Is Javed Akhtar a confused judge?? - Page 2

javedji is the best judge on the show. I do not agree with your analysis. His judgement in my opnion has been consistent with the performance for the day vs Alisha's blatant favoritism.

And btw...it is really mean of you to call two young girls 'mujra' girls just because you have soemthing against people dancing. I am sorry to say but your statement really speaks very little of them but more about your perception of these kids!

Javed Akhtar is the best judge on the program. He brings a credibility to the show.

Your interpretations of his judgements are skewed.

you have no right to call ankita or deepali
"mujra girls". please take that back. it is very rude of you to say that. and as far as javed saab is concerned, he criticizes people when they sing bad and appreciates when they sing well. it is not him who is inconsistant but the contestants.

Originally posted by: joshi23

1. He went after Suhit because of 'singing'. He never gave any marks to Suhit's performance appeal.

2. He favored Ankita over Padmanav in the wild card because as per him 'Ankita is a better performed' despite Padmanav being a better singer. In regards to Ankita, performance is important

3. He favored Smitha blindly despite the fact that Smitha didnt perform at all during the entire piano/gala rounds. In regards to Smitha' singing was important.

4. He has been favoring Deepali consistently despite the fact that Deepali went out of sur in songs like Lukka chupi.. whats the hidden agenda?

5. He is very fast to criticize Parleen and asks him NOT to perform and concentrate on singing.

6. He has never appreicated Prashant great voice and always gives a negative comment on him for some unnown reasons.

7. He is criticizing Emon for NO reason whatsoever since Gala #1. Is he pulling Emon's legs?

Basically he only favors the 2 'mujra' girls.. Ankita and Deepali.. REST he is confused about big time

What does Javed want??? If he continues to blindly favor PERFORMANCE over SINGING than I fear there will be no bharat ki shaan but rather 'Bharat ka naam dooba' II3.

First of all I would like to ask that why you always (or most of the time) creat controversial threads ???? 😕😕

In wild card, he chosed Ankita b/c she is an outstanding performer and a good singer as well, 😊whereas Paddmanav was only a singer and Suhit was only a performer and that performance too was just average (no offense to suhitians) 😳.. And by the way Javed sahab was not the only judge who select Ankita.. She was the common choice of all the four judges 😊

You should not have called Ankita or Deepali Mujra girls.. I am really very disappoint to hear that 😕😕.. they belong to respectable families just like you and this is just really very bad to call them Mujra girls😕😕

Initially u agreed that Javed sahab favours Smitha ..thats true but he did that whenever she has given good performance... not just blind support... and in the end you said that he basically support Ankita and deepali..I think you are more confused then him 😃

I agree 100%. Calling Ankita and Deepali Mujra girls is not acceptable. It shows your sanskar or the lack of it.

Please don't open threads to insult people, we really don't appreciate it.

Originally posted by: f_javaid

First of all I would like to ask that why you always (or most of the time) creat controversial threads ???? 😕😕

In wild card, he chosed Ankita b/c she is an outstanding performer and a good singer as well, 😊whereas Paddmanav was only a singer and Suhit was only a performer and that performance too was just average (no offense to suhitians) 😳.. And by the way Javed sahab was not the only judge who select Ankita.. She was the common choice of all the four judges 😊

You should not have called Ankita or Deepali Mujra girls.. I am really very disappoint to hear that 😕😕.. they belong to respectable families just like you and this is just really very bad to call them Mujra girls😕😕

Initially u agreed that Javed sahab favours Smitha ..thats true but he did that whenever she has given good performance... not just blind support... and in the end you said that he basically support Ankita and deepali..I think you are more confused then him 😃

Yeah i agree with you!! He shouldnt have called deepali and ankita mujra girls. 😕 Thats very rude!!

i didnt clarify myself.

I only meant that Ankita and dipaali are being forced to act as if they were performing a mujra and not participating in a SINGING CONTEST. Either way both are not as goos singers as eg Pooja or Smitha yet no judge appreciate Pooja or Smitha as much as Ankita/deepali.

My wording was not clear, so sorry..

Each member has the right to criticise contestants/judges, but insults towards anyone will nt be tolerated.

do not open topics just for the sake of controversy, open thread if you really want a healthy discussion.

such posts only hurt members feelings.

if repeated,you will be warned.

topic closed.