Replacing Anu Malik

After hearing Anu Malik's views today, I seriously feel he should be replaced. I think the only people who could take his place is Vishal -Shekhar or Shankar Mahadevan. I think these people would do a better job of judging. Vishal performs in a rock band and so I think he has a better idea of stage presence and performance compared to Anu Malik. Moreover, their views are unbiased, they give the right advice, don't judge based on looks and actually keep up to their promises of giving the contestants a break. I hope if we do have an Indian Idol 4, VS are taken instead of the great Anu Malik.

I agree with u. I think for Indian idol-4 Judges should be

OPtion 1:
Shankar Mahadevan
Sonu NIgam
KAvita Krishnamurty/Sunidhi Chauhan

OPtion 2
Vishal-Shekhar
Sonu Nigam
Sunidhi Chauhan/KAvita Krishnamurty

OPtion 3
A.R. Rehman
Sonu Nigam
Sunidhi Chauhan/KAvita Krishnamurty

Don't take it to heart people..i am just telling the truth here.
I am not a big fan of Anu Malik..he is the biggest chor in bollywood..everybody knows this fact. But when said good looks..I did not find anything wrong in that..All you peopl e need to check truth..If that should not have been criteria..Smita would have been Indian Idol as her voice was the most trained and even other contestants respected her. I know she did not sing well..but she could have sung much better than any other contestant remaining now. And also why Chang is getting votes...Girls need to blame themselves ..why they do vote for Chang..just because he look cute..(Please leave his Chinese agenda...he is 100% indian and a gem of heart person). In all 7 contestant was there any one who was not good looking..then Anu Malik was not wrong in his saying..I will say tell me one person..who was not good looking in all three indian idol finals..(Don't go for the person who hate because he was not good singer..ask your heart).

His time is up now.... he is just soooo biased...

If he is looking for looks...then its better to go n judge a beauty pageant...

He seriously looks like he is on the cheapest drugs available to man

What is wrong with him -- he is soo annoying..even if its an act..its bloody irritating

pls never bring Alisha back on the show and Udit...they may rock their jobs..but seriously...sticking to their day jobs is best for em.

i agree with yogsma.....ME neither not a great fan of Anu Malik....but feel that whatever he says is right. When anu said Emon has over confidence he was absolutely right....Emon is what he is now after that comment. Emon was sensible enough to take the comment in a creative form.

He speaks the truth maybe in a arrogant or agrresive way......he is quite egoistic.....but people count his judgement and know he is right.......

whereas alisha and udit are hopeless for this job and they should never take up this job again.

Anu malik is way better than alisha and udit!!
Give me a break guys u need a breather!!

you know tvfan you should replace Anu because you are so intelligent 😉