Cvs. We want the Ibrahimi Mansion story NOT Siddiqui Mansion story

SheAish thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#1

@simran_sing_24 I hope you don't mind that I borrowed your phrasing for my post. 😉

Dear Cvs,

I think the large majority of Q2 fans have been watching this season as a fresh story that had a background story from Q1 to provide a little bit extra flavor to this current story, grounded in Ibrahimi Mansion, revolving around Ahil and Sanam. No doubt both Q1 and Q2 has the same vamp. But I would hardly say that most of us are watching this show because we want to see Sj take AG down for what Tanveer did in Q1.

I feel this is where the Cvs are failing the audience mainly. Contrary to some beliefs postulated in the IF forum, TRP gain has been when the focus of the story was Ahil, Sahil and the happenings at the Ibrahimi Mansion. This is the reason why Q2 is still here for us to be even fighting this whole fan war about Sahil and Sahan and revenge drama vs. love story.

How many of us believe that Q2 ran a pretty tight ship with a tight story that was amazing and griping during the first 5 months????
I bet the large majority of us would agree that this was the best time period with regards to Q2 as in the romance and story both moved along together flawlessly.

So then what happened along the way.
IMO two tracks that were introduced soon after marriage dragged down the main story which is tied down with Sahil. (I'm going to leave RAHAFA because this does not directly affect Sahil)

1) Raziya was introduced and we all had pretty high hopes that the story was going to reach a peak soon enough and if not, would provide much drama to the Sahil story with regards to tanveer and her antics but alas it proved to be a dud even after 3 months since then.

2) Seher was introduced and I admit that I have always been highly skeptical about the twin track because I could see how much this was going to affect sahil story as Sj is going to be playing double role. I just did not see the need for the Cvs to go this road in order to provide more drama while the story has been going SO WELL.when the potential for messing up sahil was so high with this track.

When these two tracks opened Ahil's family completely disappeared and he has been relegated to provide a sprinkling of romance now and then. Except for a couple of times Raziya has not eaten into much of the screen time so it did not impact the main story much.
However Seher's story has got huge amount of screen space and for the last month or so has actually occupied the majority of the screen time with her going through a multitude of changes in her character itself from the badass OTT dram queen conwoman to damsel in distress falling in love to the tragic heartbreak all in the span 2 weeks in Q2 time.

With the introduction of the twin track the story seems to be shifting mainly towards revenge drama with the development of the story of the estranged twin seher during the last couple of months. While this has been going on, the main story (Sahil and Ahil) which brought the TRPs back has been put on hold while Seher's story could get developed and along with that the TRPs also seems to be going down.

During the last week it seemed that Cvs has learned their mistakes and is going to focus back on Ibrahimi mansion and the main story they started with in the first 5 months. However if the spoilers are to be believed sehers is going to be brought into the Ibrahimi mansion in order to take down Tanveer and I think this is again a huge mistake. Navab murder does not have anything to do with Seher and Sanam is no weakling that she needs Seher to deal with Tanveer now that she knows the real face of Tanveer behind the best mom facade. If she can stand up and actually have stood up (quite fabulously I must add) to Ahil Raza Ibrahim, she can stand up to Tanveer with one hand behind her back no doubt.

Cvs I know that you guys seem hell bent on this twin track, but atleast for now could you just give the lime light to Ahil, Sanam and Ibrahimi mansion happenings with the Nawab track and keep Seher away from Ibrahim mansion during this track. We definitely need Ahils estranged family atleast the Badi Ammi and the sisters for this track.

And in the mean time Seher can romance and break up with Rehan 101 times for all I care as long as the focus is given to the leads during the Navab murder track WITHOUT including Seher in the Ibrahimi Mansion.

Seriously at least give this much to us for the time being and later when you open asya murder you can bring in Seher and also Haya when Tanveer is taken down ultimately for good.

Edited by SheAish - 11 years ago

Created

Last reply

Replies

34

Views

3.2k

Users

12

Likes

150

Frequent Posters

KhatamKahani thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail Networker 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#2
I want to throw this question though. What was the reason for drop the week after Nikkah from 6.3 to 5.5? That was before Raziya, good amount of SaHil. It also had introduction of Faiz I believe in the middle of that week and was FF worthy. But... there was also disgusting phoophie in similar? amounts during the next 6.1-6.2 phase.
Seher actually did bring up ratings (or at least she and the promo both). But when she was tied to Sanam and Ibrahim mansion. It is SeHan not Seher which correlates with the decrease.

However I do agree that I would hope AG and SJ are exaggerating on Seher suddenly man handling and pushing Tanveer around. Too soon for that.

Maybe Seher decides to return the necklace (though how I don't know..i don't think she stole it back from the jeweller, she just stole money) in her attempt to right some wrongs and start a better life, and that 's how she ends up at the mansion. She doesn't know the lookalike Sanam is the one from the Nawabi family.


Edited by KhatamKahani - 11 years ago
--Sana-- thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 11 years ago
#3
Ok agree with you but but not completely
I also big fan of SaHil at the same time Qh1
nd AsYa fan too as a fan I want justice for asya brutual murders and now Aahil dad death also.I know last one month so much unnecessary tracks though CVS finally start to focus SaHil along with revenge drama thats why sanam start to investigate her hubby past she cant see Aahil pain so nawabs murder case reopen to find who is real murderer and other side seher entry Aahil mansion to investigate asya murder s n revenge agabilli so equally story move rightway.

Dont worry SaHil n Aahil screen space now story mainly shows Aahil mansion only so we chance to see SaHil,seher and tanzia
SabrinaMalik thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 11 years ago
#4
You cannot completely neglect QH-1 story.

QH-2 was born from QH-1.
SaHil were born from AsYa.
If there were no AsYa, SaHil wouldn't exist.

If there were no Siddiqui Mansion, Ibrahim Mansion wouldn't exist.

As a die-hard AsYa fan, I want to avenge their death.

Nawab's murder has nothing to do with Seher but AsYa's murder has got everything to do with both Sehar and Sanam.

Besides, QH is still doing good in the TRP charts.

Plus, the drama is starting NOW.
Ahil's past has come into limelight just recently, let's wait and watch what CVs have in store for us. :)

And, RAHAFA is something which is totally useless. CVs could do good if they cut them down.
Edited by SabrinaMalik - 11 years ago
--Sana-- thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 11 years ago
#5

Originally posted by: KhatamKahani

I want to throw this question though. What was the reason for drop the week after Nikkah from 6.3 to 5.5? That was before Raziya, good amount of SaHil. It also had introduction of Faiz I believe in the middle of that week and was FF worthy. But... there was also disgusting phoophie in similar? amounts during the next 6.1-6.2 phase.

Seher actually did bring up ratings (or at least she and the promo both). But when she was tied to Sanam and Ibrahim mansion. It is SeHan not Seher which correlates with the decrease.

However I do agree that I would hope AG and SJ are exaggerating on Seher suddenly man handling and pushing Tanveer around. Too soon for that.

Maybe Seher decides to return the necklace (though how I don't
know..i don't think she stole it back from the jeweller, she just stole money) in her attempt to right some wrongs and I. Hstart a better life, and that 's how she ends up at the mansion. She doesn't know the lookalike Sanam is the one from the Nawabi family.







Completely agree with you
Trp start to decrease when they show ff sehan love track and phuppi crap I hope CVS realise this
SheAish thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#6

Originally posted by: KhatamKahani

I want to throw this question though. What was the reason for drop the week after Nikkah from 6.3 to 5.5? That was before Raziya, good amount of SaHil. It also had introduction of Faiz I believe in the middle of that week and was FF worthy. But... there was also disgusting phoophie in similar? amounts during the next 6.1-6.2 phase.

Seher actually did bring up ratings (or at least she and the promo). But when she was tied to Sanam and Ibrahim mansion. It is SeHan not SeHer which correlates with the decrease.

However I do agree that I would hope AG and SJ are exaggerating on Seher suddenly man handling and pushing Tanveer around. Too soon for that.

Maybe Seher decides to return the necklace (though how I don't know..i don't think she stole it back from the jeweller, she just stole money) in her attempt to right some wrongs and start a better life, and that 's how she ends up at the mansion. She doesn't know the lookalike Sanam is the one from the Nawabi family.




Immediately after Nikkah they did scale down on Sahil and yes they started with the Faiz and Poopi track prettey soon which obviously did contribute to trp decrease. But it didn't keep on dragging down the TRPs and infact picked it up pretty quickly.

As for Seher, yes her introduction weeks did bring up TRPs but during these two weeks Sahil story was also moving forward once again specially with the accident due to which we got some lovely Ahil and Sahil moments.

As for Sehan it definetely is bringing down the TRPs no doubt.

But my concern with Seher helping out Sanam with navab murder track is that this would once again mean less screen space for Ahil and ofcourse Sahil because now time would be allotted to sisters bonding. And really Sanam is a strong enough character to deal with Tanveer with the navab truth and it would let Sanam and Ahil to shine a bit once again and give the current story more focus.

With the twins taking on Tanveer it would be once again Siddiqui mansion revisited since now they have, Dilshad, Raziya with asya's daughter taking down Tanveer, similar to Sj vs AG back then in Q1.
This is not what Q2 is about at least while navab truth is explored, Ahil and his family should be the focus instead of the twins bonding (which could be dealt with later) when Asya murder is reopened.
Just my POV

Edit: Seher did actually steal back the necklace from the jeweller. And you might be right that she does not come back to the mansion as they joked about in the interview.


Edited by SheAish - 11 years ago
micshy thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#7
I dont agree with u completly... I m a big big big SaHil fan ... N i love watching them period.. But i also know that they cant show SaHil all the time so they need other things too... P.s where it was started as a story of AsYa's daughters so it was bound to be a revenge drama from its inception... We all were actually tricked by the Great Ms Gul khan that its a love story... I totally agree with u that it gained its popularity n the ratings due to SaHil story..but that was because the writing was great.. They built up their story properly... But yeah they had to show other tracks as well .. And i would also disagree with u to some but ... There r many other ppl like me who have been following this show since its inception n they would like to see a logical revenge drama not only of Khan sisters but of Aahil as well... N Rehaan being the weakness of tanveer going against her ... Bringing her to a miserable state... They could have beautifully interwoven all these stories ... While keeping the romance alive..
Well i for once was never against Sehaan rather fully supported their love track but the way they rushed the love story i also think they could hv done without it.. It leaves a bad taste in the mouth...

So i wish they now atleast start showing consistency in tracks... N some logic too... At the end of the day audience r not that mad... But we all agree to one point that Aahil n SaHil should be given the due they deserve .. Aahil has been ignored much hope instead of wasting their money on bad actors n crappy tracks ... Tbey start focusing on the main characters n good editing n pacing... They still have a good story... N i hope they'll be back again IA
SheAish thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#8

Originally posted by: --Sana--

Ok agree with you but but not completely
I also big fan of SaHil at the same time Qh1
nd AsYa fan too as a fan I want justice for asya brutual murders and now Aahil dad death also.I know last one month so much unnecessary tracks though CVS finally start to focus SaHil along with revenge drama thats why sanam start to investigate her hubby past she cant see Aahil pain so nawabs murder case reopen to find who is real murderer and other side seher entry Aahil mansion to investigate asya murder s n revenge agabilli so equally story move rightway.

Dont worry SaHil n Aahil screen space now story mainly shows Aahil mansion only so we chance to see SaHil,seher and tanzia



Ok I am pretty sure that Seher entering Ibrahimi mansion means Sehan in Ibrahimi mansion and it would bring the two twin love stories that much closer. At least now this is happening far away from each other and I really feel that navab truth could be unfolded better without Sehan in the Ibrahimi mansion as well, so more of Ahil, Ahil's family and Sahil could be explored during this track.
KhatamKahani thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail Networker 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#9

Originally posted by: SheAish



Immediately after Nikkah they did scale down on Sahil and yes they started with the Faiz and Poopi track prettey soon which obviously did contribute to trp decrease. But it didn't keep on dragging down the TRPs and infact picked it up pretty quickly.

As for Seher, yes her introduction weeks did bring up TRPs but during these two weeks Sahil story was also moving forward once again specially with the accident due to which we got some lovely Ahil and Sahil moments.

As for Sehan it definetely is bringing down the TRPs no doubt.

But my concern with Seher helping out Sanam with navab murder track is that this would once again mean less screen space for Ahil and ofcourse Sahil because now time would be allotted to sisters bonding. And really Sanam is a strong enough character to deal with Tanveer with the navab truth and it would let Sanam and Ahil to shine a bit once again and give the current story more focus.

With the twins taking on Tanveer it would be once again Siddiqui mansion revisited since now they have, Dilshad, Raziya with asya's daughter taking down Tanveer, similar to Sj vs AG back then in Q1.
This is not what Q2 is about at least while navab truth is explored, Ahil and his family should be the focus instead of the twins bonding (which could be dealt with later) when Asya murder is reopened.
Just my POV




You are right that they scaled down. But there was still more SaHil focus compared to week of SeHer entry and probably for the whole period of 6.1-6.2, with the exceptions of a few episodes.

Phoophie didn't come in till after SeHer. And that's my point, Phoophie was sickening but till SeHan, Phoophie didn't affect ratings as deeply.

When you look at other weeks and how bad or annoying sidetracks didn't affect adversely, Faiz entry shouldn't have brought down ratings that much. Focus was still on Ibrahim Mansion and SaHil.

(I have a few reasons which may explain some of the fall, but they cannot be used as definitive.)
livelytanu thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 180 Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 11 years ago
#10
I agree with you partly. The TRPs started increasing when the CVs started to focus on SaHil only, not IM as a whole. A lot of characters disappeared during that time. But it made the show more interesting.
I guess the CVs are introducing Seher entering IM track to increase the drama quotient. To say the truth nothing is interesting in the show except for Sahil, story is stuck in the same place for months. The damage has already been done extremely. This is supposed to be a recovery method I guess.
For a show to work properly there has to be a good dose of everything. This was there during the SaHil marriage track which somehow got lost after the marriage track. Seher's entry & Ahil's accident track did stabilize it which again got lost after SeHaan & phoopie track. I guess the TRP viewers were satisfied with SaHil romance & drama. But the moment they introduced SeHaan & Rahafa cheap track the scale became unbalanced. It led to too much importance to romance, unworthy track & zero importance to drama not to forget SaHil were ignored royally for many episodes. The viewers, including me never understood the Rajdhani express romance & break up. 😆 What significance did it have on the story? Just like I keep on wondering what significance does Rahafa have in this show. Also I do agree Seher's character lost its sheen with the romance track. With this the twin drama gradually became a flop. I guess this Seher entering IM is to rectify the mistakes of Seher's character?
Also too much importance has been given to the villains. Even last week was full of Tanveer. And I completely agree Razia is a complete waste character just like Rahafa track.
Even I want to see more of Ahil, Sanam, SaHil & IM. But I guess Cvs have successfully managed to repel the viewers with poorly developed side tracks & characters Now some good drama is needed.
About the revenge drama, IDK whether they will bring TRPs o not. But I can say that like the new viewers of Q.H2, Although I watched whole of Q.H 1, I do feel disconnected, & disinterested it this track. I guess the CVs should end the the past track & move on with new tracks concerning Sahil, Ahil & Sanam.

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".