Watching an Indian drama is not easy...

shabnammm3 thumbnail
Engager Level 1 Thumbnail Fascinator 2 Thumbnail Fascinator 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#1
It really isn't. It's not as easy as just switching on your TV, turning to the channel and show of your choice and immersing yourself in a beautifully spun, engrossing story.
No, first you need to sacrifice a few things, or at least suspend them for a while:
- Sense
- Logic
- Belief
- Any knowledge or experience of human behaviour
- Expectation of consistency

You know what they say. You can give the best possible ingredients to a cook, but what the cook does with those ingredients is a totally different ball game.

Here, you have a mostly great ensemble cast (barring a few people; Hint: the actress playing the expressionless Mala), an interesting premise, an enticing and intriguing story idea...and what do we get?

We get:

- A cheerful Paro. A girl who has just been through ( a bare few hours earlier) one of possibly the most traumatic experiences one can imagine going through. Someone threw acid at her. Go on. Say the following words aloud. "Someone threw acid at me!" Just saying the words sends a shiver of terror through one. It takes months if not longer to get over an ordeal like that. Yes, I know. That kind of luxury is not available in a daily soap. Fair enough. But some evidence of trauma? Some shock? Maybe terror at sudden noises? Some dread? A nightmare? Something?
But no. Let's have a chirpy giggling female lead instead.
Sensitivity, you say? What's that?

- Out of sight, Out of mind Maithli and Mala. Let's see now. Let me read a letter threatening to do immense harm to someone I love deeply; like a daughter or a sister. Let me show shock and worry for five minutes. Then let me have an attack of amnesia and have a flirty conversation with my husband about my upcoming holiday!
Or better yet, let me make laddoos and thread garlands, while continuing with my pretense along with my daughter-in-law (whose life is under serious threat) to win over my son.
One has to prioritize after all.
Death threats, you say? What's the harm in that? Let's giggle about not breaking fasts instead!

- Taking the horse to the well Mohini. It's easy, you know. All I need to do is not let my son say the words that he's married. After that, all will fall into place. He will never know that he's meeting a girl for the purpose of marriage. The families will finalize the proposal, and then I will somehow trick my son to wear wedding finery on the wedding day and lead him to the mandap and he'll go along with it.
Brainless scheme, you say? Well what do you know? Have you ever tried it!

- Romantic Rudra: Aaah yes. I'll probably find the least amount of takers for this point, I have a feeling :-) Let's see now. Someone threw acid at my wife. Someone made a threatening call to do worse. Someone CAME INTO my room, STOOD next to my wife, and took her doll. I think what I'll do is distract her with a kiss (a fake one at that to add insult to injury!), I'll carry swings in, and decorate them with flowers, then I'll smile at her innuendoes of not having sex for 108 years, then I'll flirt with her a little in a husky voice, then I'll show some irritation at being interrupted by a phone call from work, and then I'll leave reluctantly for work because... well I'm sure Aman can handle finding out who is trying to kill my wife on his own. Oh wait a second... I think I'll leave the task of keeping my wife safe in the hands of my sister in law, who after all is great at ummm let's see... cooking!
Setting up some BSD guards/security around my haveli, you say? How dare you mistrust Maithli's capabilities!

- And now, the piece de resistance: The Cameras! Who would have thought that installing cameras - please note the plural - in the room of the fiercest BSD officer of all would have been so easy! Behind the bed, on top of the wardrobe, on the pillars, outside the bathroom (which is outside the room, so essentially the camera work has been spread out quite diligently, and with great anticipation of human need!). Not inside the loo though...no, no...that would be too cheap!

There's no avoiding it, so I'm just going to say it.
One: Rudra and his family must be some of the dumbest people on this planet if people can come into his room and their house, install multiple cameras at various locations without detection!

Two: How can the CVs insult the audience's intelligence to such an extent as to expect them to swallow with good grace that it is just THAT easy to enter someone's house/room and undertake such a technical, time consuming, and noisy task in a matter of mere minutes possibly?

And in any case, Mr Hegde seems to be running out of ideas at an enviable pace! What is this fascination he has with installing cameras in people's rooms? Freud would have a great time with him!
All I can do in the mean time is shake my head in disappointment. And lower my expectations even more. (I really didn't think that was possible.)
Many of you might say, wait a while. After all RR has given us some great episodes too. And you'd be right. They have given some great scenes and moments. But why should these great episodes be interspersed by such mediocre writing and scripting?
To take an analogy probably close to Rudra's heart, it's like saying, oh so what if you have to eat burnt aloo ki sabzi fifteen days of the month? You might get one tasty meal on the sixteenth day.

It's really not that hard to be consistent, you know. We've seen some good, tight scripting, writing and pacing. Which means that the talent is there. Unfortunately, the intention is weak. Very weak. And respect for the audience, weaker still. Till the time, our show makers keep on treating the audience like brainless entities, we will continue eating burnt aloo sabzi.

And because, after this long rant, I'm feeling quite spent of my ire and irritation, I'll end on a somewhat frivolous note.

What in God's name is wrong with the editor? Did he really just ruthlessly cut out the romantic scenes we had been looking forward to since seeing the behind-the-scenes footage? The kiss, the falling on the bed, and the leaning in and picking up of the garlands? Does he have any idea of what the hard core fans of RR are looking forward to?

As if the director's penchant for blurry shots and ridiculous angles wasn't bad enough!


Created

Last reply

Replies

47

Views

6.3k

Users

29

Likes

325

Frequent Posters

_SilverLining_ thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 11 years ago
#2
U are one angry young woman baisa!!

I understand your qualms.. And I agree that Paro recovered from the shock a little too soon. But I expected that, coz for some strange reason, the writers here are really idiots when it comes to portraying the women's perspective on some matter. They give long episodes on how Rudra cries over a 15yr old trauma but don't care to spare one episode to show Paro's shock from a terrible incident the day before. It has happened before so no surprises there. But this tym I forgive them coz they are really on a tym constraint here. I know they r rushing the track a lil bit but I guess they just need to get to the main track as fast as possible for TRP reasons.

For Rudra and the family members all I can say is they are just playing their parts, they are worried internally but aren't showing it to Paro for obvious reasons.

As for the editing peeps, m still angry at them for changing the part where Rudra wakes up and finds Paro's head has slipped from the pillow and she is lying on his hand and then he carefully puts her backvon the pillow (that's what they showed in the BTS vids) to just taking out his hand from beneath her head that they aired yesterday. I think that would have been way cuter than the simple scene we got instead.

I understand watching an Indian show isn't easy but I don't think I can live without RR either!!And that comes from an avid western show lover 😊

A lil ranting is gud for the health 😆 Hope u will feel better now n be able to enjoy the expected-to-be-awesome epi tomorow...Cheers!!
Edited by _SilverLining_ - 11 years ago
rowan thumbnail
Explorer Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#3
Bang on Post! Seriously viewers are so not dumb and we ain't take shit. Buckle up and ork hard. And Don't forget the worst editors.
princessunara thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Trailblazer Thumbnail + 8
Posted: 11 years ago
#4
lol agree on it and ur anger too!

but i also agree on the forgetting the logic etc etc.. i learned that when I was about 11 yrs old and plastic surgery ruled Indian TV! 😆 polygamy of the craziest kind where after a few yrs of watching u are confused which one is married to which one.. cz they are not triangles or anything simple like that.. more like quintuplets! And kids! god knows who the real parents are, etc etc..

So darling as much as I can understand ur frustration lol. honestly TV has improved a bit more from what I used to have as a staple diet when i was a preteen and a teen.. lol..

anyway one gripe I have always had is the glossing over or the emotions and the shoddy writing of the female perspective! How hard could it be to give us a bit of that too!
I get fed up n throw the towel in once in a while.. but i invariably find myself back here after a bit..

so i guess as maddening as this is, i cannot do without it either! 😆


Deezi thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#5
@ Does he have any idea of what the hard core fans of RR are looking forward to?

see the editor mistakenly thinks hardcore RR fans are TRP aunties ...not us...who can't have enough of PaRud... he might even think after 20june...we should just shut the heck up til a month... 😆

Not me...who fights her hubby for remote during every cricket, football, tennis match...who the hell cares if its the final...my PaRud comes first
Not me...who abruptly ends calls with family and friends with a phoniest 'Someones at the door I'll call you back' as soon as it turns 9:30pm.😆
Or changed the dinner time from 9:30 to 8:30pm...just so i could watch my RR without demands for food or stuff...

Editors Directors, writers...we criticize them when after they've put our expectations high...they bring it crashing down with mediocrity...and RR had done a excellent job in putting our expectations up there on the top in the earlier epis...so this downward spiral is very painful...hope they pull up soon...

a sincere advice...don't look for sense, logic, consistency in an hindi show...it'll keep you healthy.😃

p.s. is this your first hindi show?

Edited by DoJin - 11 years ago
CyberOstrich thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#6
Thanks a lot Shabnamm for putting down your thoughts! And as you said- even if you have set your expectations low...really really low...even then it grates!
You know - with very limited desi soap watching experience that I have- what they showed today actually happens- when they are at the fag end- they are clueless what to show- but somehow they have to scrape through last few moments/months? They start missing out on the characterizations they have taken so many pains in the initial months to establish! Rudra is the latest in line to loose the basic ingredients of his characterisation- as you mentioned- no anxiety, no gussa , no simmering tension inside him that an intruder has actually managed to invade his bedroom and get THIS close to Paro?!! Thats not pardonable for me at least! And now hes shown to have inner monologues like- oh my biwi is looking for her doll- I have to distract her! Just doesn't fit him- NOT the romantic overture- but that speaking aloud of his thought in his mind!

Paro and Mala- I have given up on them totally! Especially the conspirational 'giggles and smiles' at each other abt how SMART they are being and foxing Rudra with their behaviour- How juvenile Rudra banna is still being- muh phulaoing and not complying till now! I have forwarded each and every scene of Mala for past few days- I really cant stand her wooden face and sonoric voice!

And the new track now- the hidden cameras- yes its so easy na- to infiltrate an army officers house and put all this paraphenalia in a jiffy?! And the new tracks are now seeming even more ominous as they are coming at the cost of editing out Rudra-Paro scenes?!! How can they expect people not to be turned off by this?

Edit- whats with that darawana music when rudra is about to feed laddoo to Paro??? YES- IT was Blasphemy- with a capital B- I get it dear BG guy! Feeding a laddoo to a Sati Savitri devout Patni- keeping a fast- is almost as close to murdering someone!
Edited by CyberOstrich - 11 years ago
hanan72 thumbnail
Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#7
👏your rant is logical
but we speak of Indian drama, and if you start counting the bullshit ...the list is long
1st time I was captivated by the story and characters of the serial
Now I just look for plaisire without thinking because I love the couple glammoure, So I don't try to understand the logic becaufe it n 'there is no consistency in the events.
So each episode you must take a bite of "amnesia" of the past and to rejoice of spectacle stupidly. 😉
SherryGS thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 11 years ago
#8
An entirely sensible post! Nothing else to be said.
⭐️
Mogwai thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#9
What in God's name is wrong with the editor? Did he really just ruthlessly cut out the romantic scenes we had been looking forward to since seeing the behind-the-scenes footage? The kiss, the falling on the bed, and the leaning in and picking up of the garlands? Does he have any idea of what the hard core fans of RR are looking forward to?
I am majorly pissed off about the editing...the editing of the BEST bits! This is a criminal act, lol. I can forgive them for everything else...for anything inconsistent but THIS?!!! I cannot forgive. The hardcore PaRudholic, the hopeless romantic within me is fuming right now.
You cannot, I repeat CANNOT edit out the romance! 😳
Bujee09 thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 11 years ago
#10
BANG ON post ...anyone sensible wil have to agree on all your points.
Fact is that we shouldnt do any reality check on the fiction shows...just watch it for whomsoever your favorite: be it the lead pair their chemistry the haveli decor the BG guy torture or vamp's mausam bigadnewala dialogues... this should have been the expectation from audience for any daily soap and RR is no exception NOWADAYS ...the way RR started off and got us glued was remarkable(their Jan/Feb episodes was way too much attractive to me from what i have seen in any other daily soap across languages) but from the time they had this laddu iron poison drama, coma attack then its recovery , laila track, then kidnap track from tejawat and last the most awaited maasa track, 15 years betraal story i seriously felt RR has NOW forced all its viewers to lower their expectations and run back into square one f usual soap drama...

I also had few hopes on this EK villian track but today with cameras around the house at multiple places ...taken a back !! But still not sure why am addicted to watch Parud every day 😆

Not to forget few more incidents where RR viewers r expected to just grin our teeth :

1. Paro chanting Mala's name everytme Rudra expresses his love interest and distracts him ...
2. Hw protective the haveli is where 2 of its brave men work for BSD one as major ...ahem ahem
3. When Parud did not have a single room to sleep and had to manage in the haveli angaan where on earth this EK VILLIAN was safely hiding the whole night in haveli to steal the doll hide the cameras and reside

I cant really believe the CVs are running out of ideas having seen Janaki's work some of GH storylines ...still clinging on with HOPES tht RR would get back on its intense track of portraying angry Rudra/ scared but asensible Paro on this new track..Fingers crossed!!

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".