Why is Shrestha Not Called Again? - Page 4

Originally posted by: Mia1love

i think the Main reason she was not called bak was she is not from Hit it gharana..
they mostly called ppl singer for their own gharana..

NOT true....desh gaurav is from ID gharana

its really b/c of politics they didnt call her back😡

they called bak 3 from their gharana.. and one from yalgar and 2 from josh ..
but the majority still is hit it ..

Only if our openion counts on any of the injustice
that has been done to few contestants in this contest,
that would be great !! Only if the judge had enough
sense to kick out Mauli & announce Shreshta as the
winner in the first place!! I don't think this show
is about finding a great singer, first everyone needs
to forget the first song Mauli sang & see beyond that
point, only then we will find a real winner of this contest. I mean even Mauli told the judge that u r wrong
Shreshta sang better then me & the best part was when
Shreshta demanded to know the reason, "why u did not select me? " I would give anything to find out what contacts Mauli has thats keeping her in the contest,
it is insulting to other winners as long as she stays.
I feel terrible for all those deserving contestants who has been kicked out when all Mauli has to do is show up on the stage. 😭 😕

Originally posted by: liquidice

NOT true....desh gaurav is from ID gharana

its really b/c of politics they didnt call her back😡

ID was given the freedom to call back any one of the ousted from his gharana. He chose to bring back Desh Gaurav.

Originally posted by: day dreamer

Only if our openion counts on any of the injustice
that has been done to few contestants in this contest,
that would be great !! Only if the judge had enough
sense to kick out Mauli & announce Shreshta as the
winner in the first place!! I don't think this show
is about finding a great singer, first everyone needs
to forget the first song Mauli sang & see beyond that
point, only then we will find a real winner of this contest. I mean even Mauli told the judge that u r wrong
Shreshta sang better then me & the best part was when
Shreshta demanded to know the reason, "why u did not select me? " I would give anything to find out what contacts Mauli has thats keeping her in the contest,
it is insulting to other winners as long as she stays.
I feel terrible for all those deserving contestants who has been kicked out when all Mauli has to do is show up on the stage. 😭

😕

I couldn't have put it better.👏👏

SRGMP is supposed to be a singing contest. It is Sangeet ka viswayudh, and not personality, charisma, popularity contest.

Some members have commented that it was Shrestha's only performance. What about Mauli? Till date, she has only been a one-song wonder. She frequently goes out of sur, and high notes are not soothing at all...it is shouting, not singing.

The rest of the contestants have already lost the battle. You are right...all she has to do now is to appear on stage, and she is chosen....if she sings the first song bad, she will be given a second chance to sing....if that is bad, guess what?....she will be given a third chance to sing, and would be asked to sing "maiya maiya"!!! The contest has now been reduced to a farce.

Originally posted by: amarendu

I couldn't have put it better.👏👏

SRGMP is supposed to be a singing contest. It is Sangeet ka viswayudh, and not personality, charisma, popularity contest.

Some members have commented that it was Shrestha's only performance. What about Mauli? Till date, she has only been a one-song wonder. She frequently goes out of sur, and high notes are not soothing at all...it is shouting, not singing.

The rest of the contestants have already lost the battle. You are right...all she has to do now is to appear on stage, and she is chosen....if she sings the first song bad, she will be given a second chance to sing....if that is bad, guess what?....she will be given a third chance to sing, and would be asked to sing "maiya maiya"!!! The contest has now been reduced to a farce.

Actually i have stopped considering these singing shows as contests . It can be best referred to as a show.

For it to be considered a contest, rules must be clear and everybody subjected to rules(both judges and contestants) and this rules must be published and made available.

I think shrestha was much better than mouli. Mouli can sing only certain type of song, but shrestha has different tonal quality. Music industry could have use her. N I was surprise of judges comments. When yalgar ho said he was about to dance when shrestha was singing, but bappida said he didn't find nything good in tat. VS made a big mistake tat faint gal is good but hav limitation. Shrestha could be better singer than her. I m upset. this is destruction of future music industry. In future people will fed-up with monotones sound as maximum singer now have al most same type of voice

Don't worry guys.
Once people star voting, things may fall in place .. cos the judges may not have heard it, but people have heard maiya maiya more than t'was necessary to hear 😆

Originally posted by: amarendu

I couldn't have put it better.👏👏

SRGMP is supposed to be a singing contest. It is Sangeet ka viswayudh, and not personality, charisma, popularity contest.

Some members have commented that it was Shrestha's only performance. What about Mauli? Till date, she has only been a one-song wonder. She frequently goes out of sur, and high notes are not soothing at all...it is shouting, not singing.

The rest of the contestants have already lost the battle. You are right...all she has to do now is to appear on stage, and she is chosen....if she sings the first song bad, she will be given a second chance to sing....if that is bad, guess what?....she will be given a third chance to sing, and would be asked to sing "maiya maiya"!!! The contest has now been reduced to a farce.

U make me laugh