Alisha Should Be Replaced

After watching all the episodes until the Piano round, one thing is now established - Alisha understands liitle about good music.Her ability to judge a singer is governed solely by his/her looks.

Remember, given a chance to name which singers she would like to save - her choice were Hrishita and Suhit, both by far the worst singers in the top 28? Like her singing career, which has only seen her sing easy songs (the MDs know her limited range and vocal limitations), her standard has also been too low...Javed Saab was right in pointing it to her that if looks were the only criterion, then who not make models into singers?

The way she singled out Smita, who is by far the best original voice in II3, indeed spoke volumes about her prejudices, and how little she knows about music (the only 'technical' comment that she can make in the programme is whether the singer is 'flat' or not!). She should be replaced by someone like Kavitaji or Shreya.

M with u remove her she is highly biased which is wrong quality for a judge !

Agree with you preethi. Wonder why did they choose her in the first place. 😡

by only Shifa 😊 😛

PLEASE VOTE FOR EMON!
PLEASE VOTE FOR EMON!
PLEASE VOTE FOR EMON!
(BECAUSE I CAN'T VOTE)

i totally agree. hate alisha 😡

yea she should be replaced
alka yagnik is a good judge but she is now in star voice of india i think
kavita krishnamurthy, anuradha paudwal, sunidhi, or shreya will be good replacements

yepp alisha should be replaced...farah was far better

one example on alisha's recent comment on Emon - when Hussain asked Alisha to give some tips to improve Emon's performance - her dumb dialogues were:

• "well....what can i say"...
• "i guess he should remove his glasses"😕

how does removing glasses help Emon to improve his performance.. poor Emon he did not know how to react while Hussain had a frown on his face..this is just one of the dumb comments...if we keep digging there are more in store...

Alisha ko bhi II contestants ke saath music ke details sikhaane ki zarurat hai 😛 ........aankho se sunne ki bajaaye kaano se music suna jaata hai yeh unko malum nahi hai shayad 😕 ..............no offence 😊

Originally posted by: mcm226

Alisha ko bhi II contestants ke saath music ke details sikhaane ki zarurat hai 😛 ........aankho se sunne ki bajaaye kaano se music suna jaata hai yeh unko malum nahi hai shayad 😕 ..............no offence 😊

Mandy tune sachi sachi baat kahe di re 😛

Alisha simply acts as if she has this huge crush on Suhit, which is ridiculous. If you're given a position of a judge, u should at least try and judge objectively.