the wounds that Alvira was inflicting... the 'Gair' was the deepest cut of all! His look at that instant said... 'Eu tu Brute!'

Disbelief, realization, and primarily hurt in those eyes... in the end just a fatal acceptance when the truth sinks in that indeed he was no one, the last vestige f hope was shattered at that point! The false sense of belonging that he had been ensconced in was brutally snatched away leaving him exposed and vulnerable again. I hope we get to see his reaction tomorrow in the private confines of his room... am sure Arzoo will be with him there. 😃 For once, I'm glad he followed his heart and snatched Arzoo for himself... probably the only selfish act he has done in his life! But thank God for that!

And one could also see the mask fall on his face again... Sahir opened and closed his mouth in sheer disbelief when he heard the word 'gair' and the next moment the shutters fell in place... he suddenly realized that he was not going to show any more emotion in front of all these people who don't care, never cared for him! The desperate hope he had clung to when he came to question Alvira was well and truly banished at that point.


@bold... yes. I don't think he is going to show what those words did to him now. At least not in front of everyone. I hope he shows it in front of Arzoo at least. I accept that romance can't be shown at this point. I don't think even the actors could emote the lovey-dovey stuff in the last episode but I wish to see him reveal his pain to his Humsafar.

And I see you are still online. Have you decided not to go to work tomorrow?? šŸ˜†

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".