Mera Naseeb: An Analysis - Page 2

Created

Last reply

Replies

14

Views

2.2k

Users

5

Likes

33

Frequent Posters

Mahabhootni thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#11
The show is pretty regressive but I feel like even that is within the scope of the characters rather than regressive for the sake of being regressive or even worse, regressive faked as progressive. (An example is the abusive male leads all the girls are dying after or the agni pariksha modern, educated female leads have to do again and again)

Three lone women choose to hide themselves and their daughters away from the rest of the world as a means to protect themselves. Who knows what kind of tough situations they had to face and now that we know that the family has a scandalous past I can imagine them trying to block out all the pointing fingers.

Sadly girls do get killed by their parents for associating with boys so it's not even inconceivable although yet again the dark past has made the women in the house hyper sensitive of keeping the girls as free from scandal as they could.
Edited by Mahabhootni - 11 years ago
khamosshhh thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 11 years ago
#12
The revelation of the past kind of made things clear abt the absolute paranoid reaction of the ammis, though I don't condone it. And ironically the past is much worse than anything that either of the girls could have done.
And it just shows the glaring hypocrisy of the elders and their jhoothi shaan.
thegameison thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 11 years ago
#13

Originally posted by: khamosshhh



Yeah there has been a WU thread for every episode aired and we discuss the show there and I suppose after ZGH, dis is d only show tht is being discussed. 😆

That's actually er, surprising. The form is so extremely dull. 🤔

IMO she lacks the desired expressions to pull off a challenging scene. Anyways she's doing good as Nazia.😳

I agree with you, she's not a very emotive actress. She wants you to kill her, she's pouting; she's happy, she's pouting. It gets repetitive. 😛

Yeah it's beyond me how such vague concepts like family honor is way above the being of a human, girl and more so a daughter! And Shazia sums it up well when she says that 'hamari ammiyon ke dil nahin, sirf naak hai.' Bang on!

Yes, she has like the wittiest dialogues in here. 😃

But I was glad that the ammis had doubt abt Shazia's rishta after encountering the obnoxious, patronizing, self-righteous father of Moiz. Now only if Nazia would hv told Shazia and all the ammis the disgusting pass made by Moiz, then I suppose tht wld hv been an end to the rishta! But dey couldn't hv had tht coz dey need to move the story forward.😉😆

I am not sure Nazia did any good to Shazia by keeping quiet, Moiz is bad. 😳


thegameison thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 11 years ago
#14

Originally posted by: Mahabhootni

The show is pretty regressive but I feel like even that is within the scope of the characters rather than regressive for the sake of being regressive or even worse, regressive faked as progressive. (An example is the abusive male leads all the girls are dying after or the agni pariksha modern, educated female leads have to do again and again)


Three lone women choose to hide themselves and their daughters away from the rest of the world as a means to protect themselves. Who knows what kind of tough situations they had to face and now that we know that the family has a scandalous past I can imagine them trying to block out all the pointing fingers.

Sadly girls do get killed by their parents for associating with boys so it's not even inconceivable although yet again the dark past has made the women in the house hyper sensitive of keeping the girls as free from scandal as they could.



The scandal can explain Phuphi Ammi and Salima's reaction, not Sajida's. She doesn't know how and why Nazia and Shazia's respective fathers died. 🤔 Otherwise, sure, you've got excellent points there, regressive sucks, in every garb. But good narrations and performances make it tolerable. 😛
thegameison thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 11 years ago
#15

Originally posted by: khamosshhh

The revelation of the past kind of made things clear abt the absolute paranoid reaction of the ammis, though I don't condone it. And ironically the past is much worse than anything that either of the girls could have done.

And it just shows the glaring hypocrisy of the elders and their jhoothi shaan.



I agree with you and I agree with you so much. 😳

Shabaaz, an independent and well earning man seemed unworthy of Shazia to her mother while she had eloped and married an unemployed man. Fine, she didn't know he wasn't her definition of 'rich', but she did elope. And post that, she did something even modern women would scowl at, let alone the ones shown in the show. 🐷

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".