An (AsYa AND SaHil) Writer's Rant

Tamara27 thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 11 years ago
#1

I am quite upset reading all of these comments on various threads where writers who previously wrote on AsYa are now writing on SaHil. I know I am probably opening up a can of worms here, but it feels like this is getting slightly out of hand.

I would just like to, for one minute (and a few lines), speak on behalf of Juliet (Perfectionist2) and myself.

I honestly don't see the problem on us writing on SaHil too.

Juliet still has Butterflies going on, and Wallbanger. I am still writing In Love and War - those are all AsYa stories.

Unlike Juliet, who has only been watching bits and pieces of QH2 - and that too, only because I nag her to... I am completely invested in QH2, and I don't see a problem in it. For me personally, the story of AsYa is still incomplete and I will watch until their daughter gets them justice.

The fact that I like Sanam and Aahil is an aside.

I have written so much on AsYa and will continue doing so if the negativity of the forum ceases. Unfortunately, I'm not sure when/ if that will happen.

What is most disappointing to me through all of this is, that as a writer, when I first started writing here on the forum... I received so much love and support from readers. (I still do, too so not many complaints for all the love)

Especially praising "the writing". Now it has become clear that except a few loyal readers, most won't read for the writing and imagination, but rather for who the story is based on.

Nevermind, I say. Because Juliet and I do have those loyal readers that are reading everything we write, regardless of who the story is based on.

Now I speak on my behalf. This virtual world has brought me into contact with the most amazing bunches of girls. I say "bunches" because the forum seems to be split into two camps these days, which is sad in and of itself.

Me? I'm Switzerland. I love everyone equally.

I absolutely love my readers... both AsYa and SaHil, and I will continue writing for them.

I get the whole "I feel betrayed" by QH1. I really do. I felt betrayed too and honestly, I didn't watch much after KSG left. I didn't even watch the beginning of QH2 but now I am invested in the show, and I am seriously taken by it.

No one is cheating on AsYa. And I won't be bullied into not writing on SaHil.

We love our readers (That's you. And you and you and you out there)

Please don't break our hearts by saying things like... "You've moved over to the dark side"; "You've forgotten AsYa"; "I love everything you write, but I can't stand SaHil"

At the end of the day... this is television, people. I am married with a kid and I deal with real issues on a daily basis.

This forum brings me happiness and entertainment and I write for the love of writing and because I love AsYa and SaHil. I don't want issues and negativity in my happy virtual world. I have enough to deal with in my actual life.

My bottom line is, read if you want to. Don't read if you don't want to.

It's great when we get feedback, honestly, it is, but the negativity not based on our actual writing is hard for us to deal with.

Especially after we've spent hours thinking up stories, typing them out, perfecting them, and PM'ing over two hundred buddies.

I am not questioning readers' loyalty here... I am saying, cut the writers some slack too.

Created

Last reply

Replies

14

Views

2.3k

Users

12

Likes

70

Frequent Posters

farz_parachute thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 11 years ago
#2
Hear hear sistah!


It's horrible reading comments that not only single writers out...worst is when writers are stopped from writing stories that they want on characters they want to!


I'm gravely offended by such comments and remarks! For if writing for SaHil is akin to turning to the dark side...then I'm a hypocritical two faced reader.


Coz I read everything. With good writing. And an even better story and concept.


And to accuse writers of betraying certain characters only because they write on others, is not only rude, but very off putting especially by readers like myself. Writers choose to stop writing because of such condescending comments that is so very disheartening! And we readers have to suffer the brunt too.


Some goes as far as to say that we're not loyal and true fans of AsYa just because we also read stuff in SaHil. What even.


If writers love both AsYa AND SaHil...okay maybe love is a strong word...but if they write on both then why question this?

It's like questioning their capability of loving.


Suddenly these writers are not loyal. No more Jedis. No more Dumbdledore's Army.

Anyway. Team Loki rocks too.



Love to all writers and readers.



FaRz


Edited by farz_parachute - 11 years ago
Perfectionist2 thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 11 years ago
#3
😃 res OH MY FIRE BRAND!
YOU MADE A POST!👍🏼
unRes!
Tamara 🤗
You said it all Sister. Yes you coerced me into watching that show QH2. Well You and Faru did. FARU you are also to blame for this madness.
Yes I have had my criticism and restraint initially. But I am loving it as of today. I am loving SaHil and it is how I had initially loved AsYa.
And I love what you said Tamara - the story of AsYa is still incomplete and I will watch until their daughter gets them justice.👏 I never considered on those lines.
AsYa will always hold a special place for me. I began writing what ever nonsense for them.
I will still continue writing for Asad.
But I will also write for SaHil. I hate disappointing my AsYa readers. Especially when they think my priorities have changed. But believe me my lovely readers I feel the love. I feel wanted. And I am honored that my readers with go to any lengths or blackmail and threat in a very cute way.
I have to mention I am greedy for love and please don't make me choose. I write for my readers and I am loving my SaHil readers too. I have always had this personal bond with so many of my AsYa readers.
Believe Me People when I say this Loud and Clear - Juliet has some stamina. Juliet can do Asad and Aahil all night taking turns.
I never exhaust. Well mostly I don't.
So don't make me choose, Enjoy the stories for what they are meant to be. And let me have the down time that I seek after a hard long day.😃
Loads Of Love.
Juliet!
Edited by Perfectionist2 - 11 years ago
Tamara27 thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 11 years ago
#4

Originally posted by: Perfectionist2

😃 res OH MY FIRE BRAND!

YOU MADE A POST!👍🏼
unRes!
Tamara 🤗
You said it all Sister. Yes you coerced me into watching that show QH2. Well You and Faru did. FARU you are also to blame for this madness.
Yes I have had my criticism and restraint initially. But I am loving it as of today. I am loving SaHil and it is how I had initially loved AsYa.
And I love what you said Tamara - the story of AsYa is still incomplete and I will watch until their daughter gets them justice.👏 I never considered on those lines.
AsYa will always hold a special place for me. I began writing what ever nonsense for them.
I will still continue writing for Asad.
But I will also write for SaHil. I hate disappointing my AsYa readers. Especially when they think my priorities have changed. But believe me my lovely readers I feel the love. I feel wanted. And I am honored that my readers with go to any lengths or blackmail and threat in a very cute way.
I have to mention I am greedy for love and please don't make me choose. I write for my readers and I am loving my SaHil readers too. I have always had this personal bond with so many of my AsYa readers.
Believe Me People when I say this Loud and Clear - Juliet has some stamina. Juliet can do Asad and Aahil all night taking turns.
I never exhaust. Well mostly I don't.
So don't make me choose, Enjoy the stories for what they are meant to be. And let me have the down time that I seek after a hard long day.😃
Loads Of Love.
Juliet!


Well said! Of course we don't want to disappoint anyone... but it's true that we also can't please everyone all the time.

Except well... Asad and Aahil.
We can both take turns and then send them home in wheelchairs 🤣

Ok, the whole AsYa thing. I really believe their story is incomplete.
Sanam (and Aahil) are going to complete it and give us the closure we need. I truly believe that.

I'm all in, sistah!

Stay strong!
jasminerose thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#5
Brilliant post Tamara.
I agree with you completely.😃

And yeah Asya getting justice through their daughter, that's a new angle and I really like it.👏

And I as I said on Juliet's thread characters will change, shows will change but your talent can never be restrained.

So Keep writing always as long as u can and u wish.
And yeah we keep aside what you think of Aahil for now.😆

lots of Love🤗
964749 thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#6
Word to your post. Can I just add that I absolutely cannot stand the resentment a few QH1 viewers have for QH2 in this forum. I mean it's totally fine for someone to dislike QH2, but why do they have to constantly bring down actors and characters from QH2 in their posts because of their love and loyalty to QH1?

I like both AsYa and SaHil and even before that I was (and still am) an ArHi fan. And during QH1 times, ArHi fans used to resent AsYa. I just never understood the need for this behaviour LOL.

Anyway, I hope your readers understand your outlook on this issue and try to cooperate with you. :)
Edited by .Serendipity. - 11 years ago
marcoe thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#7
I understand what ur going through
But honestly if it's asya or sahil it shudnt matter
I mean I love asya
And m not a really big fan of sahil
But when u wrote the sequel of hopeless I guess which was on sahil
I really loved it
Not once did I regret reading it
It's the stories that keep you addicted honestly
I mean yeahh the characters form the basis
But I mean right now it's sahil cuz of whom the show is back again
They deserve some love too
As long as u promise to keep writing something on asya in d future m happy
I wud suggest u dnt take such things to ur heart
U and juliet r fab writers
And keep doing that
We'll always support u in what ull do
Love,
Marcoe🤗


kals82 thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 11 years ago
#8
awesome post...tamara...
to tell the truth...

i am the culprit behind the whole thing...

i kind of said, commented that she is planning to write on saahil, before giving my butterflies for me...and jumped the ship...

it was just my rant for butterflies...which i love so much...

it kind of picked up... there...in her wall banger thread...


you both are awesome writers...

as jas pointed.. whatever u write... we will read.,...

SurbhikiPankhi thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#9
Great post! <3
Criticizing is another thing but spreading negativity is another one.
Other than that I believe couples matter to the extent that if the story of the fanfiction is following the show but if it isn't then the changing of names shouldn't make a difference 😕

Ps: I've read some of your work! And it's brilliant. 😳
kaussar thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 11 years ago
#10


Tamara

I seriously feel very sad knowing that so much disharmony still exists in this Forum. I thought that most of it has gone now and those days are over.

Although i haven't read all of yours and Juliet's stories ( read two of yours and one of Juliet), i know that you both are brilliant writers and have written so much on AsYa and have entertained AsYa fans so much. So you both should not get these type of comments from those fans.

May be some of them feel that you are ditching AsYa... but Loving another couple and writing on them doesn't mean ditching AsYa..

And another point is we should always learn to respect others choices and tastes as well.

for an example, even i am an ardent AsYa fan, and the character Asad was my favourite character and QH 1 was an inspiration for me, so much so that i have written countless posts on AsYa and episode reviews etc... and now eventhough i am still watching QH 2, and even liking SaAhil, over all QH 2 doesn't inspire me enough to write about it and so far i haven't written anything on it and these days i am channeling my inspiration on AsYa by writing stories on them which i earlier didn't do... i still love AsYa that much... but does it mean i should go on criticizing each and everything about QH 2 or bash writers who are writing on it just because it doesn't inspire me to write about it?

It shouldn't happen that way..they are writing on it because it inspires them.. so even those who are not watching QH2 ,they should also understand that these writers are writing on QH 2 because it inspires them to write on it and we should respect their choices.. and they haven't stopped writing on AsYa so read what they write on AsYa and keep AsYa alive but at the same time let them write on other things as well and let them entertain others as well.

And Tamara these days i love reading your Rants on QH 2 ( as you know i have commented on few of them).. just be happy and continue with your good work .😃

Related Topics

Qubool Hai thumbnail

Posted by: desidillse · 1 years ago

[NOCOPY] Hello everyone! Happy to be here. I was searching for an opportunity to be here with all of you as a member after a long time as writer...

Expand ▼
Qubool Hai thumbnail

Posted by: Coloursoflove · 2 years ago

*New chapter updated* Asya FF: Rendezvous with Honor

Asya FF: Rendezvous with Honor Asad Ahmed Khan is the prodigal son. All the tabloids say so. Coming from an affluent family in Bhopal, he's done...

Expand ▼
Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".