Tanveer committed a big sin by calling doctors to her bedroom

OriginalJuhi_04 thumbnail
Visit Streak 750 Thumbnail Visit Streak 500 Thumbnail + 9
Posted: 10 years ago
#1
Its high time people especially Muslims sud file a case against Gul. She is going beyond disgust by showing Tanveer calling 3 male doctors to her her bedroom to operate her dat also in disguise. If I am not wrong, in Mslim religion a woman cannot call strangers in her bedroom n shut d door. But here Tanveer called 3 male doctors in d disuise of maulvis which is disgusting. If she wanted to get operated in her room then she wud have informed d members of her family n 1 person of her family sud be there inside d room. Tanveer committed a big sin by calling male doctors in her bedroom. Wat if these doctors attempted to molest or rape her wen she was unconscious? If Tanveer really wanted to get operated then she sud have done it in d hospital by lying to d family n takn khalu-khalu or 1 of them wid her. Not only in Muslim religion but in any religion, a woman will not call male doctors to her bedroom widout informing any family members. Gul is ruining her own religion. Dis is d limit. How can anyone even allow those maulvis to meet Tanver(an alone woman) inside her room even allowing her to lock d door? R all d family members nuts? Can't they think of Tanveer's safety. I have of women aged above 70, 80 or 90 getn raped. And Tanveer is only 41-42 as she is younger than Zoya. Gul is very disgusting to show a woman calling male doctors in her bedroom🤢.

Created

Last reply

Replies

18

Views

2.8k

Users

11

Likes

44

Frequent Posters

SurbhikiPankhi thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#2
The reason she called the maulvis to her bedroom was for medical help. And I doubt even Tanveer can be denied that. Muslim women, also get operations y'know? In operation theaters. Isn't that a room with closed doors too? 😲 With Male doctors? 😲 Shocker.
Also she was older than Zoya. She was 24, when Zoya was 22.
Az07 thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 10 years ago
#3

Originally posted by: SurbhikiPankhi

The reason she called the maulvis to her bedroom was for medical help. And I doubt even Tanveer can be denied that. Muslim women, also get operations y'know? In operation theaters. Isn't that a room with closed doors too? 😲 With Male doctors? 😲 Shocker.

Also she was older than Zoya. She was 24, when Zoya was 22.


I am a doctor dear. In our ethics always a female patients when being treated by a male doctor always one female should be present with him. That can be the patients relative, a female doctor, a nurse or a female attender. It's mostly preferred to be from patients side. In Islam I don't know about this rule. But according to medical ethics a female patient can't be attended without another female persons presence. In operation theather also there will female nurses & attenders. Never male doctors alone. Atleast in India that's the rule. Also she can't get eye operation in her bedroom. It's a major operation which should be done only in operation theather under monitoring the vitals. If vitals are not monitored & if vitals go error even death too can happen. Also b4 the operation patient should be admitted in hospital for complete routine checkup & all her routines should be normal then only she can be operated. B4 operation she should be given anesthesia. After operation she will be blindfolded for next one week completely. Not like in show where tanveer roams with out her eye bandage. The patient will be discharged only after a week of operation after opening her bandage & after that there will be a final checkup for the eyes to make sure that her eyes is perfectly normal.
Yes I agree case should be filed against the cvs & gul for showing these kind of medical things like a blunder. Also Muslims should have filed a case against them 1 1/2 yrs back when they showed the famous zoyaan accidental nikkah mocking the rituals & ceremonies of nikkah.
Chahat_A_Doshi thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 180 Thumbnail + 7
Posted: 10 years ago
#4

Jo bhi ho based on medical grounds or based on religion the makers are protected y the creative liberty provided

Haan one could complain to the broadcasting regulators

BCCCI.com or something like that

SurbhikiPankhi thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#5

Originally posted by: Az07


I am a doctor dear. In our ethics always a female patients when being treated by a male doctor always one female should be present with him. That can be the patients relative, a female doctor, a nurse or a female attender. It's mostly preferred to be from patients side. In Islam I don't know about this rule. But according to medical ethics a female patient can't be attended without another female persons presence. In operation theather also there will female nurses & attenders. Never male doctors alone. Atleast in India that's the rule. Also she can't get eye operation in her bedroom. It's a major operation which should be done only in operation theather under monitoring the vitals. If vitals are not monitored & if vitals go error even death too can happen. Also b4 the operation patient should be admitted in hospital for complete routine checkup & all her routines should be normal then only she can be operated. B4 operation she should be given anesthesia. After operation she will be blindfolded for next one week completely. Not like in show where tanveer roams with out her eye bandage. The patient will be discharged only after a week of operation after opening her bandage & after that there will be a final checkup for the eyes to make sure that her eyes is perfectly normal.
Yes I agree case should be filed against the cvs & gul for showing these kind of medical things like a blunder. Also Muslims should have filed a case against them 1 1/2 yrs back when they showed the famous zoyaan accidental nikkah mocking the rituals & ceremonies of nikkah.

Agree with everything you said, I was just mocking the post. Ofcourse, the nurse is always present and most of the time is a female too. The show is so illogical! I can't even get past that.
rabees011 thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#6
islam does permit women to be treated by male doctors when a female doctor is not available. There's no harm in doing that. A male doctor operated on my mom while she was having me. There's no need to sue anybody for that and it is not a sin. The only illogical scene was the in-house eye surgery and that is the only thing that should be criticized.
AGirlHasNoName thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#7
It's a fictional show, such things shouldn't really matter IMO. If they started following every rule and regulations of religion and such, they wouldn't be able to show much cuz they would be getting sued right and left.
I'm sure we've seen far worse things than this in other shows if not QH itself.

Again, this is all just my opinion.
Edited by Booteefool - 10 years ago
Raingoddess thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#8
Since when has Billi cared about committing sins? Lol I find her other crimes/sins far worse than this lol Actually I really don't see how this is a sin lol You have a point about the illogical surgery in her bedroom. Its silly, that I agree with lol I have no comments on the male doc things cuz I have no knowledge on the legal aspects nor do I really find an issue with that lol QH has shown so many illogical and incorrect things anyway. I have stopped counting lol I just enjoy it as entertainment. Its fiction and has a disclaimer and honestly I feel they don't care anyway. You can complain n they might air an apology but the scene has already been seen by everyone lol then they will repeat it here or in some other show lol thats how it rolls in the entertainment world lol
Edited by Raingoddess - 10 years ago
OriginalJuhi_04 thumbnail
Visit Streak 750 Thumbnail Visit Streak 500 Thumbnail + 9
Posted: 10 years ago
#9

Originally posted by: rabees011

islam does permit women to be treated by male doctors when a female doctor is not available. There's no harm in doing that. A male doctor operated on my mom while she was having me. There's no need to sue anybody for that and it is not a sin. The only illogical scene was the in-house eye surgery and that is the only thing that should be criticized.


Doctors ho ya na ho but nurses hona chahiye. U may be 4m India but in Muslim countries, d women r jail, whipped n stoned to death as they r accused of spending time wid unrelated men. Its good for u. R u 4m India? Dats wat I was saying dat if Tanveer wanted to ave surgery then she wud have had it in d hospital. For rest, u can learn 4m above Uma's(Az07) comments on dis.
OriginalJuhi_04 thumbnail
Visit Streak 750 Thumbnail Visit Streak 500 Thumbnail + 9
Posted: 10 years ago
#10

Originally posted by: Booteefool

It's a fictional show, such things shouldn't really matter IMO. If they started following every rule and regulations of religion and such, they wouldn't be able to show much cuz they would be getting sued right and left.
I'm sure we've seen far worse things than this in other shows if not QH itself.

Again, this is all just my opinion.


Gul is too much for showing illogical things. I read her another show article dat she ramp walked on coal bed while 2 men claiming to love her just watched widout helped. Wen she fell in a man's arm, they both said 'Qubool Hai' to each other n were declared married by d maulvi. Wat a marriage yaar?

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".