642126 thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#1
A mystery and suspense show is close to becoming a saas bahu show. Boardroom, courtroom drama and intense power play was trashed to make way for foolish lapses, rona dhona, exchange of sadakchaap dhamkis or pointless flashbacks.
Is this show indeed finite and scripted till the end? This doesn't look like the watertight screenplay promised earlier.

Is this mess due to TRP aunties?

But then how can public be the reason when same public accepted films like NOKJ, Kahaani and Mardaani? Same public made Khoon bhari maang blockbuster in 80s?

What's this show trying to do? Dayal lost edge. Durga lost it. Dev is positive but unbelievably foolish. Shaurya is a joke with nothing except bed and booze on his mind. Rajnath behaves foolishly.

Does anything make sense? Shaurya's friends are still spared despite them being rapists too. Payal is back to square one. Past flashbacks have no context.

Loose ends remain like that old mystery man, Mathur swearing revenge on Goenkas, Akash, Karan's minister dad, RajMa affair etc. We keep waiting for things to fall in picture but nothing happens.

Why is marriage needed? Was it original plan or inserted now for TRP aunties? Don't tell me a rapist should be served even as a drama.

Why is Durga sitting on recordings? Why not use the audio and video proof she has?

Is it your lack of creativity or real public demand that show has become so shaky and directionless?

Created

Last reply

Replies

13

Views

3.3k

Users

11

Likes

76

Frequent Posters

cherrypansy thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#2
Agree with you...there was so much to show...but cv's followed the usual saas-bahu drama. TBH, I have lost all interest, just reading the updates and following the forum discussion.
dey.bh thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#3
I cannot believe that this was the original idea. Sorry, I refuse to take the argument.
1. I never understood how Nitya had more grievance for Dev than the other three rapists. How come Shaurya is her only target. Now, its no more Shaurya also, its Sakshi alone who is her target because Sakshi is after all the mastermind. This way revenge angle is understood, where is justice here?


2. I always maintained that DEv was a forced entry. I have been told that the story had some option for a 'good' Goenka. Fair enough but it definitely was not of Nitya's childhood friend cum boyfriend. He always looked misfit in the story. His background is obscure too. May be they had planned one Goenka who slowly learns about Goenka's dirty secrets and try to unmask them. This man is completely clueless. On what basis he is expecting to meet Nitya one day is something I never understood.

3. Shaurya, Sakshi and Rajnath were strong characters. Suddenly, there are some changes in these characters. Rajnath looks completely disconnected to his family They planned so much before.The whole rape case was covered so conveniently and now they fail to relate Payal- Durga to the downfall of Mathur, Ganguly , commisioner and the Pandit sounds somewhat ridiculous. All of a sudden Bagchi, the witness of the rape case turns up and yes Ms. Thakur is to be blamed. Ms. Thakur also manages to get hold of Payal, the victim. I wonder how Rajnath is so casual about it.


4. Sakshi's past reveal. what was that for ? Neither did it helped Durga to find those'dogs' whose food Sakshi must have snatched all her life to become Mrs.. Goenka nor did it helped the audience to understand what made her Mrs. Goenka after all. It was another Dev- Nitya friendship and love, no thats highly unlikely. They have just closed the chapter.

5. Who is Akash ? What is his story ? Why are they playing ringa ringa roses with this character ? His character can bring another dimension in the story but these days he hardly appears.

6. Loopholes, loopholes and loopholes. We have discussed Dev's defectiveness all the way, last night's Durga's visit to her old house was just a stupid step to do. What was she expecting ? Sakshi will just give up the idea to defeat her that too now when she sensed danger for Shaurya?

7. Nitya never loved Dev isn't it ? Not even then when her life was full of happiness. Now when her objective is reinstating the honour of her sister and her family, how did she fall for Dev? Sorry, Nitya and Dev's flashbacks are like the makers are forcing us to see them as a couple. A driver's daughter and the Master's son are sharing chuddy- buddy relation and no one ever objected. Which part of the world does this 'Kolkata' belong ? Its definitely not one I know.

8. Initially Durga had a concrete plan for each of her enemies. Now things are just happening. The way Pandit was brought to justice wasn't really impressive. It was not a planned acttion. More than Durga, Sakshi is herself responsible for this.

9.Having brought Kangana in the story and showing her affair with a rapist what does the makers intend to do.I expected it to some concrete effect on the revenge plan. One showpiece material she is who has only two thngs to do, One making calls to say " Love you" and other showing how excited she is for her brother's marriage. She was a spoilt brat too.What happened to that idea?

10. Dayal. Wasn't he helping Durga to make plans. Why premature retirement?🥱 Beti ka bojh itna bhari tha kya ?

And then there are many more points which make me believe this defintiely wasn't the script. It is definitely not going to end in a year. If they manage to get one extension so we we will ringa ringa roses again or else it will be some rush rush story to meet the end. Either way, we lose the show.




Edited by dey.bh - 11 years ago
Rocky.Bhai thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 11 years ago
#4
Can't blame the creative team also.. They are working for star plus..
Trp's is what they bother about. If a show is getting low trp then it channel will pressurise for more trp's or to close the show... So can't blame anyone..
dey.bh thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#5
Someone has to take the responsibility. There is no quality left in Indian television show. Only shooting overseas and spending millions for lavishing sets and songs cannot be counted as a brilliant venture. What lacks is the creativity. Besides, this whole TRP system needs to be thrown in the dustbin. Its not really a reliable instrument to calculate any aspect of a show yet it plays the deciding role. Research has shown how easily TRPs are manipulated in the telly world.
642126 thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#6
Few tam meters on a couple of tv sets in few metros can't indicate what nation is watching.
Trp system is bull!

And you can't change story just to please public! If public had it their way then Karna would have been alive in MB!
ViTharvforever thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#7
Lol dev has oly questions n no answers kyu laktahe?kyu mujhe laktahe?he doesnt know ne otherr words...n durga he openly feels guilty infront of dev...n gives challenging luks to sakshi...😆
Colt.Pixy thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Trailblazer Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 11 years ago
#8
I think channel is forcing some shows to change story line . Other 2 shows also getting changed in weird way. Dunno what is going on frm few weeks m watching feeling like m seeing different shows .
princess.noor thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#9
Why are TRPs so low? If they are this low right now then what will happen after the wedding when most of us will lose interest :( I love this show but I don't think I'll be watching it after the wedding :(
Colt.Pixy thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Trailblazer Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 11 years ago
#10
all sp has drop of trps very badly .

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".