Rudra the BIG confusion in MK: should we only criticize or interfere t

RANOU thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#1
Rudra the BIG confusion in MK: should we only criticize or interfere to change the character?

Among many people i also don't like too much this aggressive character of Rudra, but I accepted it as something new at our TV. Sincerly, who tells us that in aaall this world, there is not really such people with an aggressive character like rudra, we saw it with Aamir khan in Ghajini like mentally troubled so that can exist. (knowing that Aamir had a very good critical response for this caracter)

I should also say that I read in an article that GR mentioned, with Full term, that his character is like "an animal" when he is angry http://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/tv/news/hindi/Gautam-Rode-I-will-never-leave-one-show-to-go-to-another/articleshow/45855467.cms

I don't think arvind Babbal or GR or utkarsh missed this character, but certainly they want it like this, and they dont talk a lot about it, and they don't explain to the public "why he's like this" to let him Mysterious. But is the audience will understand and accept it?! i doubt!

We have not yet reached that level of thinking in Indian TV, we only follows the gentle hero, saas bahu or love stories that entertain, and to reach this level I think we still need years.
The big problem now is that GR or Arvind Babbal should talk about it, to at least explain that the character is like this, "we want it or not it is designed that way" and should told us why they want him like this, so we "viewers" can understand the reason of this complex.

Sometimes I giggled when i heard others saying that the actor shouldn't exaggerate and must control his overacting or the director is OUT. The question is: Who are themselves to find out how this character is?! and how far this aggression must be expressed?!! they are the director, or writer or creator?!!
For sure if the director sees the actor making an "overacting" he will tell him to repeat the scene. The making-of goes through several stages, and after the director, there is creation and production team, to be finally an episode we can watch on TV with what they want it to be.

Everything that comes into my mind on hearing these comments is the fact to laugh deeply from my heart, as if they were the ones who hold the keys of this character, and the director/writer and creation are children just playing to give us a cartoon.
I dont say not to criticize, far from this, We can always criticize everything in their work it's on no account perfect, but we never can tell them why you create such a character or to suspect anything like for exemple they missed the character, coz logically, they are people who know what they want, "we like or no this character" he will be there like this and with intent.
The mistake MK Team do in my view, is that they don't explain why "OTT Rudra?" (especially when they know it is necessary for our category of viewers, coz we are not able to understand randomly and easily beyond things, we need explanation and it is not our mistake, we are not used with our TV shows made before).

We have to admit, It is not an ordinary story, it's not an entertainment, and they want a message with it. We can always criticize but never doubt what they want to show us! All their team say "you accept you follow, if no, you can not follow, it's your choice" that's why it's not about TRP i guess. They know this is an experience to raise the level of TV and wait for public response, but anyhow at bottom, they want it to work of course, coz it would be a recognition for their effort, this is why they are happy every week with the show first in TRPs.

And since we are used to the entertaining shows and many of us still not able to think with logic in our analysis of things, And since this is a first experience, And since the team want it to work too, all I request and hope, and guess many of us, is that GR and Arvind babbal speak a little about the caracter of rudra to the media and they explain things to the viewers if they want people to follow and receive their message, there is few very few interviews and it will not help the show if they still like this, coz otherwise, except the few ones who use their brains to see beyond things, other people are not going to make effort and accept it and none will follow it after!

I already wonder how GR behaves with people who tell him that stuff, and when he reads such comments, he know for sure that people find him strange, surprising/ or overacting like they say, i'am sure! is that does nothing to him?!! is he and Arvind keep their disappointment for them?!! i don't know really!! It's true that he expected this, while saying a few months before this role is difficult, complex and can not be accepted from a lot of people, but I really don't want to be in his place now! Hope for the best to all their team coz they work hard and whatever it is, their motive is for "Good".
It's for you also to see what you think about.
Edited by RANOU - 10 years ago

Created

Last reply

Replies

3

Views

523

Users

3

Likes

8

Frequent Posters

Gul.S_Ef thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#2

Very well said, this is no ordinary show, n audience will take time accepting n relating to Rudra's character.

The biggest problem is the 180* change frm the actor's old character,many r finding it hard to accept him (at times call him OTT) in this avtar because of that,as he played the last one to perfection.

But all the more reason to appreciate the actor that he's working so hard,enacting Rudra.This show at times get a lil difficult for me too 😳, but patience n complete attention is wt needed to appreciate Arvind babbal's brain child. 😊

Happy watching everyone. 😃
happychappy thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#3

Originally posted by: Gul.S_Ef


Very well said, this is no ordinary show, n audience will take time accepting n relating to Rudra's character.

The biggest problem is the 180* change frm the actor's old character,many r finding it hard to accept him (at times call him OTT) in this avtar because of that,as he played the last one to perfection.

But all the more reason to appreciate the actor that he's working so hard,enacting Rudra.This show at times get a lil difficult for me too 😳, but patience n complete attention is wt needed to appreciate Arvind babbal's brain child. 😊

Happy watching everyone. 😃



Gul, such a thoughtful comment. I think you speak for many of us.👍🏼
Gul.S_Ef thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#4

Originally posted by: happychappy



Gul, such a thoughtful comment. I think you speak for many of us.👍🏼


awww thanku 😳 u know naa how emotional i get whn its abt G 😉

U're appreciaton means alot 😃

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".