emon = overrated and too publicized? - Page 3

"I agree that Emon can play guitar, keyboard etc.. But somehow it just doesnt fit when we call him the next IDOL! Please!! he is still a kid in the way he behaves. A true IDOL needs to be setting a good example of a proper matured singer/individual."

Amitftw, I agree with your above statement.

May be Sony wants to see more of him...and the way he keeps coming in the bottom zone everytime....it's really scary!!
Imagine II3 without Emon....he needs to stay!!

he deserves all d hype nd stuff....cuz hez d best singer ova there along wit amit.... 😃 😳

Emon does get a lot of attention but that is because he always does something funny or charming when the camera is on him. I think Emon would make a good Indian Idol as he will be an inspiration to the 17/18 year olds that with hard work anything is achievable. I never knew maturity was a prerequisite to becoming Indian Idol. Just because he cries when contestants are out does not make him immature. He is one of the most talented contestants out there. The day Emon goes out, the show will lose its charm. Same goes for Amit and Puja. We will lose a good voice.

Let's stop the character bashing posts like overconfident, proud, etc and focus on singing.

I WANT TO SEEEMON AS AN INDIAN IDOL 3

i dont think he's over rated. he deserves all that promotion. i would rather watch him for 30 minutes than watch chang or prashant for even 7 minutes.

no what i mean is by the judges or mini not by the camera man...like theres always some msg for him or someone comes on the stage to kiss only him..that sorta stuff

Originally posted by: Maya_M

Emon is aptly rated. I just finished watching rubaroo and he was the only one who sang in perfect sur and taal. I am glad at least he is given screen presence. I don't want to hear irritating noises in the name of singing.

Completly agree!!!!!!!!!!!! infact i don find the judges prasing 4m their heart especially 4 emon nd it also happened in last yr II....where karunya was not credited 4 his tremendous singing abilities!!!

Originally posted by: amitftw

.. But somehow it just doesnt fit when we call him the next IDOL! Please!! he is still a kid in the way he behaves. A true IDOL needs to be setting a good example of a proper matured singer/individual.

I'm sure the whole forum is gonna be after me for stating my honest opinion.

but Indian Idol did not mention tht.........II only wants a excellent singer nd performence(which am not bothered abt)....no matter whether hes 16 or 25