DOTW:Single Genre singers & their ratings

By now we have all come to a realization, maybe some of us are more or less willing to admit about some single genre singers

A single genre singer generally sings the songs of their genre very good, but when they go out, they generally are so good, that they are noticed as being not as nice a singer

no I am not talking about Mauli, I am talking about Mussarat

he is excellent in Sufi, but when he goes into other genre he is not as good, if you compare his performance from yesterday and today, you will see the difference.

The difference for single genre singers is the same, Mauli has the same difference

not about Mauli or Mussarat, how do you decide?

A singer who is excellent, absolutely mind blowing in one genre, but not at all good in others, do you still vote for that singer?

Amanat is supposed to be versatile, look at all the songs he has performed, do you feel he is?

Raja? rewind all his performances

or do you vote for a singer who is versatile, sings all genre's moderately well and does not suck in any, once in a while sings one out of the park?

or do you vote for a singer who blows you away in his/her genre?

are you honest with the same opinion no matter who that person is?

Originally posted by: *Jaya*

Great post Vineet and put very objectively... Yes, Mauli is a single genre singer and I dont like her a bit, but so are Musarrat and Raja... I am surprised that still we give a preferential treatment to these 2 as compared to Mauli... maybe because even in her genre, Mauli has not always done fantastic. I mean she made real bhurta of some Asha Tai songs..😆

There is another thing, I feel affects voting pattern.. if its a single genre singer and keeps repeating the same kind of songs week after week after week.. the audience may soon find it too repitative and would look for more fresh voice.. Agree this has not reflected with Raja thus far, but will soon happen! Musarrat will run into same issues if he listens too much into his guru on this topic!