gr8love thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#1

Hi all,

I just wanted to add a little bit o Sunshine n kudos for SSharad Malhotra, whose dynamic entry as the older MP has stirred up a lot of people...some in a happy n positive way and others in an overly critical n negative way.

So I decided to add my humble opinion to this boiling pot of happy or angry emotions!!!!

Let me begin by saying how amazing SSharad looks as MP. I totally love his look and styling and the mouchyyy is soo cute. Also love how he constantly twirls it...much in the Rajput style!!

It is evident that his preparation for this role is paying off as can be seen in the way he rode the white stallion- Chetak and the little snippet of his fencing skills we observed in the Maha episode.

I think the creative team did a fabulous job on his entry episode! It was pretty captivating and appealing. I agree in part that da running scene cud hv been shortened and a few parts totally eliminated...but most of the outdoor shoot of this scene whr he is actually running on sand is beautifully done! It is hard to run like a pro on sand when yr feet constantly sink in it. So I think SSharad did a great job making it look very realistic.

I knw that ppl have been saying that he has a chocolate boy' image. That is 100% true!! But that is only coz we have not seen him portraying a character other than that as yet. In BMTD and his (released) film FSWL he has played the role of a young man madly in love with his spouse or gf! So just coz we have not seen him play a more intense and larger than life role DOES NOT MEAN he cannot portray that successfully!! He is a versatile actor who is very dedicated to his profession. So we need to be a little patient and let him show another side of this emoting skills n his versatility. I knw that right now in the story he is only being shown as the nice, soft hearted, kind, caring and nurturing person, who respects his choti rani, his dad and bonds beautifully with his timid lil sis, who is very forgiving of Jagmaal's rude n nasty attitude towards himself. This is just one side of MP. But wen the time comes to show the warrior-like brave side of MP, I totally know SSharad will excel in that as well. He will amaze us with the transformation!!

When historians write about the great kings of our history, they mostly write about the big things in their life, the wars they fought, the victories they won, the wives they had and any socio-economical changes they made to their kingdoms. They usually do not give any details about the persona of these kings, their private lives, personal likes/dislikes, their interactions with their family or loved ones etc etc

But these famous kings were totally human and so would definitely have the softer, loving, caring, forgiving side to their characters too. So why do we only want to see MP as a warrior and as an aggressor! It is pleasant to see the softer side of him too.

Besides this show is not an exact enactment of MP's life. The creative team has to add a lot of fiction to make it a story, to make it viewable and appealing they have to add a lot of romance, drama, intrigue and comedy to it. Or else ppl will not watch it at all.

Also I know that each actor takes some time to connect with their audience. And this becomes even more difficult when the previous actor is well established and has a huge fan following. But with a little patience and time I knw SSharad will win over these fans. He has sooo much to offer to this serial and he and Rachana will create a lovely memorable chemistry between MP n Ajab and take the leap to the next higher level!!

The links below actually give another side of MP's greatness...in his personality there was bravery, greatness and extreme love for his motherland. But there was also a sense of honesty, justice, love and respect for his family and people!! He really was one of the GREATEST IN HISTORY...in all areas!

http://www.chittorgarh.com/maharana-pratap.asp

http://indiaopines.com/5-lesser-facts-maharana-pratap/


Jus my 2 cents 😊😊... n sorry for the long post! 😛

Edited by gr8love - 11 years ago

Created

Last reply

Replies

33

Views

4.1k

Users

19

Likes

94

Frequent Posters

AroraTanya thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#2
He needs to have lots of improvement in expressions, body language, voice modulation, vocal strength and speech delivery.
.LovelyDreamer. thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 11 years ago
#3
nice post dear..
loved each and every word of urs..
pramilakarande thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#4
I agree with u...I know he needs to ve lots of improvement BT I ll give him some time to iimprove himself...
Danseuse thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#5
Hi,
I agree that we need to give sSharad some more time. The character he has moved into is a lot different from what Faisal has portrayed so far. The older one was seen to be left w/out his Ranimaa and Ajabde. Traumatised and alone. He has become more soft spoken and the fire in his belly may reawaken in the coming episodes. Hopefully...since he is a warrior at heart. That's the magic of Maharana Pratap.
Regarding the leap, my view is that the Creatives could not hav continued with Ajabde as she is only 12 and looks even younger. The marriage justified it, as Pratap and Ajabde had a child marriage. So a 15yr old and a 13 yr old looked apt for the characters. But Ajabde playing a mother would hav been too much to ask for. The option perhaps would be to continue with Faisal (since he has grown taller and sturdier) but change the actress for Ajabde. Then what about the ensuing history where MP has to fight the Haldighati war and retreat to the jungles and the guerrilla warfares etc.??? That character would hav required another change. Faisal would hav to be replaced because no amount of make up can make him look like a 30+year old.
So, the best option was to show a leap of 7+ years where all are grown ups etc and take the story forward.
Tweaking history may become important esp if its 500 years old. Besides, child marriage is already shown. Now in todays times, you may not be able to indulge in child pregnancy!!!! The Censor Board may come with a big ban theory...:)
Faisal and Roshni hav a long way to go. They hav done their parts well and am sure will be flooded with offers as time flies.
Lets look ahead positively and wish the new team of MRP best of luck!
-Rekha
sweta2005 thumbnail
Visit Streak 1000 Thumbnail 19th Anniversary Thumbnail + 8
Posted: 11 years ago
#6
No one said dat dey should show younger praja with kid its da fake love hate story dey r showing is all against the essence of praja relation was dere support to each other der understanmding and not dis separation of 7-10 years which was not needed which i thik cvs did to kill of ajab's character during her pregnancy which is also ditiorating history
Pooja2311 thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#7
CVs have already made a mockery of history and story line. It's no longer a period drama. SSharad needs to improve a lot but it's not magic that you can achieve it in days or even months. It takes years to hone one's acting skills.
Edited by Pooja_Chavan - 11 years ago
642126 thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#8
Historians do write about humane qualities too.
Maharana Pratap was a tall, broad built man more than 6 feet tall. Not like Ssharad who has a puny frame.

Ssharad does not look like a typical Rajput.

I don't think we need to supply links on how men looked back then.

Rana ji was a stoic man and fiery even at home. He opened up only to 3 people, his parents and Ajabde. But emotional expression used to be restricted back then.

Fancy flying scenes cannot make up for persona.

Sorry to say Ssharad does not even have clear voice and correct pronunciation.

Not only image from past show, he just looks like a choco boy only.

Anyway history is butchered in story. What is left to talk?


_GurIkaholic_ thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#9
Oh not again ! Ssharad simply doesn't posses the aura , the dynamic of Maharana Pratap instead with his chocolately personality annihilating MP show .He is a royal misfit for a playing MP and always will be because there is nothing he can improve like his height , his voice , an exaggerated or exhilarated sense of power and strength in his eyes and Machismo !!
He is a big let down as MP .
gr8love thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#10
The fact of the matter is that the PH auditioned and chose him to play the role of MP!
We cannot get away from tht fact...however much you may criticize him or the PH for choosing him.
We think he is doing a great job so far and we will continue to support n encourage him.
Every actor brings a lil of himself n his perception of the role. In the 3 episodes so far he has already shown some awesome emotions...ranging from anger, to respect, to love mixed wid hate, to bravado, to a caring n forgiving older brother.
Faisal did a remarkable job @ being the younger MP. But now its time to move on and allow SSharad to put his stamp on this role. For those of you who say he cannot act or emote or does not have da body language...to these criticisms I want to say that yes he is not trying to copy Faisal...he is doing it his way...so far the acting style for MP was set by Faisal...but now with da change of actor we need to allow SSharad to act the way he perceives and understands the role...which prolly will be very different from Faisal's style, Comparing actors does not ever help...each person has their own perceptions n skills that they bring to the role. We da viewers just need to accept the change and allow the new actor to connect with us, For Faisal fans this connect will be hard as they can only connect wid SSharad when they disconnect wid Faisal. And since that is an impossible thing to do...so I guess they will continue to dislike SSharad.
But I am positive that one day soon they will relent and accept the change and appreciate SSharad as MP!

Btw. I posted links abt some interesting facts abt MP...not abt how he looked!!

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".