JA Oct6 2014 Does NR Give License to Murder History: DT NT Pg4

RadhikaS0 thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 10 years ago
#1
Friends,

Today I officially give up any hope for JA. Till today's episode, I kept my hopes alive that despite all forms of NR and all means to milk the TRPs, EK would not actually play around with history. But today, she proved me wrong, totally wrong! Today she proved that to a business house, all that matters at the end of the day is PROFIT and neither history nor viewer sentiments hold any value.

What a mockery of viewers' emotions and sentiments! When the whole world knows that Hussein died first, how can the CVs show the opposite? 😡

Just so that they can drag this track on and on?

Just so that they can show Jodha crying over the fact that despite giving birth to twins, today she is bereft of both - having given one away and lost the other?

Just so that the CVs can show Ruq gloating that her son is now the waaris and she the future MUZ?

Just so that the CVs can show Zeenat gloating that she was able to kill the waaris so easily despite JJ's constant attendance on him?


More than anything else, the track seems designed to GLORIFY Ruq to the extent that Ekta wants to make her the MUZ, at least temporarily. 🤢 If Ekta has her way, most likely Hussein will never die and will go on to become the next emperor and RUq the next Queen Mother. Truly, this show is now ALL FICTION and nothing but FICTION. 🤢

On a smaller scale, Mahesh Das was shown to be a buffoon who didn't know one note from another. Sheer abysmal depths of NR - I was shaking at this mockery of a great artist, as till then I didn't know that worse was in store in the second half of the episode.

************************************************************************************
The Preamble

The episode opened with Jalal walking with Mahesh Das in the garden and asking the latter if he was nervous about the switchover in court that day. Mahesh Das, in his inimitable style, narrated a joke about a "great singer" who was requested by his patron king to sing the same song again and again. Apparently, the king used to ask for an encore because he could not understand the song, while the singer felt flattered by the repeated requests for an encore.

Jalal was pleased by Mahesh Das' ability to laugh in any situation.



The Switchover


More banter followed between Mahesh Das and Tansen, as they proceeded to the DEK for a special "mehfil" organized for the occasion. Interestingly, a sub-plot is running between Tansen and a "courtesan" (?) since the last episode. This courtesan helpfully shared the joke Mahesh Das had narrated to the king that morning with Tansen, who happily shared the same with the mehfil, much to Jalal's surprise and Mahesh Das' consternation.

When his turn came, Mahesh Das was reduced to a clown a la Mehmood in Padosan and made to do a ridiculous jig to a kind of rap song, which seemed to leave everyone in splits. If Ekta researched for 2 years, didn't she discover that Mahesh Das was a trained singer-musician and poet laureate who also wrote books?

Jalal was impressed by both. Specially as Tansen admitted that the joke was not his original one, while Mahesh Das had rendered an original song that had connected with the audience and could therefore be considered a form of music. And Mahesh Das admitted that singing was not his forte while it was most modest on the part of Tansen to joke about a singer.


Hasan is Sick


The atmosphere was suitably light when suddenly dark clouds gathered over. Hasan who was in Jodha's arms so far suddenly started to throw up. Ruqaiyya immediately shouted for the Hakima and Jalal was alerted.

The scene shifted to Jodha's hojra, where the Hakima was unable to detect the exact cause of constant vomiting by Hasan. Jodha was concerned, the entire royal family was watching with increasing worry, while Jalal was driven to an emotional rage at the Hakima for being unable to even diagnose the problem. He literally shouted at Man Singh to fetch a battery of hakims to check Hasan.

Ruqaiyya was equally worried in her hojra, as Hussein was being nursed by Zeenat. Hoshiyar informed Ruqaiyya with tears that Hasan's condition was slipping. Hearing this, Ruqaiyya rushed with Hussein in arms to Jodha's side. Zeenat was shown smirking that one child was about to die and soon both of Jalal's kids would be dead and her revenge complete.

Hasan Flings His Life Away

Paridhi was PERFECT as Jodha today. As the mother who is swaying between hope and despair at her son slipping away in front of her eyes, while Hindustan's Shahenshah and his team of hakims could do nothing, except watch helplessly.

She did everything that struck her mind in that darkest of hour. She prayed to her lifeline, her Kanha. As the hakima announced that the breathing was slowing down, she rushed to Jalal's side and pleaded with him to save her son. She took the child in her arms and tried to talk to him. Briefly it registered in her fuzzy mind that something had happened. Jalal tried to inform her but she refused to let him speak the words, as if afraid that if said, the words might turn true. Then slowly she went numb with shock and got cut off from reality.

Jodha carried the child to his jhoola and kept talking to him, asking everyone to be silent as her son could hear her and would soon reply to her. Hamida took the difficult step of breaking the news gently to Jodha that Hasan was no more. Jodha momentarily came to her senses and then passed out.

Jalal, who could take it no more, broke down himself.


Precap


Jodha slowly wakes up in her bed and sees the shroud-covered body of her Hasan laid out in front of her. A grief-stricken Jalal is trying hard to control his emotions in front of Jodha to lend her courage. It was such a poignant moment to see Jalal fighting his own emotions so that he could support and console his Jodha.

I so hope to see Jalal being the rock in Jodha's life this time round.


What Next


Will Jalal ask Ruq to give Hussein back to Jodha to bring her out of her grief? And will Ruq finally show her true colors by refusing to part with Hussein?

Even today, she was shown to be a wonderfully concerned woman who was the first to call the hakima, was worried stiff about Hasan and equally grieved by his passing away. Will she continue to be painted as the SAINT who could do no wrong? Will Ruq be glorified by the CVs till the end of the show, as an exceptionally noble woman?

If the CVs could turn things upside down today, they can show just about anything in future. 🤢

Will Zeenat get away with cold-blooded murder of two innocent babies, with none of the hakims suspecting any foul play?

Will we be left banging our heads in despair, as JJ keep getting buffetted by the strong winds of Fate, while the guilty laugh their way to glory?






Edited by RadhikaS0 - 10 years ago

Created

Last reply

Replies

66

Views

6.8k

Users

26

Likes

385

Frequent Posters

prav2 thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#2
Thanks for the post Radhika.You said it all.i was so hopeful that Hasan will be saved today but they did made a mockery of our sentiment.Right from fake preg track the overall tone of the tracks have completely changed and the villains are glorified so much and I don't understand this cvs undue interest on spreading negativity. In come some beautiful episodes but I'm really tired of hoping that for once justice will be timely delivered
Now I have no hopes.I see a similar glorification of ruq like maham.
If at all she is punished that episode will be full of her fear,anger,loss etc...
Coming to the episode I couldn't enjoy the DEK scene much.Tansen seems to be more graceful and I'm sad md is made to do this.But one thing stood out today is the exceptional performance of RT and PS .I couldn't still get over it.Even now I'm in numb disbelief that Hasan is dead .It was so real and heart wrenching.
Edited by prav2 - 10 years ago
sweet_diksha thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail Networker 2 Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#3
Good take , Radhika...

frankly i m not surprised with what they r showing... and abt murdering the history, then they have murdered it long back...so no use of questioning them now...

rather i ll say, thanks to them, that they have not shown salim as Akbar's first born baby, and all that stuff... they atleast showed a part of history abt twins being the first borns... rest, leave it to CVs...

and calm down... CVs will never give u real story... as they never claimed to show true history... thay have always said that it's NR based on historical backdrop... and NR can be anything...

so what's use of questioning them now??? Ekta and her dumbo team will never sudhrofy...👎🏼


Donjas thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#4
Nice analysis of one of the most tragic episodes of Jodha Akbar.
First the positives, superb acting by Paridhi and Rajat. They were the souls of Jodha Akbar today and aptly portrayed what the real historical pair must have gone through. A performances for the ages.

Now, coming to Birbal. I knew the moment he was introduced in this serial, that the role of Birbal will be comic relief with the occasional bouts of deep thinking. I sort of understand the logic, can't make Birbal showing his cleverness all around, it will undermine Akbar. And they need to give Birbal enough air time since he was so famous and the actor playing it so pricey, hence the humor. But still, today's scene could have been avoided.

I used to chuckle when a few days back I read someone write that there will be a leap because, they don't want show this or do that, as happened in history. I had said to myself, what nonsense, because I know that the CV's are not bound to history. They will twist facts and invent scenarios to show what they want and nobody is going to say anything. Today proved it. Who will protest that Hassan died first and not Hussain? I swallow all that "natkiya rupantar" because I know there are serials, one airing on SONY at present where almost nothing depicted has anything to do with history.

Besides, I console myself, even Abhay has admitted that foul play could be a possibility for the twin's death.

The purpose of all this is also obvious, make Jodha suffer, make Ruqaiya a de facto Marium Uz Zamani for a few days and shoving it down everyone's throats. After the torment and Ruqaiya patent smirks when the ratings again begin to slip, finish this track with another tragic death. That could take a couple of weeks. All depends on the ratings.


Edited by Donjas - 10 years ago
SindhuMenon thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#5
Thanks for the post Radhika. I have not watched the episode yet. I was totally shattered when I heard that Hassan died and decided to skip watching. WIll watch it later just for Paridhi and Rajat.

So now the Promo does look real and I have a feeling Ruks will give Hussein to JO for the meantime. Zeenat would have by then succeeded in poisoning Hussein and baby may die when he is being taken care of by Jodha. Here Ruks will get furious with Jodha and accuse her and at this time her real intentions comes out.

Will Zeenat be caught ever. Why do always villains win and they never get caught.at the right time.

ann2012 thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#6
I had mentally prepared myself for today's episode. One of the twins was supposed to die. And true to saas-bahu form, the innocent Jodha was the first to be afflicted with this tragedy just so Ruqaiya could irritate us for a few more days before even her twin takes it's last breath.

I still think this event in the serial isn't entirely NR as the babies might have been exchanged. I think i read in one of the written updates about Zeenat adminstering Ruqaiya's twin i.e. Hussain, a slow poison. If it really were a slow poison then if Jodha's twin i.e. Hasan, tasted it once then it wouldn't have had much effect. Also switching places has suddenly become a trend in the Agra palace. Is this indicative of something?

Added to this, we know JJ keep their promises, no matter how difficult. Would they really ask for Hussain to be given back? I don't think so. They must have discovered the switch and only then asked for Ruqaiya to give the twin back who is actually Jodha's Hasan. But up until he is returned to Jodha, Zeenat would have fed him ample amounts of the slow poison. Thus, even Hasan dies within few days.


Edited by ann2012 - 10 years ago
SindhuMenon thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#7

Originally posted by: ann2012

I had mentally prepared myself for today's episode. One of the twins was supposed to die. And true to saas-bahu form, the innocent Jodha was the first to be afflicted with this tragedy just so Ruqaiya could irritate us for a few more days before even her twin takes it's last breath.


I still think this event in the serial isn't entirely NR as the babies might have been exchanged. I think i read in one of the written updates about Zeenat adminstering Ruqaiya's twin i.e. Hussain, a slow poison. If it really were a slow poison then if Jodha's twin i.e. Hasan, tasted it once then it wouldn't have had much effect. Also switching places has suddenly become a trend in the Agra palace. Is this indicative of something?

Added to this, we know JJ keep their promises, no matter how difficult. Would they really ask for Hussain to be given back? I don't think so. They must have discovered the switch and only then asked for Ruqaiya to give the twin back who is actually Jodha's Hasan. But up until he is returned to Jodha, Zeenat would have fed him ample amounts of the slow poison. Thus, even Hasan dies within few days.




@bold: good point..
Charu.S thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#8
Excellent writeup Radhika .

I have not watched today's episode , nor do I have any intentions of watching it .

I saw the pictures that Susan had posted and that alone is enough for me to imagine Jodha and Jalal's state of mind . Just to think that in reality the royal couple were only in their early twenties when they had to tolerate the untimely death of the first born , makes me love their characters ten times more .
Thank you Creatives and Production team for distorting and butchering historical facts , in order to make way for 'natakiya roopantar'.
When my mom told me that it was Hassan who had died , I actually corrected her and told her that it was Hussein . After reading Maddy 's post , I was assured that mom was right . What was EK's idea behind distorting historical facts I wonder .
How are they planning to expose Rukaiyya ? Zeenat will definitely get caught and her husband punished, I've no doubts about that . It is Rukaiyya's decline and punishment that I am more interested in . The Creatives better not show Jalal forgiving her after Hussein's death , because the grief of losing both babies is more intense for him than Rukaiyya's treachery . If only this is done , I will completely stop watching Jodha Akbar for good .



Charu .
Edited by JAfanCharu - 10 years ago
surochitadutta thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#9
Radhika history??!!!!!! What history?????!!! Which history are you talking about!!!! History was dead long time ago!!!! This EK, Zee and their creative team are sick and disgusting people!!!!! They can do anything for money!!! Agar unka bas chale toh Salim ko Ruqaiyya ke kokh se phida kare...

There is a limit to Ruqaiyya glorification and they are crossing the limit... Before I had one percent hope that maybe Ruqaiyya will be caught and punished but today that 1% hope also died... To hell with Balaji Eakta Zee and their Natakiya Rupantar...


But seriously even though the story has gone haywire but the talents that drives the show is shining more brightly... Rajat and Paridhi were simply perfect... Their performance gave me goosebumps... More than the dialogue and the scene it was their acting which made me cry...


I Stand up and salute Rajat Tokas and Paridhi Sharma for this flawless acting...
bokul thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Master Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 10 years ago
#10
nice analysis dear
u did it so beautifully

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".